Do you have “links to nowhere”?

By Tim WindsorMarch 31, 2009  /  8:27 a.m.  

A quick thought that can’t fit into 140 characters, but isn’t quite a full blog post: Just because your online news story has words with blue underlines, that doesn’t mean you’re linking.

I was reminded of this by my local paper’s online edition which — at least a little unintentional irony — today features a story on how journalism students are learning the new digital tools of the trade. Amid a sea of robolinks — automatically generated links to so-called Topic Pages (SEO-bait, really) — I noticed this:

johnharrisstrok

Of course they’re not really tracking John Harris editor of the excellent Politico. The Chicago-centric publishing system used by The Sun is tracking John Harris, former chief-of-staff for former Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich. It’s a seemingly small error, but when more relevant terms in the article aren’t linked, it chips subtly but surely away at credibility with readers, especially digital natives, conversant in the language of linking.

Local newspapers can’t automate their way to success. Linking matters, and it takes humans.

This entry was written by Tim Windsor, posted on March 31, 2009 at 8:27 am, and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback.


3 comments:

  1. nicole at 6:23 am, April 1, 2009

    That’s the problem with robo-linking (there are so many sites where, for instance, a company name is links to a tag that gives you further stories from the same site about the company, assuming you know who they are and that’s what you want) and in some cases humble blogs are much better, because the person who writes is the same one who links. And if something gets messed up — can fix it, pronto…

     
  2. s at 4:34 pm, April 1, 2009

    Took me a minute to get why the Baltimore Sun would be Chicago-centric. Then I remembered the Tribune parent company is still around and apparently still has a sense of humor on April Fools’ Day: http://www.tribune.com/

     

Trackbacks:

  1. David Carr: The reckoning is at hand for free content » Nieman Journalism Lab at 7:12 am, April 13, 2009

    [...] NYT’s online publishing system, however, has supplied six nearly meaningless robolinks to topics it has found in its database. Is this the kind of “search-friendly landing [...]

     

Leave a comment

Check out these related posts