Complicating the network: The year in social media research
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Oct. 28, 2009, 11 a.m.

Geanne Rosenberg: Protections for journalists shouldn’t just apply to the ones collecting paychecks

[Our friend Geanne Rosenberg is both a journalist and a lawyer, so she’s well positioned to analyze the ongoing legal controversy surrounding student journalists at Northwestern. Geanne is founding chair of the Department of Journalism and the Writing Professions at CUNY’s Baruch College in New York. —Ed.]

Northwestern University Journalism Professor David Protess is accomplishing what many journalism schools and departments are increasingly seeking to accomplish: educating students through the actual creation of high quality news information that’s in the public interest. That’s good for the students, good for the educational institution, and good for society.

But the state of Illinois is sabotaging Northwestern’s noble efforts and delivering a chilling message to journalism schools and programs around the country.

In a widely reported controversy, Illinois prosecutors responded to a Protess-led, university-based journalistic investigation of a 31-year-old murder conviction with subpoenas seeking “virtually every conceivable record” relating to the school’s newsgathering activities, including records of interviews, the professor’s communications with student journalists, receipts and records regarding expenses, class syllabi, grading criteria and student grades, according to a motion by Northwestern and its affiliates seeking a protective order quashing the subpoenas.

The subpoenas have led to questions about whether Illinois’ shield law extends to student journalists and, more broadly, raise questions about legal protections and risks for amateur and unaffiliated journalists and for journalism educators and educational institutions. These questions are becoming more important with the growing impact and value of student and amateur journalism.

“The state’s attorney’s zeal seems punitive,” says media lawyer Samuel Fifer, a partner at Sonnenschein Nath & Rosenthal LLP and an adjunct professor at Northwestern’s law school. He called the subpoenas “a ridiculous effort in light of the benefit to ordinary citizens” of the important information being reported through the school project.

Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office spokesperson Andrew Conklin, when asked about the concern that the subpoenas may have a chilling effect on college and university-based journalism and whether State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez is considering withdrawing the subpoenas in light of the criticism, declined to comment and referred to the state’s attorney’s response to the motion to quash the subpoenas.

Deciding who is a journalist

For Northwestern’s Medill School of Journalism Dean John Lavine, the battle over the subpoenas is “time consuming and it’s burdensome and it shouldn’t happen.” Still, he adds, “If this kind of challenge and these kinds of precedents are going to be raised, I think Medill is the place that ought to take them on. It’s part of what we teach. It’s part of what we live. But we do it first not for journalism. The reason is the criminal court system is fundamental in this society. We are all citizens. The importance of ensuring that all journalists can cover the courts so the public can really know what’s going on is just the backbone of the country.” Lavine characterized as “scary” the notion that prosecutors could seek to decide who is or isn’t a journalist and go after those who produce factual information uncovering a convict’s innocence because it could “frighten people off from bringing forward facts.”

In general, beyond Northwestern’s current situation, subpoenas directed at newsrooms and college or university-based journalism can damage journalistic efforts and enterprises. First, according to Lucy Dalglish, executive director of the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, they can “jeopardize your ability to be perceived as an independent gatherer of information when you turn [the results of reporting over] to a government agency” and that “may make sources less willing to come forward” resulting in less access for the public to truthful information. Second, according to Dalglish, dealing with subpoenas can be an enormous “financial and time drain.”

These risks and burdens can be heightened for those practicing journalism outside of professional news organizations who may not have the legal resources that professional newsrooms frequently employ. Yet, the public is increasingly relying upon these alternative news sources for information on matters of public concern.

The place of student journalists

To be sure, Northwestern students have been producing professional quality, published news information for decades. But, beyond Northwestern, nationally speaking, with the decline of mainstream media, the implosion of news media business models and the decimation of well-established, highly trained professional newsroom teams around the country, there’s an expanding vacuum in high-quality, independently reported-out news information. In tandem is an accompanying risk that government institutions and officials, whether at the local, state or federal level, will operate without adequate scrutiny, outside of the view of the public.

“You ignore college journalism or university-based journalism at our peril as far as I’m concerned,” says Dalglish.

As more journalism schools and programs more vigorously pursue and publish news information, as they grow stronger to help compensate for declines in the news industry, as undergraduate schools train not only those seeking to embark upon careers in the news media but also a much broader student population to be critical consumers of news information and capable contributors to the news content that’s out there, and as more and more of this student work morphs from class assignments that traditionally were quietly graded and seldom published to content available globally via the Internet, they will likely need some of the same kinds of legal training and resources that newsrooms have come to require.

They should consider basic training in legal parameters, lawyers either on staff or on call to answer questions and vet stories, effective correction and retraction policies and procedures, media liability insurance, mechanisms for transparency and accountability, and access to lawyers or legal teams that can help fend off subpoenas and defend against libel and other claims. At the same time, the schools can benefit from legal resources to help them gain access to government records and meetings.

But they’ll need more than that, as Northwestern’s subpoena situation highlights. They’ll need a legal system that provides protections that have become increasingly necessary to the practice of journalism.

For starters, they’ll need shield laws that clearly extend to those acting as journalists and performing journalistic functions, whether or not those practitioners of journalism are on news staffs or compensated for their reporting activities.

POSTED     Oct. 28, 2009, 11 a.m.
Show comments  
Show tags
Join the 15,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
Complicating the network: The year in social media research
Journalist’s Resource sifts through the academic journals so you don’t have to. Here are 12 of the studies about social and digital media they found most interesting in 2014.
News in a remix-focused culture
“We have to stop thinking about how to leverage whatever hot social platform is making headlines and instead spend time understanding how communication is changing.”
Los Angeles is the content future
“Creative content people are frustrated with the industry and creating their content on their own terms. Sound familiar?”
What to read next
Complicating the network: The year in social media research
Journalist’s Resource sifts through the academic journals so you don’t have to. Here are 12 of the studies about social and digital media they found most interesting in 2014.
339Finance media’s hottest club is Ello
Business reporters flocking to the platform won’t radically change journalism, but it’s worth asking why users gather where they do.
305Why Google is taking another shot at helping readers pay for news
Google Contributor is the latest tool the company has designed to help readers pay for what they read online. But its previous experiments in supporting paid content have had limited success.
These stories are our most popular on Twitter over the past 30 days.
See all our most recent pieces ➚
Encyclo is our encyclopedia of the future of news, chronicling the key players in journalism’s evolution.
Here are a few of the entries you’ll find in Encyclo.   Get the full Encyclo ➚
The Tyee
Charlottesville Tomorrow
The Daily
Austin American-Statesman
The UpTake
New West
Poynter Institute