In the (future of) news this week: Facebook, The New York Times, GigaOM, Hasselhoff? nie.mn/yrRbkW
SHARE
Nieman Journalism Lab
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

When a journalism gig is paid for by outsiders

In the sea of good pieces last week about the Dave Weigel imbroglio, his own explanation of events stood out. And there was one paragraph that particularly interested me:

In 2004, when I was graduating [from Northwestern's Medill School of Journalism], I was offered two jobs — an editing role at the libertarian magazine Liberty and a fellowship at USA Today, sponsored by the conservative Collegiate Network. I chose the USA Today job, but kept freelancing, mostly for magazines like The American Spectator and Reason.

I was familiar with the Collegiate Network from my own college days; it funded a conservative publication on campus, and that’s what I thought the extent of their work was. But I didn’t realize that it also pays for journalists to work at mainstream news organizations. So I contacted USA Today and got this reply from spokesperson Elga Maye:

We’ve had Collegiate Network interns — including Weigel — working with the paper’s editorial board for several years. They participate in board discussions, their primary daily duty is fact-checking, and their work (like that of all interns) is closely supervised. Toward the end of their internships, some have written editorials reflecting the board’s consensus or, less frequently, bylined op-ed pieces reflecting their own point of view. Their value to us — apart from their labor — is to add another voice, young and conservative, to the diversity of perspectives we already have on an ideologically mixed editorial board.

In that context, the fact that they have a strong point of view — their own, not the Collegiate Network’s — is an asset. We’d gladly take a qualified intern from a liberal organization on the same terms if we were aware of such a program.

The Collegiate Network describes these jobs as year-long fellowships, with stipends of $24,000 to $30,000 paid by CN, and along with USA Today lists Roll Call among outlets where it’s placed journalists. Their Wikipedia page also lists a wide variety of conservative publications and outlets, but also US News & World Report. The application form also lists the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, the News & Observer, the San Diego Union-Tribune, and my old paper The Dallas Morning News — although that form doesn’t differentiate between summer internships and the year-long fellowships. And based on this post, fellows aren’t just on the editorial board — they’re also writing news stories.

We normally don’t write about issues of media bias here — we leave that to the 10 million other people out there who write about media bias — so I didn’t pursue this any further. Go make your own calls! But given what some journalists have argued recently about the proper role of ideology and opinion in a newsroom — which is to say, no role — it’s an interesting data point that a political group is paying the salaries behind some of the bylines you see.

                                   
What to read next
npr-local-story-engagement-good-good
Eric Athas and Keith Hopper    February 10, 2012
When NPR shared links to KPLU stories on its Facebook page — only visible to people in the Seattle area — the station’s website got record traffic.
  • http://embargowatch.wordpress.com Ivan Oransky

    There are at least two of these in science and health journalism:

    The AAAS Mass Media Fellowship http://bit.ly/9DJmik (I was offered this after college, but they required an orientation scheduled for the same day as my commencement, so I had to decline)

    The Kaiser Media Internships in Health Reporting http://bit.ly/3RBjwa (Reuters typically has one each summer)

    Ivan Oransky, MD
    Executive Editor, Reuters Health
    Adjunct Assistant Professor, New York University’s Science, Health, and Environmental Reporting Program
    Treasurer, Association of Health Care Journalists
    Clinical Assistant Professor of Medicine, New York University School of Medicine
    Blogger, Embargo Watch http://embargowatch.wordpress.com (a blog independent of Reuters that does not necessarily reflect its views)
    http://twitter.com/ivanoransky

  • http://www.niemanlab.org/ Joshua Benton

    Thanks, Ivan. There are others, too. I think the issue is about political organizations doing the sponsoring and the placing.

    I don’t fault Collegiate Network at all — they’re just trying to get their point across, and good for them! And I don’t blame the journalists for wanting to take advantage of the opportunity, particularly in this environment. I just think it’s interesting that some news orgs are on board with is, given the traditional stance that there’s no room for ideology or opinion among their ranks.

  • Pingback: Suburban Guerrilla » Blog Archive » Geeze

  • Pingback: Journalism Today - Tracking Media Changes

  • Marie

    There are also religious organizations that are “paying the salaries behind some of the bylines.”

    According to the World Journalism Institute, its mission is to recruit, equip, place and encourage journalists who are Christians in mainstream newsrooms. The Institute also awards paid fellowships.

    http://www.worldji.com/