Twitter  Ken Doctor on the newsonomics of how and why nie.mn/WHcDmB http://t.co/AYGuIqfDGp  
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

Why the Oregon Daily Emerald is transforming what it means to be a college newspaper

The University of Oregon’s student newspaper is giving up a stable print business to focus on digital and better training for young journalists.

When newspapers cut back on their print product it’s big news. When the New Orleans Times-Picayune — not to mention three other Newhouse newspapers in Alabama — announced it was reducing its print production to three days a week it was like the shot heard around the (journalism) world.

And yet, that same day up in Eugene, Ore., another paper announced it was pulling back to two days of print and made it sound like a triumph. The Daily Emerald has been publishing five days a week for over 90 years and now, like the handful of papers who have cut back on print before it, plans to beef up its web presence and find new digital ways to reach their readers.

“We’re shifting to this idea of what does the reader want, not what do we think the reader needs.”

If you haven’t heard of the Emerald it may be because you don’t live in the Pacific Northwest, or, specifically attend the University of Oregon. The Emerald is the university’s student paper. (Go Ducks.) But there’s something else that sets the Emerald aside from other papers pulling back in print: It’s not bleeding money. The paper’s publisher says they have no debt and “a solid reserve fund”; this year has been the paper’s best, financially, in over a decade. And yet, the Emerald is knocking it all down, as the paper’s leadership wrote in the announcement: “We are making this change to deliver on our mission to serve our community and prepare our student staff for the professional world.”

When I spoke to the Ryan Frank, publisher of the Daily Emerald, he put it in basic terms. Stability is no excuse to stay idle, especially in the journalism business. “Some of our peers have been pushing the envelope on innovation for a decade — we’re not in that camp,” he said. “We had to do something big and bold to push as fast as we could to go where we need to go.”

So this fall, when students return to campus, the Daily Emerald will be officially replaced by Emerald Media Group. Under the new plan, the paper will be published on Mondays and Thursdays, two high traffic days on campus. The Monday edition will focus on longer news pieces and sports wrap-ups; Thursdays will have an emphasis on arts and entertainment (and, again, sports). The design of the paper is being completely overhauled; shifting from a broadsheet to a tabloid. They’re also adding an app development lab called The Garage and plan to extend themselves beyond advertising into marketing services and events.

Whenever a newspaper shakes up its production model, it runs the risk of shedding readers. As much as the Emerald’s target audience is of an age not known for reading print, the physical ritual of picking up a paper still has meaning. Frank told me they’ve received plenty of feedback from students that amounts to “the only reason I read the paper is because I can pick it up on the way to class.” At the same time, he said the Emerald hasn’t done extensive surveys on student’s likelihood of reading news online or on devices. In other words, the risk is real.

“From what I’ve seen, what I know, and what I’ve learned about students since I’ve been here, I honestly don’t know what kind of success we’ll have reaching them with news specifically on web and mobile devices,” he said.

But Frank says, even if times aren’t bad now, he expects the Emerald’s trend line for the print paper will be the same as others: Advertising will decline. The Emerald doesn’t get support from the university, which means they had to be proactive. At the same time, the paper’s mission is two-fold; keep the university community informed and prepare their staff for a career in the journalism business. Using that frame, thinking of a student newspaper as a “teaching hospital” for journalism, Frank said they had to change.

“Our approach has been let’s teach our students and ourselves how to deliver what the readers want, because that’s going to be demanded of them when they leave this office,” Frank said.

Staffing up a newspaper that is always in flux

The Emerald has a staff of around 80, most of them students, many getting a small stipend for their work. Under the new plan, a handful of reporters will be assigned to the “speed team,” a group, Emerald Editor-in-Chief Andy Rossback said, responsible for chasing breaking news and updates for Dailyemerald.com. Rossback said they want these reporters to post breaking news as it happens, even if that means bypassing editors for expediency.

Elsewhere on the staff, Rossback wants to create thematic beats to encourage deeper coverage for things like student debt, public support for education, and the relationship between college athletics and sports business. (That’s something of particular interest given Oregon’s deep ties to Phil Knight and Nike.) “We want people to spend nine months on the beat and they’ll become experts in it,” Rossback said. With the change in print, Rossback expects to see more enterprise pieces, with an emphasis on news on Mondays and features on Thursdays. Of course, since it’s a college paper, some things won’t change: The police blotter is not going anywhere. “We’re shifting to this idea of what does the reader want, not what do we think the reader needs, which has been the journalism philosophy for years,” he said.

As they prepare the staff for the transition, Rossback said they’ve discovered that learned journalism habits can be hard to break, even for 20-year-olds. Even for a staff that embraces technology and is familiar with online journalism, change still takes getting used to, he said. “We can come up with a plan and set it out on the table, but the execution of it is a process that is going to take time,” Rossback said.

One of the biggest challenges college newspapers face is the annual staff turnover. It would be hard for any news organization to carry on institutional knowledge or not suffer drops in coverage if they brought in a new staff every 9-12 months. Rossback said the paper has a high carry-over rate of underclassmen; around 30 staff members (including himself) are returning from this past year. “The biggest thing about next year is it’s an all-hands-on-deck year,” he said. “Everyone has to pick up everyone else’s slack.”

While each year promises some staff shuffling, Frank said fresh faces are blank slates when it comes to learning about journalism. For Frank, that’s another reason why making the change was important; it puts students in an environment closer to the media companies they could work in after graduation. Mobile devices and social media have had a large impact on journalism, and for many of the potential journalists who’ll work for the Emerald, these things are second nature. Frank thinks that’s reason enough to adapt. “A [student] walking on this campus…they were 10 when Facebook started,” he said. “If we’re lucky, their parents still got a newspaper at home.”

Image of the Oregon Duck by Wolfram Burner used under a Creative Commons license.

                                   
What to read next
lippmann-house-990
Ann Marie Lipinski    July 24, 2014
The Nieman Foundation for Journalism at Harvard wants to hear your idea for making journalism better. Come spend a few weeks working on it in Cambridge.