One Wednesday this spring, I wrote about an accelerator aimed at local newsrooms and funded by Facebook. Two days later, I criticized the fact that Facebook’s algorithm changes don’t actually appear to be hurting hyperpartisan publishers. This is a fairly common dynamic at Nieman Lab, where we write about the duopoly’s latest news funding efforts and announcements even as we bemoan their increasing dominance. We’re certainly not alone among news outlets in doing this, but, as Mathew Ingram pointed out this week in Columbia Journalism Review, it’s a weird situation:
These mega-platforms are now two of the largest funders of journalism in the world.
The irony is hard to miss. The dismantling of the traditional advertising model — largely at the hands of the social networks, which have siphoned away the majority of industry ad revenue — has left many media companies and journalistic institutions in desperate need of a lifeline. Google and Facebook, meanwhile, are happy to oblige, flush with cash from their ongoing dominance of the digital ad market.
The result is a somewhat dysfunctional alliance. People in the media business (including some on the receiving end of the cash) see the tech donations as guilt money, something journalism deserves because Google and Facebook wrecked their business. The tech giants, meanwhile, are desperate for some good PR and maybe even a few friends in a journalistic community that — especially now — can seem openly antagonistic.
People whose initiatives have benefited from Google and Facebook funding told Ingram how they feel about this dysfunctional alliance. Common thread: They’re offering money, take it, just don’t trust too much.
— Our own Joshua Benton, director of Nieman Lab: “I think there are a lot of very well-intentioned people at these companies who honestly believe that journalism is important and want to help as best as they possibly can. But I think it’s hard to view all these efforts through a lens other than public relations.” (Full disclosure: We host a Google Journalism Fellow every summer, and said fellow is paid by Google!)
One thing remarkable about Goog/FB support of journalism is how successfully they’ve rebranded “offering training in our products” as an act of charity.
Like, when Salesforce sends a trainer to a company using its software, it doesn’t get called “funding” https://t.co/Yr722TWaGM
— Joshua Benton (@jbenton) May 16, 2018
— Alexios Mantzarlis, director of Poynter’s International Fact Checking Network: “I think it’s kind of unfair, in a way that, with every grant, it feels like you need to justify that you’re not beholden to your donor, in a way that you don’t have to with other kinds of transactions. If you have a large client, aren’t you kind of beholden to their whims, too?”
— Jennifer Preston, VP of Knight: “If there are organizations, including Facebook and Google, that want to help support the future practice of journalism, then I’m in. I think the more people and the more organizations we have supporting the future of journalism, the better off our communities and our democracy will be.”
— Emily Bell, director of Columbia’s Tow Center for Digital Journalism: “I think it’s important to remember that the same companies that are coming into our newsrooms and training and talking to journalists and building projects for journalists are doing the same thing with local politicians, seeking to put self-driving cars on the streets of your town; they are selling packages of software to your local educational authority…It’s really hard to evaluate exactly how independent journalism can be in those circumstances. I think these are very serious concerns and, honestly, rarely discussed because of the pervasive nature of the money.”
Good piece by @mathewi – so many projects take $ from Facebook and Google (at @TowCenter we have zero funding from big tech companies as it is in conflict with the research we do). We need tech money to start paying for reporters – but does it bring with it too much compromise ? https://t.co/3CpUqyHRAF
— emily bell (@emilybell) May 17, 2018
It’s also tricky when, as Ingram points out, “Google and Facebook are rarely just small funders of specific projects along with other major donors, and they almost never fund the same initiatives together. This means that in many cases, the two tech companies are the single largest or possibly even only major funders, which raises a lot more potential red flags.”
9,049 comments:
The 10 Scariest Things About Mental Health Assessment Near Me mental
health assessment near me (Elwood)
10 Great Books On New Sash Windows Sash Windows Repair Near
Me (Combshoe9.Werite.Net)
5 Clarifications On Window Repair Near Me Window Repair Service Near Me
25 Surprising Facts About Change Door Lock Window Lock Repair near Me (https://postheaven.net/)
The Reasons 3 Wheeled Pushchair Has Become Everyone’s
Obsession In 2023 3 wheel Running buggy, http://Www.google.com.pe,
How To Save Money On Private Psychiatrists
private psychiatrist Near Me Uk
See What Upvc Tilt And Turn Windows Prices Tricks The Celebs Are Using upvc tilt and turn windows prices
The 9 Things Your Parents Teach You About Babiie
Pram babiie pram; Dante,
Ten Easy Steps To Launch Your Own Tandem Double Buggy
Business all Terrain double buggy (http://www.google.pt)
See What Independent Psychiatric Assessment Tricks The
Celebs Are Using independent Psychiatric assessment
20 Fun Facts About Misty Glaze Misted Window Replacement
5 Laws Everybody In Sash Window Cost Should Know casement window sash [Hollie]
Wooden Window Repairs Near Me Tools To Ease Your Everyday Lifethe Only Wooden Window Repairs Near Me Trick That Every Person Must Learn wooden window repairs near me (Mittie)
7 Small Changes You Can Make That’ll Make A Big Difference With
Your Private Mental Health Psychiatrist private psychiatry uk (Zulma)
Why Upvc Repairs Near Me Should Be Your Next Big Obsession Window Repair Near Me
The 10 Scariest Things About Upvc Window Repairs Near Me Upvc Window Repairs Near Me
Private Psychiatrists Near Me Tools To Ease Your Everyday Lifethe Only Private
Psychiatrists Near Me Trick Every Individual Should
Be Able To private psychiatrists Near Me
The Reasons You’ll Want To Read More About Replacing A Window Handle Upvc window handle stiff to close – yogaasanas.science,
Nine Things That Your Parent Taught You About Parent Facing Pushchair Parent facing pushchair
11 Creative Ways To Write About Cheap Locksmith Near Me Commercial Locksmith Near Me
(https://Telegra.Ph)
Now That You’ve Purchased Mental Health Assessment Uk
… Now What? Mental Assessment Test
What You Can Use A Weekly Window Hinges Project Can Change Your Life
window blown Off Hinges
A New Trend In Private Mental Health Assessment London assessment for Mental health
You’ll Be Unable To Guess Private Psychiatrists Near Me’s Tricks
Private Psychiatrists Near Me
Guide To 2 In 1 Travel System With Car Seat:
The Intermediate Guide Towards 2 In 1 Travel System With Car Seat 2 in 1
travel system With car Seat (istartw.lineageinc.com)
How To Tell The Mental Health Services Near Me
That Is Right For You mental health assessment report (Jaimie)
10 Facts About Local Locksmith That Make You Feel Instantly The Best Mood Locksmith
average price – henningsen-Harper-3.blogbright.Net –
The Most Significant Issue With Assessment In Mental
Health, And How You Can Fix It take a mental health assessment
(Casimira)
A Step-By-Step Guide To Mental Health Test Online Mental Assessments
11 Methods To Completely Defeat Your Assessment Mental Health Mental Health Assessments
10 Tell-Tale Signals You Should Know To Look For A New Replacing
A Upvc Door Lock replacing window locks – Latrice –
10 Things That Your Family Teach You About Misty Window Repairs Near Me misty window repairs near me
– clashofcryptos.trade,
Some Of The Most Common Mistakes People Make Using Mental Health Assessments mental health capacity Assessment
9 Lessons Your Parents Teach You About Window Hinge Repairs Near Me window hinge repairs near
me (Joshua)
How Sliding Patio Door Repairs Changed My Life For The Better patio
door repairs near me, Val,
5 Killer Quora Answers To Upvc Window Lock Repair Near Me window lock Repair near me
9 . What Your Parents Teach You About How To Get Psychiatric Assessment how
to get psychiatric assessment, Randell,
5 Killer Quora Answers On 3 Wheel Stroller Cheap
3 wheel stroller cheap
10 Tips For Assessment Mental Health That Are Unexpected
assessing mental Health
What Are The Biggest “Myths” About Replacement Double Glazed Sealed
Units Could Be True Sealed Unit repairs
Guide To Psychiatrist Therapist Near Me: The Intermediate Guide
Towards Psychiatrist Therapist Near Me psychiatrist therapist near
me (Deon)
A Relevant Rant About Online Psychiatric Assessment UK psychiatric assessment bristol
How To Create An Awesome Instagram Video About Assessment In Mental Health Mental Health Assessment For schizophrenia
Indisputable Proof Of The Need For Door Lock Service Near Me Replacement Locks For
Double Glazed Windows – http://Www.Hulkshare.Com,
Guide To Single Running Stroller: The Intermediate Guide Towards Single Running Stroller single running stroller, Merry,
See What Windows Repairs Near Me Tricks The Celebs
Are Using windows repairs near me
5 Window Handles Replacement Projects For Any Budget Replacing Window Handles
The Good And Bad About Assessing Mental Health online mental health Assessments
The 10 Most Terrifying Things About Secondary Glazing Sash Window secondary Glazing Sash Window
Trackbacks:
Leave a comment