Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
Is the future about one all-knowing AI or many? The new app Poe gets you ready to chat with them all
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Feb. 28, 2022, 7:48 a.m.
Business Models

AP cancels auction of overcrowded migrant boat NFT after outcry

The AP’s NFT marketplace is still up; a “commemorative NFT” by Anja Niedringhaus, the German AP photojournalist who was killed in Afghanistan in 2014, is being resold for $1.5 million.

The AP will not auction off the NFT of “migrants drifting in an overcrowded boat in the Mediterranean,” as it had planned to on Friday, after many complaints that the auction was a blatant attempt to profit from human suffering. The NFT marketplace it launched at the end of January, however, remains up and running.

The AP deleted the tweet sent at 2 PM on Thursday about the auction. “This was a poor choice of imagery for an NFT. It has not and will not be put up for auction,” Lauren Easton, AP’s director of media relations, told me in an email.

She added: “AP’s NFT marketplace is a very early pilot program, and we are immediately reviewing our efforts. As a not-for-profit, AP’s mission is to inform the world with accurate, unbiased journalism. That remains our primary focus.”

The AP launched its NFP photography marketplace at the end of January with the “white-label NFT marketplace” company Xoaa. “NFT price points will vary,” a press release noted at the time. “As a not-for-profit news cooperative, proceeds go back into funding factual, unbiased AP journalism.”

Two “commemorative NFTs” by Anja Niedringhaus — the German AP photojournalist who was killed in Afghanistan in 2014, and a 2007 Nieman Fellow — were auctioned off this week at 0.66 ETH, about $1789, each.

NFTs purchased through the AP’s site can be resold there, with the AP taking a 10% fee “inclusive of payment processor fees.” The AP sold another Anja Niedringhaus NFT, “Splash in Kabul,” for $1,799 3 days ago; that buyer is now trying to resell it for 532 ETH — roughly $1.4 million, at the moment.

An NFT of Noah Berger’s “Marsh Fire,” first bought for $399, is being resold for 35.52 ETH, or about $99,999 at the moment.

Here’s a good thread filled with screenshots from the AP staff’s official Discord, where staffers expressed dismay over the migrant boat NFT and the program in general. “Clearly what happened tonight doesn’t have to do with whether the photographers are consenting,” one wrote, after it was made clear that AP photographers have to actively agree to have their work in the program. “It has to do with the consent of the people in the boat, and whether a video of them should be turned into a commodity. How are you deciding what photos get turned into NFTs and do you even recognize that something went wrong here other than that you went viral?”

POSTED     Feb. 28, 2022, 7:48 a.m.
SEE MORE ON Business Models
Show tags
 
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
Is the future about one all-knowing AI or many? The new app Poe gets you ready to chat with them all
Poe lets you use ChatGPT alongside a new rival named Claude — which seems to work better in important ways.
Can journalism’s “reckoning” with racism progress to accountability — and redress?
“The magic — because magic can be good or bad — of narrative is that it can counteract your lived experience.”
Google now wants to answer your questions without links and with AI. Where does that leave publishers?
A dozen years ago, Eric Schmidt forecast the AI pivot that’s playing out this week. And the questions it prompts — around the link economy, fair use, and aggregation — are more real than ever.