Jessica Maddox
De-influencing news influencers
For the last few years in my Nieman Lab predictions, I’ve discussed the convergence of journalists and influencers. But if influencers are becoming journalists and journalists are becoming influencers, is it possible to de-influence the news the same way we have de-influenced products from books, makeup, water bottles, and more?
De-influencing has been described as the practice of encouraging others to divest from overhyped and excessive consumption. This question was asked to me by some of my phenomenal students at the University of Georgia’s Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication when I spoke to them about news influencers. “If we can de-influence influencers and products,” one student asked me, “can we de-influence the news?” I’ve been thinking about that question ever since. This prediction charts what de-influencing the news looks like in 2026, and why it’s more important than ever.
On one hand, journalists becoming influencers represents what my U.K. colleague, Sophie Bishop, calls “influencer creep” — how the labor of being an influencer has seeped into other professions. To be a successful journalist, individuals are encouraged to develop their personal brand, post on social media, achieve visibility through a consistent online presence, and seek successful metrics in the form of clicks, likes, and views. Journalism’s influencer creep has only become more ubiquitous and obvious as reporters leave major news corporations and turn to the likes of Substack and self-started podcasts. This turn is also where influencers become journalists. Influencers have built bases of large and dedicated followers who trust them. Whether they are journalists-as-influencers or influencers-as-journalists, all these freelancing individuals form the growing category of “news influencer.”
De-influencing the news and news influencers isn’t that different from de-influencing clothes or skincare. While de-influencing has been criticized as just a different kind of consumption in which people merely swap one product for a cheaper alternative, we can’t treat all de-influencing as the same. For instance, there is a difference between eschewing luxury mascara for a drugstore brand sold by a massive, exploitative corporation as opposed to shirking that same luxury mascara for one sold by a minority-owned business or one from a local vendor in your community. There’s a difference between fast fashion and choosing to spend a little more on sustainably sourced clothes.
I see the de-influencing of news and new influencers as a return to community. In a moment where Pew Research Center finds that over half of Americans now get their news from social media “at least sometimes,” we cannot treat all news influencers as equal. While news influencers may have once been seen as the “de-influencing” of major news corporations, they can easily succumb to social media’s worst tendencies of sensationalism, fearmongering, engagement bait, and online drama. This is the byproduct of influencer creep — the labor of being an influencer can quickly descend into other aspects of being an influencer. We should be deliberate in who we follow and who we trust.
It may be easy to follow the most popular news influencers out there, but is it possible to trade out that consumption for one who is in your community? They may have a smaller following, but they’re more likely to cover issues that impact you on a local level. Instead of following a reporting generalist, can you follow someone who is focused on crafting a niche in environmental journalism, political journalism, etc.? While pushes to save local news are nothing new, turning toward local news influencers is.
I see 2026 as bringing a reckoning for news influencers that begins to prioritize glocalization — or how news influencers can successfully bridge the global and the local. How global and national issues play out on a local level, with how policies impact communities, is of paramount importance. This is not to suggest we turn to individualistic news consumption, because people can follow news influencers who cover other communities, as well. I see inspiration for this coming from some of the great work being done in climate journalism, as these reporters often expertly connect issues of natural disasters, data centers, and more to local neighborhoods. This is not to say we shouldn’t follow larger online-first outlets or influencers, but to strike a balance between the macro and micro.
De-influencing the news means being deliberate. It means resisting the attention economy and engagement bait of social media. It means searching and going slower. The convergence of journalism and influencers isn’t going away — so we must resist the overconsumption, sensationalist mentality that comes with it.
Jessica Maddox is an associate professor of media studies in the Grady College of Journalism and Mass Communication at the University of Georgia.