Twitter   The value of crowdsourcing can be more than mining social media for sources. nie.mn/JLgvek
SHARE
Fuego
Nieman Journalism Lab
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

Alicia Shepard: Anonymity allows “the loudest drunk at the bar” to dominate online conversations

Editor’s Note: Our sister publication Nieman Reports is out with its summer 2011 issue, “Links That Bind Us,” which focuses on the role community plays in journalism. We’re highlighting a few entries that connect with subjects we follow at the Lab, but go read the whole issue. In this piece, Alicia Shepard writes about quality of online discourse (or lack thereof) during her three-year tenure as NPR ombudsman.

Nieman Reports summer 2011 coverIt might be hard to believe, but one reason NPR was inspired to build its social media community is what it found in personal ads like this one — “Female golfer, loves NPR, travel and skydiving, is looking for like-minded man.” With NPR squeezed into the middle of self-portraits, the network figured that if it created a digital public square, people would want to congregate there.

So three years ago NPR invited its 27 million listeners to gather at this virtual water cooler to share ideas, suggest stories, offer comments and criticisms, and participate in civil dialogue. Joining NPR’s digital community requires creating an account. Individuals need to log in each time they comment on a story, though using real names is not required. So far 500,000 people have signed up as members of the NPR.org community.

Since the launch in 2008, those tasked with oversight of this digital community’s dynamics at times have felt as though they are riding a bucking bronco in the rodeo ring. Those feelings hit hardest when contentious issues surface, and it can be challenging to maintain civil dialogue as conversations devolve into downright meanness.

Keep reading »

                                   
What to read next
harvard-university-education
Ken Doctor    May 17, 2012
Journalism and education are both about knowledge. Could their post-disruption business models start to blur?
  • MK

    While at the Lowell Sun, I wrote a column explaining why we were switching to moderated comments from the free-for-all we had before. That meant an editor had to read each comment for approval, unless the readers posting a comment had registered previously. The column is behind a paywall, but here’s the nut graph.

    “Online comments have the roll of the ocean to them. Rogue waves come out
    of nowhere. Fins break the surface. The first bite is drawn, and a
    school dives in to dismember the weak, the young, the old, the injured,
    the misfortunate, and those who have erred in public. In other words,
    humans. …”

  • Pingback: Sunday Reads « LONGER BACA