Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
How much news makes it into people’s Facebook feeds? Our experiment suggests not much
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
June 10, 2016, 9:45 a.m.
Reporting & Production

The Telegraph is trying to streamline soccer live blogging with an automated graphic system

The British paper is unveiling the latest iteration of the tool, Roboblogger, for the European Championship, which kicks off Friday.

In the 79th minute of last fall’s Rugby World Cup Final, New Zealand fly-half Beauden Barrett scored a try to ice the All Blacks’ victory over rival Australia.

Seconds after Barrett downed the ball, a graphic mapping the score appeared in the live blog that the British newspaper The Telegraph was using to cover the match in real-time.

RoboBlogger1

The infographic was produced by Roboblogger, an experimental project the British newspaper launched last year to use real-time data to create charts and infographics for liveblogs.

Roboblogger ingests real-time statistics from Opta, a U.K. sports data firm, then spits out graphics and charts. For the Rugby World Cup, the graphics showed how each team scored from various points on the field, the number of tackles they made, the distance they carried the ball, and more. Telegraph editors and reporters got the graphics and charts in a feed and added them into the liveblog manually.

The Telegraph has now transitioned to focus on soccer, a more popular sport with richer data to analyze. It will roll out the latest version of Roboblogger for its live coverage of the European Championship, which kicks off Friday in France.

chelsea-sunderland-passes

The paper is now working to further streamline Roboblogger by developing automated processes that determine the most interesting or significant plays and add them straight to the liveblog, so staffers can focus on their own commentary.

The Telegraph received a €300,000 (USD $342,222) grant from Google’s European Digital News Initiative to create Roboblogger. The paper announced cutbacks last month, but the Google funding enabled it to hire three contract employees for a six-month period that runs through September. After that, The Telegraph plans to integrate Roboblogger into its normal editorial operations.

“It was previously impossible to do graphics in live articles,” said Adriaan Pelzer, Telegraph head of editorial development, who is leading the project. “You can’t get a graphics desk to sit there and furiously punch out graphics; it’s too slow. Doing it automatically makes sense.”

The Telegraph decided to focus its efforts for this type of coverage, at least for now, on sports because there’s an abundance of well-structured data.

The paper is using a two-pronged strategy to build out Roboblogger’s automated selection process. It’s developing a rule set that triggers the creation of a chart along with a more advanced rankings system.

For the rule set, the developers established various metrics that prompt infographics or charts to be presented to the editors. After a goal is scored, for example, a graphic is produced that shows all the passes and runs that led to the goal.

chelsea-goal

Roboblogger is also able to set rules for less obvious data — a certain number of passes in a row or a specific distance covered on the field — and turn those into graphics as well.

man-united-passes

To help staffers decide which graphics to include in liveblogs, developers are building an interface that will show numerous graphics at once and indicates — with color or some other sign — which ones might be interesting enough to be auto-published.

chelsea-crosses

In addition to the Euro 2016 games this summer, the developers have been populating Roboblogger with datasets from old matches. “That provides us with a very strong signal of what our rule thresholds should be,” Pelzer said.”

The rankings system, meanwhile, is being developed to include a more nuanced understanding of player performance. Pelzer compared it to Google’s PageRank, which uses different factors to measure the importance of web pages.

The Telegraph’s ranking system assigns scores to each player, and it’s able to pick up on things that the simpler rule-based approach wouldn’t notice. If a player who hasn’t done particularly well in a competition suddenly starts doing better, for example, that sudden movement could be a signal to start increasing the likelihood of sharing graphs where the player is involved.

The finished product will ideally combine the rankings and rule-based approaches. The Telegraph hopes to add in the ranking system in August when the new Premier League season starts. At that point, editors will be able to set up parameters for individual games because they’ll know the tendencies of each team and which types of plays to expect.

The Telegraph introduced a new CMS earlier this year, designed to support live coverage. But Roboblogger has also helped boost the speed of live posts, Pelzer said. Often, the live blog is run by a journalist in the newsroom and the TV feed is a few seconds behind real-time, meaning that results come in from Roboblogger before they show up on TV.

“Editors started using it as a cue,” Pelzer said. “They are under a very high amount of pressure when they do these live blogs.”

Photo by Jon Candy used under a Creative Commons license.

POSTED     June 10, 2016, 9:45 a.m.
SEE MORE ON Reporting & Production
SHARE THIS STORY
   
Show comments  
Show tags
 
Join the 45,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
How much news makes it into people’s Facebook feeds? Our experiment suggests not much
Half the people in our survey saw no news at all in the first 10 posts in their feeds — even using an extremely generous definition of “news” that counted everything from celebrity gossip to sports scores to history-based explainers, across all mediums.
TV goes digital, digital goes TV
“Television reaches this critical stage with a lot of experience and lessons that have been learned by others, with heavy pockets, and two clear strengths: a very strong footprint on social networks, both from its brands and its individual talents, and a unique sensitivity for video storytelling that is higher than that of all its competitors.”
The editorial meeting of the future
“In the future, we’ll instead organize the editorial meeting around this all-important question: “What can we help the public understand or do today?” We won’t start with our ideas — we’ll start with the information gaps the public demonstrates they have, and focus our efforts squarely on filling those gaps.”