It’s fun to hate on newspapers’ op-ed sections (inspiring debate is kind of the point), meaning the job of editing them is not for the faint-hearted. And changing and diversifying them can be a challenge — whether you’re battling bad-faith arguments from the alt-right or just trying to get rid of a strain of [deep, booming, obviously male voice] “I want to tell you about Middle East policy.”
The deep, booming “I want to tell you about Middle East policy” had been the problem with the Financial Times’ opinion section, but Brooke Masters is up to the challenge of fixing it. At the FT for more than a decade, she was the companies editor before becoming opinion and analysis editor this past spring. Her role — diversifying the 130-year-old paper’s opinion section, previously known as “Comment” and dominated by opining men — is just a piece of what the FT is doing to appeal to women. I spoke to Masters, who is based in London, about how she’s bringing in more voices, how she thinks about quotas, and what the biggest problems are with most op-ed submissions. Our conversation, slightly edited for length and clarity, is below.We also rewrote the guidelines on how to submit, to make them friendlier and more suggestive of the kinds of things we want. It was genuinely an effort to be much more welcoming, to really encourage some of the people who have always read us but didn’t feel comfortable about contributing. We also wanted to include people who were stumbling across us on the web, to help them realize that we really wanted to hear from them.
The traditional comment section had always under-indexed women compared to the rest of the website and we’re moving closer in line, which is great, and I’d like to over-index eventually.
When I started, you never got anything about how people live. It was very much [she puts on a deep voice] “I want to talk to you about Middle East policy.” Well, we still get a lot of “I want to talk to you about Middle East policy,” but there are definitely people who are, like, “I want to tell you about my life as a trader” — actually, that was one raging success that came from the callout box. This woman said she wanted to write about why, if you’re a woman, despite all the stereotypes about bro culture, you should be a commodities trader. She wrote a fabulous piece that did incredibly well and I think there’s no way on earth that (a) she would have submitted or (b) it would have run, before we started this stuff. It got more than double the usual number of pageviews for an opinion piece.
There was a controversy in February about removing the statue of Cecil Rhodes from Oxford. A woman wrote in saying she was a former Rhodes Scholar, and the piece was about how the Rhodes was very worthy and important and needs to be diverse. But then at the bottom of her pitch — not actually in the piece — she talked about how weird her experience was applying for the Rhodes in the ’70s, all the horrible, sexist things they did to her. We thought if we got her to write about that — as opposed to the worthy policy stuff — people would read it. We worked with her and helped her craft an op-ed that was quite personal and did brilliantly. That’s another one that came straight out of the callout box.
Also, because I used to be a companies editor, I know a lot of corporate reporters around the world. I put the word out that if they got something that they thought maybe wasn’t a traditional FT op-ed but was interesting, they should connect me directly with the person. That way, I got in touch with a woman in California who runs a small investment fund and got totally dissed by Facebook at their annual general meeting. We worked with her, and again, it was one of our huge successes. That is not a piece that we would have run in a traditional op-ed slot, because we had to offer the explanation of what was going on and say Facebook had been given a chance to comment. It doesn’t fit so well in a traditional paper format. But online, you can do that. Natasha [Lamb]’s piece got like triple the normal amount of pageviews. It was really fun. The PR guy we quoted who called her not nice ended up quitting within a couple days.
People also tend to trade in platitudes and big generic statements. I want concrete examples, I want to help people be concrete and compelling. We’re making the effort to tell people about experiences they themselves don’t have. Traditional op-eds tend to be policy arguments; this is more about walking in other people’s shoes, even if it’s also arguing for some sort of change.
One of the things I would like more of is people who are less naturally FT readers. We get a lot of European policymakers, centrist Americans. We don’t get a lot of right-wing Americans; I would like more of that. I would like much more developing world stuff. We have a pretty good relationship with various sources of Chinese commentary, but we don’t have very much Indian commentary except that the head of the Central Bank is lovely and writes for us; I would like more Latin America, more Africa, and I really would like more people where you’re walking in their shoes. We’ve had a guy who’s in an Australian refugee camp. We had an auditor talk about how much everybody hates her, because auditing is very much under fire right now.
I think people are much more willing to listen to an argument and consider perspectives other than their own if they can envision that they’re talking to real people, not just policy points. We will always have important policy op-eds, becuse that is one of the things we like, but it’s a bit of changing the mix. I think that’s partly how we get more diversity — and it’s diversity of perspective, as well as diversity of gender and race and national origin. It’s not diversity just for diversity’s sake. It’s diversity so that people can understand each other better. I want people arguing with each other on my pages, but I want them doing it nicely.
We also instituted this thing called a head-to-head where we pick an issue — like should audit firms be broken up, or should Dodd–Frank be weakened. We commission two people, generally both external to the FT so we’re not putting our finger on the scale, and get them each to write a piece of exactly the same length arguing one way or the other, and then we invite the readers to participate: You’ve read both, what’s your view? And then a week later, we do a “reader’s respond” as well. That’s been great, those have been really popular.

