Twitter  Quartz found an unlikely inspiration for its relaunched homepage: The email newsletter.  
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

An NPR listener’s dream comes true: pledge-free programming, if you pay

KQED: Turn Pledge Off

When ex-NPR chief Vivian Schiller came to town the other day, she bragged: “Public media has the most successful paywall out there. It just happens to be voluntary.” She warned stations, however, they must innovate or perish.

KQED San Francisco, America’s largest public radio station by audience size, can’t be accused of resting on its laurels. The station is rolling out its trusty spring pledge drive next month, but this year, KQED is trying to give people a satisfactory answer to an age-old question: I already gave you money, so why do I have to keep listening to this infernal pledge drive?

For a donation of $45, listeners can opt to turn down the tote bag and get a premium premium: a members-only Internet audio stream with no fundraising whatsoever. Paying listeners will hear uninterrupted local and national programming — the programming otherwise covered up by pledge breaks on the FM signal.

“In this beta — it will always be in beta to some extent — we’re just looking for: Is there really a market for it? And how do we have it priced?” said Don Derheim, KQED’s chief operating officer and executive vice president.

Pledge drives, annoying as they might be, are the bread and butter of public radio. They aren’t going away. But Derheim said it appears listeners are willing to “pay their way around it.” He said about 100 people had signed up as of Thursday morning, when the offer first went live. Since then, the station has raised $26,000 in response to promotions for the pledge-free stream. KQED has 205,000 individual donors, whose contributions make up more than half of the station’s annual revenue.

After donating, every listener gets a unique code tied to an email address. That code unlocks access to the alternate stream on KQED’s website on up to four devices. The pledge-free stream is a one-time gift — more like a mug than a subscription. Derheim said he expects to offer the pledge-free stream again during the station’s next drive, in September, and listeners will have to donate again to get access.

KQED’s digital media team developed and beta-tested the technology with volunteers two years ago. The tech worked, Derheim said, but the world wasn’t ready for it — with smartphones in so many listeners’ hands (and cars), now is the time: “The device universe is ready. The listeners here are ready.” KQED also was among the first stations, a year ago, to take small donations via text message.

“We’re lucky enough to be here in the ever-expanding definition of Silicon Valley. We’re getting out there with our products and ideas and taking them to our customers,” Derheim said.

I spoke with the public radio pledge drive’s original inventor, the longtime NPR correspondent Susan Stamberg. She loved the idea: “I think it’s a clever and realistic solution,” she said.

Back in the 1960s, Stamberg was general manager of American University’s fledgling public broadcaster, WAMU. “I didn’t have a clue, but I did know that we needed money and that we weren’t going to get any from the university,” she said. She fought with AU’s vice president for the right to raise money. She hand-stamped envelopes to 200 listeners, soliciting contributions in any amount.

“They were small, modest checks but from loyal, loyal listeners,” she said. “I kept watching for those checks to come in…and realized the amount of money we were collecting would not cover the cost of sending out letters.” Then, a miracle: An anonymous donor wrote a check for $1,000. That’s when Stamberg (and her university bosses) realized people would be willing to pay for news on the radio. The pledge drive stuck, although it would be awhile until someone (she doesn’t know who) would get the idea to put it on air.

This week, when word of KQED’s idea got out, an intense debate emerged within the industry. My former colleague at Boston’s WBUR, reporter Adam Ragusea, said the whole idea rubs him the wrong way: He’s worried because he thinks it’ll work.

“The incentive for the stations will be to gradually make the exclusive service more and more desirable than the free service, and the pledge periods longer and longer in order to get more people to buy in,” Ragusea said. “Then little by little, year by year, we will become a de facto subscription service, which is not what we’re supposed to be.” He takes issue with the concept of offering “premium” content only to paying members, saying it departs from public radio’s core mission of public service.

I put that argument to Stamberg. [See update below.] “That’s a very sophisticated argument,” she said. “But you know, I don’t think it’s an argument for the 21st century…The realities shift and change. I think we have to recognize it. We’re not putting commercials on the radio. We’re staying true to what our mission is.”

Derheim, at KQED, says public radio needs to have a good philosophical think about all this. But he said KQED can’t sit around and wait for that conversation to happen. He listened to the audio of Schiller’s talk at Harvard this week, and he said he identified with her aggressively future-focused attitude.

“[We] must be the disruptor,” he said, using Schiller’s word. “We’re trying to thrive on being there first, on what’s going to work next.”

[Update, 4/25/11: An earlier version of this story mistakenly referred to Susan Stamberg as "Mama" Stamberg. The nickname, in fact, belongs to her mother-in-law. Every year on NPR, around Thanksgiving, Stamberg shares "Mama Stamberg's cranberry relish recipe," a recipe from the mother of her late husband, Louis C. Stamberg.]

What to read next
Justin Ellis    Aug. 25, 2014
Developers, designers, and writers from across the Vox Media family are getting involved in building new storytelling tools for the tech site and plotting its next phase of growth.
  • Joel Abrams

    I would pay for this. I have also long argued that NPR ringtones would be a great premium for subscribers – I had to roll my own ringtone from the ATC theme.

  • Pingback: PLEASE help me with this dream? :(? | New ways to organize a room

  • Pingback: Is this Obsessive Compulsive Disorder? | New ways to organize a room

  • Pingback: Flight Simulators Warning – Read This Information Before Buying Any Flight Sim Recreation | Buy Pro Flight Simulator

  • Pingback: Gebet Nationalhymne Ausmarsch Großer Zapfenstreich | youtube

  • Pingback: Anonymous

  • Pingback: Fundraising Talk is an Endurance Contest… «

  • M

    I’ve been waiting for this forever. (even tweeted about it.) as a long-time member, i’m frustrated when I dontate, then have to listen to a begfest for 2 weeks. Now if only WBEZ and KCRW would do this…

  • robynsc

    i hate to be the bearer of bad news, but since i got my ipod touch and and either the tunein radio or, wait for it, the public radio app, i can always switch away from my local npr station during pledge week.

    i do like the ringtones idea – i’d buy that. get carl casell to do voicemail for subscribers instead of just on wait, wait. or some of the other personalities. who would not want their voicemail message by sylvia poggioli? seriously. or my favorite furman university alum, eleanor beardsley!!

  • Mritt1

    I am a dedicated NPR listener and I think the idea of ‘pledge-free’ public radio is brilliant. Can’t wait for it to come to Boston. I sympathize with Adam Ragusea’s distaste for diluting the ‘public’ in ‘public radio,’ but I think this is an idea whose time has come. (BTW, I, too, change the station during pledge week).

  • melodyhritt

    An NPR listener’s dream comes true: pledge-free programming, if you pay

  • Charles

    I would completely pay for this. Though I think the concerns raised by Ragusea are valid. They may not necessarily come true, but it’s a valid concern that would need to be thought long and hard about.
    But imagine the reception if the NYTimes decided to go non-profit and instituted a pay wall for two weeks a year under which every article would be proceeded by a 20 second request for donation, and a promise that the ask would disappear once a certain level of donation had been received.

  • Dave

    I’m only interested in this if you can bring it to the actual radio. If I were listening online I’d already be listening to the source programmes via their web sites.

    Twice a week I commute between Montpelier, VT, and Boston, MA. Annually I end up getting three times as many pledge drive annoyances because VPR, NHPR and WUBR do not coordinate their solicitation. I loathe the drives. I would gladly donate to all three (instead of just VPR as I do now) if only I could have the ability to tune my car radio to a pledge-free station.

  • Pingback: NPR Offers Premium Stream For Those Who’ve Already Pledged - Techland -

  • Jeannie

    Agree – dream come true. I’d pay on day one if this was available in Atlanta. Now, do I pay 50% of my annual pledge in spring and 50% in fall to avoid both drives? Me thinks so.