• Fellowships
  • Reports
  • Lab
  • Storyboard
    • Nieman Foundation at Harvard
    HOME
    About
    Subscribe
    Archives
              
    Foundation
    Reports
    Storyboard
    LATEST STORY
    Rebooting the Minnesota Star Tribune: A conversation with Steve Grove
    Business Models Mobile & Apps Audience & Social Aggregation & Discovery Reporting & Production
    ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
    Aug. 12, 2024, 9:04 a.m.
    Did Taylor Swift really call Florida “racist”? (No she didn’t, no matter what that TikTok “news alert” says)
    LINK: www.ft.com  ➚   |   Posted by: Joshua Benton   |   August 12, 2024

    When is a news alert not a news alert?

    No, that’s not a question from a blunted hippie who just read the I Ching and now speaks only in kōans. It’s a question about TikTok and other social apps that have leaned into sending push notifications that look like news alerts but actually derive from the user-generated muck.

    The Financial Times has an interesting story out this morning that notes the vertical-video app’s tendency to send pushes that frame non-news as news:

    TikTok has been sending inaccurate and misleading news-style alerts to users’ phones, including a false claim about Taylor Swift and a weeks-old disaster warning, intensifying fears about the spread of misinformation on the popular video-sharing platform. 

    Among alerts seen by the Financial Times was a warning about a tsunami in Japan, labelled “BREAKING,” that was posted in late January, three weeks after an earthquake had struck.

    Other notifications falsely stated that “Taylor Swift Cancelled All Tour Dates in What She Called ‘Racist Florida’” and highlighted a five-year “ban” for a US baseball player [Shohei Ohtani] that originated as an April Fool’s day prank.

    The notifications, which sometimes contain summaries from user-generated posts, pop up on screen in the style of a news alert. Researchers say that format, adopted widely to boost engagement through personalized video recommendations, may make users less critical of the veracity of the content and open them up to misinformation.

    RELATED ARTICLE
    R.I.P. Chinua Achebe, again: The unstuck-in-time life of social media
    March 23, 2015
    These alerts are newsy in format but not in content; they are either culture-war agitprop or old stories unstuck in time. Many of these are perfectly accurate, of course, but they are nonetheless produced by someone other than journalists, leaving the door wide open for abuses. And given that their broadcast is governed by algorithms, measures of engagement are more likely to win out over measures of accuracy.

    A reminder: News alerts are not nearly as common among the general population as phone-addicted journalists might imagine. As of 2021, only 24% of Americans surveyed said they had received even a single mobile news alert in the past week. (I’ve gotten more than that in the past five minutes.) While that was higher than in most other countries (e.g., U.K. 17%, Japan 13%, Finland 9%), it still means three-quarters of Americans carry an essentially news-alert-free phone in their pockets. So these platform-derived alerts may, for many, be the only ones they see. And, of course, many users will see the alert but not tap through, leaving the false info as the entirety of the message communicated.

    TikTok removed the specific alerts the FT brought to their attention, but declined to get into how they managed to rise to the top of the algorithm in the first place.

    Show tags
     
    What’s the best way to follow how the news is changing?
    Our daily email, with all the freshest future-of-journalism news.
    Prefer a once-a-week email? »
    The latest from Nieman Lab
    Rebooting the Minnesota Star Tribune: A conversation with Steve Grove
    Richard Tofel
    Collaboration helps keep independent journalism alive in Venezuela
    Hanaa' Tameez
    The Salt Lake Tribune, profitable and growing, seeks to rid itself of that “necessary evil” — the paywall
    Sarah Scire
    Want to fight misinformation? Teach people how algorithms work
    Myojung Chung
    Newsonomics: California’s local news agreement with Google is a win
    Ken Doctor
    Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
    Rebooting the Minnesota Star Tribune: A conversation with Steve Grove
    “We would like to see at least 25% of our P&L look different in a couple of years than it does now…I don’t think any media company right now can just be banking on subscriptions to save the day.”
    Collaboration helps keep independent journalism alive in Venezuela
    In recent weeks, Venezuelan journalists have found innovative ways to keep independent journalism alive; here are some of their efforts.
    The Salt Lake Tribune, profitable and growing, seeks to rid itself of that “necessary evil” — the paywall
    The first daily newspaper in the U.S. to become a nonprofit has published a refreshingly readable and transparent annual report.
    Help advance the Nieman Foundation’s mission “to promote and elevate the standards of journalism” by making a donation.

    To promote and elevate the standards of journalism

    Covering thought leadership in journalism

    Pushing to the future of journalism

    Exploring the art and craft of story
    © 2024 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College  /  Some rights reserved
    Harvard Trademark Privacy Digital Accessibility
    Walter Lippmann House    One Francis Ave.    Cambridge, MA 02138    617 495 2237