What went wrong at the Houston Landing?

“We tried to be too much, too fast, for too many people.”

In May, the Houston Landing shut down less than two years after its ambitious launch, laying off all 43 employees.

The announcement that the board of directors had voted to close the nonprofit news outlet generated national attention, and many questions. The big one: How does a local news startup that appeared so promising — one endowed with well-staffed newsroom and business operations, and more than $20 million in seed funding — fail?

In conversations with more than a dozen former Landing staffers, and additional nonprofit news observers and leaders, I heard about a news outlet with an unclear identity, led by a CEO who struggled to unify the organization. Leadership lacked the fundraising and nonprofit experience to achieve the lofty ambitions set out for the Landing. It spent quickly from the outset, and could not generate revenue to sustain its size.

The factors leading to the Landing’s closure may be unique. But the outlet’s challenges — how to balance the pursuit of impact with building an audience; how to carve out a niche among more established local outlets; how ample seed funding can become a liability — are relevant to other news nonprofits.

“We tried to be too much, too fast, for too many people,” a staffer and member of the Landing’s union told me.

In reporting this story, I reached out to more than 40 former Landing staffers and leaders — from every member of the board of directors to reporters to audience engagement producers. It was striking how few were willing (or able) to go on the record. Many staffers, including every unionized staffer, were required to sign non-disparagement and confidentiality agreements as a condition of severance. Such arrangements are common in the corporate world, but less so for nonprofit newsrooms — especially those that have gone out of business and thus have no surviving brand left to protect.

CEO Peter Bhatia — the man at the center of this story, an esteemed journalist who led major newsrooms in Portland, Cincinnati, and Detroit — has declined to answer my questions on the record for months, instead issuing broad written statements. His actions have been the subject of substantial controversy within the organization long before this closure. I reached out to all six of the Landing’s board members, including the three whose organizations were the newsroom’s major funders — an arrangement some former staffers said hampered the outlet’s governance. Two of the six directed my questions to board chair Ann Stern; she and the other board members ultimately declined all my interview requests.1

When the Landing shuttered in May, I reached out for interviews. An external public relations specialist who said she spoke for the board and Bhatia emailed me: “Given that Houston Landing is in the process of winding down we respectfully decline this interview opportunity.” When I followed up a few weeks later, she wrote, “I appreciate your interest, however the leadership at Houston Landing has basically moved on, and there is no interest in a wrap up story.”

Perhaps the Landing’s leaders have moved on. But for others in the local news world, it’s hard to look past seeing a nonprofit outlet burn through $21 million so quickly. This was one of the largest investments in American local journalism in memory; what made it turn sour so quickly?

Dreaming big

“Houston deserves a news ecosystem as big and bold as it is,” Ann Stern, Rich Kinder, and Laura Arnold wrote in January 2022 about why they’d decided to “collectively invest $20 million for a new nonprofit newsroom in Houston.” (Stern is [now outgoing] president and CEO of the Houston Endowment, Kinder is chairman of the Kinder Foundation, and Arnold is founder and co-chair of Arnold Ventures.)

“Journalism is, at its core, a public service — and Houston could use more of it,” they wrote. “Even Houston, a city rich in local media in every language and on every platform, lacks news coverage at the size and depth appropriate for our chaotic, energetic, sprawling coastal metropolis.”

The funders decided to invest in nonprofit news for Houston “in response to an assessment conducted by the American Journalism Project” — a two-year research endeavor that relied on focus groups, community listening sessions, surveys in four languages, and an analysis of existing news sources in Houston to identify information gaps and news needs. (I reviewed a May 2022 slide deck summarizing findings of this research.)

American Journalism Project slide, May 2022.

That research came out of AJP’s Local Philanthropy Partnerships program. (The Houston Endowment and Arnold Ventures are both listed by AJP as local philanthropy partners.) The city is home to several existing newsrooms, including the Houston Chronicle. The report, however, recommended starting a new, nonprofit Houston newsroom. The three local funders opted to move forward with that solution.2

The Houston Endowment and the Kinder Foundation each committed $7.5 million. Then there was $4 million from Arnold Ventures, $1.5 million from AJP, and $250,000 from the Knight Foundation. The nearly $21 million in seed funding was expected to support the organization from 2023 through 2025.

The vision for this exceptionally well-funded local news startup was ambitious from the outset. It would be one of the largest nonprofit newsrooms in the country, per AJP’s January 2022 announcement.

That announcement named a six-member search committee to choose the Landing’s CEO and editor-in-chief. The Houston-based funders chose the search committee members, AJP chief investment officer Michael Ouimette told me, including three representatives from their own foundations: The Houston Endowment’s Stern; the Kinder Foundation’s Rich Kinder; and Arnold Ventures’ Jeff Cohen, a former Houston Chronicle editor who oversees the philanthropy’s media portfolio and serves on AJP’s board of directors.3

The search committee selected Scott McClelland, retired president of Texas supermarket chain HEB, as the Landing’s CEO. With McClelland, they made two more early hires: Mizanur Rahman, who had been the Houston Chronicle’s investigations editor, as editor-in-chief, and Emily Keeton as chief operating officer.

In September 2022, though, McClelland stepped down unexpectedly. A few months later, he was replaced by Peter Bhatia, who had spent decades in editorial leadership roles at daily newspapers.

The Landing’s board of directors held its first meeting in November 2022. The board had four of the same members as the search committee: The three funder representatives (Stern, Kinder, and Cohen), and Anne Chao, manager of the Houston Asian American Archive at Rice.4

It was a mistake for the Houston Landing to put major funders on its board, someone with knowledge of the early hiring process told me.

“The worry is that you make decisions out of fear that [funders] are not going to renew their initial grants,” they said. That “really erodes your independence.” (This person understood that the grants had been made with the possibility of renewal. Multiple staff described Bhatia assuring them that funders would renew the grants at some level, as recently as this year; other reporting confirms that at least some staff at the Landing expected some level of funding renewal.)

At least one funder, Arnold Ventures, had already decided not to renew its grant months before the board voted to shut the Landing down.

The board composition also raises a governance issue, the person added. “The Landing had a situation where it had a board within a board,” they told me. “It was very clear that the power rested with [funder representatives Stern, Kinder, and Cohen]. The other three didn’t have nearly as much voice or power.”

An editor-in-chief as CEO

Peter Bhatia came to the Landing after a long and celebrated career in legacy newspapers — most recently, as the top editor at the Gannett-owned Detroit Free Press. He led newsrooms to 10 Pulitzer Prizes. Bhatia and Landing board member Jeff Cohen were industry contemporaries, serving as editors and executives of metro dailies in the same era. Bhatia had never led (or fundraised for) a digital-only nonprofit newsroom. He was not from Houston, though editor-in-chief Rahman had deep ties to the city.

The person with knowledge of early hiring recalled being excited about Bhatia’s journalism background. (They said another candidate considered for CEO was a retired executive from a Fortune 500 company.)

In hindsight, though, this person thought choosing a CEO who wasn’t familiar with Houston and didn’t have fundraising experience was a mistake. “We could do the greatest journalism possible, but if you’re not fundraising, that makes your sustainability very, very difficult,” they said.

Bhatia is a “man of integrity,” Joseph Turner, the Landing’s former director of marketing, told me. But he lacked “clarity, and vision, and leadership…in contrast to other CEOs that I had worked for.”

Former Landing staffers I spoke to said Bhatia never became deeply established in Houston and wasn’t an effective fundraiser.

“These nonprofit CEO jobs [are] more than 50% fundraising,” one nonprofit news expert told me. “Clearly, that either wasn’t happening or wasn’t successful.”

This was a “classic example of what one bad apple can do to an entire organization,” one reporter told me. (The same reporter compared the Houston Landing’s board to the shadowy Lumon Industries board in the TV show Severance.)

Bhatia declined requests for an interview and did not respond to detailed written questions. “Houston Landing faced several challenges, but I’m immensely proud of the impact it made during its short time,” he told me in a statement. “We were honored to deliver high-quality, nonpartisan journalism to the greater Houston community. Although there is conjecture about why Houston Landing closed, ultimately, it came down to financial performance. The Houston Landing team gave it our all to make it a success.”

A week later, he emailed me with another statement.

“I gave my all in working to make Houston Landing a success and for it to endure. I accept my responsibility for unsolved issues on my watch, but I was working against some circumstances from the beginning that made it extremely difficult,” Bhatia said. “I will not engage in personal disparagement of anyone associated with Houston Landing and I remain very proud of the work done by the staff in the last year. We made remarkable steps forward.”

The Landing’s scale

“A local news solution must be staffed to produce enough to have impact,” the 2022 AJP slide deck noted. It imagined a newsroom staffed with enough journalists “to generate a critical mass of content that both serves every community in the way that it needs, and commands attention from local decision-makers and funders.”

The report budgeted for a 44-person organization (including 26 newsroom staffers) in the first year, growing to 61 people (including 37 newsroom staffers) by year four.

The Landing didn’t grow at quite that clip, but it staffed up relatively quickly. At launch in 2023, it had more than 30 “reporters, photojournalists, editors, digital specialists” and others. Six months later, the staff topped 40, and eight new hires were announced in fall 2024.

Salaries were generous, by industry standards. According to the Landing’s 2023 990, Bhatia’s salary was $450,000; Rahman’s was $245,455; and other C-suite staff made well over $100,000.

The Landing’s revenue in 2023, per the 990, was $3.2 million. Expenses were $5.8 million, with executive compensation and other salaries making up more than two-thirds of that.

I asked Ouimette if, from AJP’s perspective, the Landing’s proposed pace of scaling up and spending was a strategic mistake. He said no: “The size and complexity of the Greater Houston area’s population and the strength of its philanthropic and business sectors validate both the need for and viability of strong nonprofit local news serving Houstonians.”

The AJP report also specified a target “original output frequency” for the newsroom: 140 stories per week, produced by a staff of 65. (The report noted that the more than 200-person Chronicle had an output of 555 stories per week.) At that rate, the Landing would have published 7,280 stories in a year.

The Landing, with its staff of 40-plus, published 936 stories in 2024.

Image from the Houston Landing impact report, 2024.

Cadence “was an ongoing conversation” at the Landing, the union member said. Many staffers came to the Landing believing it would prioritize time-intensive investigative reporting. The Landing “never found the right way” to address concerns about “needing more content, needing to keep the website fresh — things that are very normal and key parts of keeping a digital news site relevant.”

All seed funding, little revenue

The Landing spent, hired, and expanded like a newsroom that expected to get more money.

Instead, the seed funders and board members chose not to renew their own funding, and ultimately pulled the plug. And the organization consistently struggled to generate revenue.

Columbia Journalism Review reported that the Landing spent $7.9 million in 2024 — $2 million more than it brought in. It also reported that the Landing generated only $430,000 in new revenue last year, including $25,000 from major donors.

“Even when you have an up-front grant,” the nonprofit news expert I spoke with told me, “you’ve got to be really thankful for that grant the first day, and then on day two, pretend like you don’t have it and hustle as hard to diversify your revenue sources.”

One source of revenue was off the table from the beginning. The AJP report recommended a news outlet to fill local gaps should “make content available free” and described paywalls as making local reporting inaccessible. The funders made that commitment right away, and Landing leadership stuck to it. “Our content will always be free,” Rahman wrote in February 2023. The Landing’s website affirmed, “As a nonprofit newsroom we want to serve as many people as possible. That’s why our content is free — with no paywalls and no subscription fees.”

“Many organizations in our portfolio are generating high membership revenues without a paywall,” AJP’s Ouimette told me. “Given the initial mission of the organization and ongoing audience trends, we don’t think a recommendation against a paywall was a mistake.” He also pointed to recent Pew research suggesting few Americans pay for news when they hit paywalls.

A budget from the AJP slide deck suggested that the Landing would bring in $1 million in revenue in its first year (including “membership, major donors, local foundations, national foundations, corporate partners”), and $2.5 million in its second year.

American Journalism Project slide, 2022.

The 2024 impact report said the Landing had just over $80,000 in total membership revenue.

In some ways, the Landing’s seed funding became a liability, a staffer told me. The Landing had raised so much in seed funding that it was challenging to make the case to other funders that it needed more.

A product staffer also said the Landing’s struggle to build an audience (more on that below) hurt its ability to generate revenue. They recalled a fundraising staffer describing the site’s low pageviews as being “too nominal to be worth selling” to prospective donors.

Sponsorships, too, were difficult to attract with such a limited audience: “People that dole out huge sums of money for sponsorships don’t do it for 12,000 newsletter subscribers,” the product staffer told me.

Firings and unionization

Bhatia abruptly fired editor-in-chief Rahman and investigative reporter Alex Stuckey in January 2024 as part of an organizational “reset.”

“We’re doing good work, we’re doing good journalism,” Bhatia told Stuckey in a meeting she recorded, “but we’re basically putting out a newspaper on the web. And that’s not a recipe for success for us for the long term, nor is it a recipe for sustainability. And in order to accomplish that, I just feel like there needs to be some fairly dramatic changes.”

Bhatia said the firings were solely his decision. “It is my belief that we need new ideas to execute our mission…effectively in the digital space,” he told me at the time. “Our coverage needs to be more original, distinctive and not available elsewhere.”

The Landing was “behind on embracing all the tools digital offers us, such as video, data visualization, [and] interactive story treatments,” Bhatia added. In an interview with Texas Monthly, he cited The New York Times’ 2012 multimedia story “Snow Fall” as the type of journalism he wanted the Landing to produce.

The newsroom, overwhelmingly loyal to Rahman, unionized six weeks after the firings. The union created its own Twitter and Instagram pages and sometimes publicly called out management. The union’s social media accounts didn’t have many followers, but one union member recalled members of the fundraising team telling them in a staff meeting around mid-2024 that these posts were hurting fundraising. So “we cooled off on using social media and public-facing collective action,” they said. “And during that time, there was still no money brought in.”

The person said it was not “a complete impossibility” that union actions made it harder to fundraise. But, they said, “if shining a light on the actions of our management — and the missteps or the miscalculations that they made; the way that workers were mistreated — is a bad thing, or is something that contributed to it being harder to raise money, maybe we should take a look at the actions that spurred those social media posts in the first place.”

Landing business staff involved in membership, development, fundraising, and finance did not respond to my interview requests.

Who was the Landing for?

From the start, the Landing was pulled in two different directions to meet different perceived “critical information needs” in Houston.

AJP’s proposal envisioned the Landing delivering the accountability journalism of a Texas Tribune or Marshall Project alongside the service journalism of an Outlier Media. That was the type of news the Houstonians surveyed said they wanted.

American Journalism Project slide, May 2022.

In 2024, Bhatia told me the Landing aimed to fill the gap between mainstream media and ethnic/alternative/community press with “a mix of strong accountability journalism and by bringing coverage and community engagement to the city’s underserved neighborhoods.”

The Landing delivered examples of both of these kinds of coverage. In a memo I reviewed, Manny García, the Landing’s editor-in-chief since April 2024, referred to the Landing’s education coverage as “a differentiator in our news ecosystem.” A 2024 investigation into suspensions of homeless students led the school district to crack down and consider legislative action. The Landing’s housing reporting revealed that landlords did not repair hurricane damage to public housing, which led to calls for increased regulation. The Landing reported extensively on the largely Latino housting development Colony Ridge and ran accountability stories on politics, public safety, and immigration.

The Landing’s service journalism, meanwhile, was exemplified by explainers and guides (some in Spanish) demystifying how the Houston Public Library could help people become U.S. citizens or apply for food assistance after Hurricane Beryl. The Landing profiled the woman behind a 2026 FIFA World Cup poster, highlighted Houstonians who connected over a knitting project, and ran photo essays celebrating everything from Iftar to rodeo season.

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Houston Landing (@hou_landing)

“Our team always punched above its weight with the goal to serve Houston,” García told me in a statement.

Still, the “both/and” approach — combined with a lack of clear leadership from Bhatia — gave the news outlet a split sense of its editorial identity, former staffers told me.

The dual priorities and catch-all phrase “underserved communities” also contributed to confusion over the Landing’s audience. Understandings of the organization’s actual and target audiences shifted over time, and tended to vary by team, by beat, and by editor.

Conflict over these two editorial directions has come up at other news nonprofits. But it’s not impossible to do both types of journalism well as a local news nonprofit. “Many of the organizations in our portfolio are successfully pursuing investigative reporting in addition to service reporting,” said AJP’s Ouimette, pointing to outlets like Mirror Indy, The City, and Outlier Media.

But the Landing’s execution for pursuing dual priorities “blew up in our faces,” the union member and former staffer told me. “The way that we tried to go about doing them both, ultimately, was a disservice to everyone in the long run, because we were spreading ourselves too thin, too fast.”

Joe Turner, a lifelong Houstonian, joined the Landing as director of marketing two years after the research that laid the organization’s foundation. He served in that role for most of 2024 before family and health conflicts contributed to him being let go (on what he described as amicable terms).

The Landing was the first news organization Turner had worked for; he’d previously done marketing for consumer brands and nonprofits. When he joined in February 2024, he believed the Landing had two urgent marketing goals: brand awareness and audience acquisition. Each goal would require engaging and retaining different audiences.

Turner believed he was hired to focus on the first goal, brand awareness. AJP’s founding report identified underserved communities (including low-income inner-city residents and non-English speakers) as an opportunity.

“You have to make them aware of who you are, and then you have to build credibility and trust with them,” Turner said. “If they don’t care about the news, why would they care about our news?”

At the same time, the Landing’s focus on accountability coverage and pursuit of tangible impact in Houston pushed it toward a different audience: power brokers and influential Houstonians, including civic leaders, politicians, and board members of other high-profile nonprofits. Reaching that audience meant competing in a saturated news market for people who already read other news.

There was another wrinkle. In practice, Turner said, the Landing’s data in the first half of 2024 suggested the people the Landing was actually reaching primarily fell into a third bucket: educated, upper-middle class urban Houstonians.

“The majority of the people that were reading our work were not people in underserved communities,” he said. “They were not minorities. They were educated, middle to upper-middle class, urban Houstonians.” This third group was precisely the audience that the AJP report had determined was already well-served by local news in Houston.

The former product staffer echoed Turner. The Landing’s audience consisted of “affluent, wealthier people,” they told me, “and that wasn’t the goal.”

Impact or audience?

From the Houston Landing’s earliest days, impact — not pageviews — was the metric for success.

“We decided early on that we had no interest in drumming up pageviews by publishing stories that offer little news value,” the Landing’s then-managing editor, John Tedesco, wrote in June 2023, the month the site launched. “Instead, we talked about focusing on a more important metric — impact.”

The fall 2024 strategic plan stated the organization would “measure Houston Landing by the change we create, in policy, in law and in practice,” and named “impact” as one of its four strategic pillars (alongside “audience focus,” “crucial information,” and “financial sustainability”). Its 2024 impact report records “over 200 impact points.”

But “there was never really a consensus of what impact was,” the product staffer told me. Rahman had a clear view of what it meant that most reporters shared, they said; losing Rahman, for that contingent, amounted to another loss of direction for the newsroom.

The Landing was not alone among nonprofit news outlets in wanting to use impact to define its success. Impact is, however, notoriously difficult to define and measure — not to mention achieve. What’s more, deemphasizing pageviews risks disregarding a tool for identifying a gap between what your target audience have said they want, and what they may actually read.

In April 2024, a year before the Landing closed, a Poynter report by Rick Edmonds described the Houston Landing as “not seeming as far along as [two experts involved in grantmaking and others] would have hoped in terms of audience numbers.” (At the time, Bhatia and AJP’s Ouimette disputed that statement and said the Landing was exceeding internal audience targets.)

Poynter pointed to Block Club Chicago and New York’s The City as examples of success “in building impressive audiences after years of focus.” But it suggested standout nonprofit news outlets delivering impactful reporting and building an audience, like The Baltimore Banner and Lookout Local, share two qualities: They’re paywalled, and broad in scope. “Tough-minded journalism is at the core of both, but it’s surrounded by softer community news content,” Edmonds wrote. “The result is something like a traditional newspaper mix but in digital format; an attractive bundle for a varied set of readers.”

The Houston Chronicle, which couples weather and sports coverage with a nationally recognized investigations unit that doubled in size last year, falls into this category.

The Chronicle is mentioned 31 times in the AJP report. Introduced as “the ‘paper of record,’ but for whom?,” the Hearst-owned metro daily is characterized as generally covering news from a business perspective rather than a public service perspective. The slide deck describes the Chronicle as staffed by overextended reporters who leave Houston’s vast suburbs largely uncovered.

American Journalism Project slide, May 2022.

The Landing was established with a group of core Chronicle staff (including Rahman and Stuckey). One of the Landing’s six board members, Jeff Cohen, was a top Chronicle editor from 2002 to 2018. His time as editor-in-chief included steering the newsroom through significant layoffs and restructuring in 2007 and 2009.

A February 2023 piece by Rahman provided a window into editorial leadership’s early vision for the Landing’s place in the city’s media ecosystem. “The Landing is not competing with anyone — not the Houston Chronicle, local TV stations, or other statewide news organizations,” he wrote. The Landing would steer clear of clickbait, and would only cover breaking news “when it really matters to the Houston region.”

And there was some news the Landing wouldn’t write about: “We don’t plan on covering the daily developments of your favorite local sports team. We won’t write about the latest hot restaurant to open.”

“Frankly, many local news outlets excel at offering that kind of information,” he added. “Our goal is to focus more on the gaps in news coverage like investigative reporting and coverage of our growing suburbs.” So the Landing deliberately avoided designated sports, weather, or food reporters. When the Landing did publish weather-related coverage, those stories tended to perform well. Four of the Landing’s 10 most-read stories of 2024 related to Hurricane Beryl, and the Landing’s best months for pageviews were both linked to weather-related breaking news — Beryl in July 2024, the derecho in May 2024.

When the Landing launched its new strategic plan in fall 2024, Bhatia wrote that it was “meant to ensure our newsroom stays focused on you, our audience.” The plan described “a new focus on Houston-area residents of color under age 40″ and “new editorial and audience initiatives, including investments in new platforms and content in Spanish.”

“Even after it was said that we were going to be trying to target Houstonians of color under the age of 40,” the staffer and union member told me, “there was no real planning or backbone of how to accomplish that.”

According to the Landing’s 2024 impact report, it gained 2,352 Instagram followers in the year — its “fastest growing account across all platforms.” Its flagship newsletter, The Launchpad, had 11,545 subscribers. Houston has a population of about 2.4 million people, and a metro area of 7.8 million.

Image from the Houston Landing impact report, 2024.

A fractured Landing

Turner compared the Landing to a fraternity house where everyone brings their own furniture, none of it matches, and no one is willing to move theirs out. “There was no motif; there was no feng shui,” he said.

The Landing comprised people with experience in one (or two) of three different worlds: startups, nonprofits, and news. Those three types did not always gel. And the absence of unifying leadership left people on different pages.

“There was a lot of tugging and pulling from different directions, [and] a lack of clarity about how business and operations was supporting the newsroom and helping to amplify the coverage and acquire new audience members,” Turner said. “And I think the newsroom had a really disconnected view of just how important the business and operations side was, at least in the early days.”

Turner, and other Landing staff, emphasized that the Landing’s teams — product, marketing, audience — were generally siloed from one another. (The newsroom and operations teams were also in separate wings of the building.) When those teams came together to debate strategy (if they came together at all), it often wasn’t clear which idea had actually won.

Most people entered meetings with their guards up, and the atmosphere was combative enough that it was difficult to get any new idea off the ground before it was shot down. “No one could ever agree on why, how, what, when, where,” Turner said.

The product staffer added that there was “a lot of big-picture, aspirational thinking,” yet “the step from the aspiration to the action…was completely missing.”

Seemingly straightforward tasks, like making the site searchable, became bogged down by disagreements over how to tag articles. (One person suggested that articles be tagged based on the feeling they evoked.)

“There was all of this ego from high up: ‘We’re going to make the future of news,’” the product staffer told me. But “they all just wanted to run the show, and it was a nightmare.”

“Let the Landing be a teachable moment”

Today, Houston is down a local newsroom and dozens of journalists — many of them young reporters who moved across the country to take jobs at the Landing. Of that $20 million, “the amount of previously committed funds that remain unspent after severance payments is expected to be less than $2 million, and there are still expenses remaining,” according to the representative of the board.

“What’s frustrating for me, and I know frustrating for other staff members, is there’s really no sense of responsibility being placed, even on the person who was paid to take responsibility of the company,” the product staffer said. “Twenty million could have changed so many lives — like, it is so much money — and it was just squandered for somebody’s ego trip.”

García praised the Landing’s journalists for doing strong work to the end, even after learning that the organization would shutter. “They cranked out stories, through the tears and the laughter, all while applying for jobs and, for our Guild members, negotiating a severance package,” he said. “The newsroom stepped on the gas even harder in the final weeks, breaking scoops and landing projects from the 50th anniversary of the Fall of Saigon to an environmental investigation and we closed our doors with an immigration project reported from Houston and Mexico.”

In the shutdown announcement, the Landing’s board indicated it was in early talks with The Texas Tribune about the possibility of bringing a local newsroom to Houston as part of its effort to establish a network of local newsrooms — but it’s unclear what, if anything, will come of that idea. Texas Tribune CEO Sonal Shah told me earlier this month that they’re “still exploring options.” Meanwhile, a new Local Journalist Index released last week counts just 3.9 Local Journalist Equivalents per 100,000 people in Harris County (which comprises most of Houston), and about five per 100,000 in nearby Fort Bend County — indicators of how underserved the city and its suburbs remain, relative to the area’s enormous population.

While Ouimette held firm on AJP’s original paywall and scaling recommendations for the Landing, he felt there were certainly other lessons to be learned from the organization’s challenges. “Successful nonprofit news startups require a strong alignment of capital, talent, and strategy,” he said. “What happened in Houston reinforces key lessons that shape our strategy: the value of building deep relationships with communities, the importance of maintaining focus on sustainability, and the need for strong leaders with vision and ability to build strong, impactful enterprises.”

The union member hopes the Landing’s failure doesn’t discourage others in the nonprofit news world. “I don’t want it to scare people away from the belief in community-driven, nonprofit news,” they said.

“The Landing’s failure is scary. It’s flashy news; it’s $20 million down the drain; I totally get that,” they added. But they felt this failure was fundamentally specific to the Landing — especially issues of leadership and management — and did not need to ring alarm bells for nonprofit news as a whole.

“I think that we should let the Landing be a teachable moment,” they said, “and not a red flag warning sign that something is necessarily wrong.”

Adobe Stock
  1. Stern issued a single public statement when the closure was announced: “We are proud of the Landing’s coverage of Greater Houston and continue to believe deeply in the need for more free, independent journalism in our region. This decision was difficult but necessary. Houston Landing’s reporting has made a meaningful impact in the community, but it struggled to find its long-term financial footing.” [↩]
  2. The Houston Landing wasn’t part of AJP’s “startup studio,” which has incubated news organizations like Signal Ohio and Mirror Indy. Instead, AJP provided a grant, served as fiscal sponsor while the new initiative awaited tax-exempt status, and offered some other support before leadership was hired, said Michael Ouimette, AJP’s chief investment officer. [↩]
  3. The other three members were Anne Chao, manager of the Houston Asian American Archive at Rice; Rice’s now-president, Reginald DesRoches; and Armando Perez, executive VP of HEB Houston. [↩]
  4. The Landing’s other two board members were Algenita Davis, of Central Houston, and Alex Lopez Negrete, of Lopez Negrete Communications. [↩]

Get Nieman Lab’s Daily Digest

The most important stories about journalism and the future of news, delivered to your inbox every afternoon.

Sophie Culpepper is a staff writer covering local news at Nieman Lab. You can reach her via email ([email protected]), Signal (sculpepp.28), or Bluesky DM.

The latest from Nieman Lab

Press Forward gave $20 million to 205 local newsrooms over two years. Here’s how some of them spent it.

The unrestricted funding helped small outlets plug holes and try new things, but publishers ran up against the limits of what two $50,000 grants could accomplish, especially when it came to hiring.