News Diaries: How a Minnesota mom and minister “blew past” her screen time limits when ICE came to her city

How Instagram, public radio, Signal, WhatsApp, the local paper of record, and local TV do — and don’t — fit into one Minneapolis resident’s daily news habits.

To say that the staff of Nieman Lab consume more news than the average American would be an understatement. And if you’re a Nieman Lab reader, chances are you’re a news junkie like us.

Most of the people that most news organizations are trying to reach, however, are not news junkies. Nieman Lab founder Josh Benton likes to remind us that the average American received zero push notifications from a news organization in the last week. Only 16% of Americans pay for news.

So we often discuss how we might better see beyond our own news habits. In this new occasional series, “News Diaries,” we’ll talk with people who are not professional journalists about their habits for finding and consuming news, and what counts as news to them. We’re interested in the ways news does, or doesn’t, fit into people’s lives, and the roles traditional news outlets, informal networks, and everything in between play in keeping people informed.

For the first entry in this series, I spoke with (a different) Sophie, 37. She’s a minister and mom of two who lives in Minneapolis, her hometown. We talked in mid-February, toward the end of the Trump administration’s “Operation Metro Surge,” which sent more than 3,000 federal agents into Minnesota to arrest undocumented immigrants; agents killed two American citizens.

My conversation with Sophie, lightly edited for length and clarity, is below.

Culpepper: What sources of local information have you been relying on day to day for very concrete, practical stuff?

Sophie: I primarily see updates on Instagram. That’s what I’m checking most often. [Before this], I had mostly signed off of social media because it was too distracting. But because there was such a flood of information and things were changing so rapidly, and I wanted to stay on top of what was happening, I’ve gotten back onto social media in a much more consistent way.

I already followed a handful of local accounts, such as Minnesota Public Radio, the Star Tribune, Axios Twin Cities. We also have a couple of [hyperlocal] outlets — one’s called Southwest Voices. I already followed MPR and the Star Tribune on social media, because I always want to see what’s going on in my city, but I’ve been following them more.

Culpepper: In terms of checking Instagram, do you have time of day habits? Has it been kind of constant, or just once in the morning? Do you have to set limits?

Sophie: It’s been constant. I have blown past all the limits I set for myself.

My screen time [before 2026] was about two and a half hours a day on average. That’s what my Apple screen time alert would tell me. It went up to six and a half hours a day. Now it’s hovering around four and a half, [including] Signal chats and my WhatsApp groups. I’ve had days where I’ll turn it off, but [generally] I’m checking all the time.

Culpepper: Are the Signal chats and WhatsApp groups neighborhood-specific, or do they have another organizing principle?

Sophie: It started with neighborhood groups. I was already in a WhatsApp chat with over 250 moms in my neighborhood, and some of that migrated onto Signal. I’m in a clergy group, and that has been the source of immediate updates. I found out about the death of Renée Good and Alex Pretti from Signal chats before it was posted on any other published source. So that’s definitely been the place for very immediate breaking news, as well as just day-to-day organizing and connection.

The moms chat was sometimes really active before, but now, on days where I turn it off or don’t look for awhile, I come back to, like, 100 messages, whereas normally it would be [maybe] five to 10 messages. Even [for] something like a regular school event, the way that we’re talking about it now is impacted by the presence of ICE in the community.

[The moms group] was already a group people turned to for support and organizing and sourcing donations. I think because we were already good at communicating and organizing, we had good networks in place that have really ramped up in activity and focus in recent weeks.

Culpepper: Does that mean coordination of ICE watch groups, response to where agents are in a specific moment, getting resources to people?

Sophie: There are groups doing ICE watch, but there’s a really wide range of activities happening on the ground, so different chats organize around different types of activities. For the moms and the clergy groups I’m part of, ICE watch is not the primary activity — it’s response and coordinated actions and community support and mutual aid.

Culpepper: When you say that the way people talk about school events has changed — how has it changed? Is it more cautious?

Sophie: There’s pervasive fear in the community, and therefore need for additional protections and plans. There’s just a whole new set of needs to attend to for daily life in order to protect and keep people safe.

We have kids on virtual learning. So, for example, planning the class Valentine’s Day party, [the school] asked us to figure out if we have virtual learners in the class and how to incorporate them in planning the party. Basic, everyday things — this is impacting all of it.

Culpepper: Are there any times that are noteworthy to you where you’ve gotten any kind of false alarm or information that you thought was real, and was not?

Sophie: Not that I can think of. I do think people can be quite reactionary if they think ICE is present in a neighborhood, but it generally turns out to be accurate.

The groups I’m in have been pretty attentive to not wanting to spread misinformation. People will say, “Hey, I’m hearing this, but it’s not verified.” Or somebody will share information and somebody else will say, “Can you verify that?” or “What other information do you have?” There’s been [more] attentiveness to not wanting to spread misinformation than there has been misinformation spreading.

People look to share visual evidence, photos or videos. That happened when Renée Good was murdered. It came through on the chats as just an alert: “Hey, something has happened. We think ICE shot an observer.” Then someone would say, “I saw a video of it,” and then video would come out. It rolls out step by step, but yes, definitely looking for photo/video evidence, or people just being able to verify in communication, like “I’m seeing this happen right now,” compared to, “my friend is reporting that this is happening right now.”

We will hear stories about what’s happening inside the Whipple Building, which is the detention center on the ground here. Or, we heard reports like, “Governor Walz thinks there’s going to be a drawdown of agents, but we don’t really have any news on that yet.”

I think [these are examples] where people are looking to [local news reporting for verification]. So we will be talking [in the community] about what’s going on inside of Whipple. Then when someone actually pulls together a story and posts it, we all say, “See, look, this lines up with what we were hearing on the ground.” The local news stories that involve elected officials or journalists or lawyers or people who have been able to gain access to a space where we don’t have eyes on the ground, like Whipple or other detention centers — that type of reporting has been really helpful. It validates the general conversation that’s happening with some additional supported journalistic evidence.

Culpepper: So it sounds like local news functions as a bit of a verification layer. You have conversations about what people are hearing, and then if there is a reported story where there is access to people who would have “official” information, that is a really helpful thing to see as a news consumer.

Sophie: Yes.

Another layer that has felt really meaningful or important to us on the ground is to have those stories to share with people outside of Minnesota.

We know that these things are happening because we’re in the thick of it. But having quality reported stories we can share out and send to friends and family, that’s been a really important element of what journalism is doing right now.

Culpepper: Has there been a distinction for you between national reporters coming in and the local reporters who are already here? And part of the reason I ask that is because there is often some kind of resentment that can be associated with national journalists parachuting in, especially to cover news with a tragic aspect, and I don’t know if, in this case, there is more appreciation for getting the word out, or if it feels at all parasitic.

Sophie: It’s complicated. We want more people to see what’s really happening here, but we also have to be really cautious, because people are being targeted for helping their neighbors. There has been journalism that has exposed or risked people’s safety, and [it’s] a challenging line to walk: What do we share with reporters, and what do we not share?

So it’s less a concern about national journalists or outsiders [per se], and more like, what are [journalists] going to reveal that might harm, while still wanting attention on the harm that ICE is causing. I think people really trusted local journalists, and have leaned on local reporting, but there’s been some really good national or international coverage that we feel has brought good attention. So it’s been tricky.

There was a really interesting Vogue article about mom chats, and all the first stories that they share are from the mom chat that I am in. It’s literally my neighborhood mom chat. And once that article came out, all of us were sharing it around with such pride. It was nice to see our experience represented well, and to say, “Here, look, this is who we are. This is what we’re doing.” It’s just one little piece of the whole experience right now, but there was something validating about seeing our experience written about and held up as a model of community engagement.

Culpepper: Anything else you would say about your personal experience, or how you think about your own role in sharing trusted information?

Sophie: Because I’ve lived outside of Minnesota for many years, I have a lot of friends and family that live out of state, and I am their connection to what’s happening here, and they’ll [generally] trust what I say is happening. ​​I have felt a personal responsibility to amplify what’s happening to [them]. Part of the reason I got back on to social media was to share my perspective of what was happening and to point towards effective resources, whether that was accurate reporting or ways to help out, like places to donate or contribute and support.

I have a private Instagram account, I’m not sharing this information publicly, I’m not sharing it as a journalist — I’m just [bearing] witness to what I see happening on the ground in my community and how it’s impacting us. A lot of people have reached out to say, “thanks for sharing,” “I’m only seeing this because of you,” and I’ve been able to raise a lot of money that way to redirect to mutual aid efforts.

Culpepper: Going back to some of the more formal, traditional local news, like MPR and the Star Tribune — you mentioned following their accounts, among others, on Instagram. How much would you say you are consuming what they report via Instagram versus taking an extra step and going to their websites? Is that a regular habit for you?

Sophie: Public radio has been my primary news source for many years, both national and local. I regularly listen to Minnesota Public Radio when I’m driving. I click through their stories on social media, I also have the Minnesota Public Radio app, or I pull up their website. Some days [I check] probably a couple times a day, and [sometimes] I don’t look at anything for a day or two, but I’m catching a lot of the headlines via their app or website.

The Star Tribune, a little less so, because their paywalls are funky — even though my family has a subscription. I grew up with the Minneapolis, or now it’s called the Minnesota Star Tribune. But it was just called the Star Tribune for a long time. Anyways, I grew up with that newspaper, like I would come home from college, and my dad always had it, and I had free time, so I would sit and actually read the newspaper — he still has a paper subscription. So I feel like, in general, it’s the newspaper I grew up with, and it was always fairly trusted, but I mostly consume it online.

I do check The New York Times headlines fairly regularly. That’s my primary national news source.

Culpepper: When you say your family has a Star Tribune subscription, are you talking about your dad and your parents, or your own family?

Sophie: Yeah, my dad has a subscription to the paper itself. I do not. [Laughs.] As a millennial, I’ve never had a paper subscription.

My parents are divorced. My dad has a subscription to the paper physically; my mom has a subscription to the Star Tribune online, and so when I need to access something, I just use her login to view whatever is behind a paywall.

Some of their breaking news coverage on what’s been happening locally has not been behind a paywall, so they’ve also been deciding what they think needs to be available to everyone. Which is also why I really love public radio, because everything’s available, and I’m a member of public radio, and so I financially support it, but that’s not necessary to access their material.

Culpepper: Well, we at Nieman Lab are very interested in people’s relationships to paywalls generally. So this is really interesting to hear — you’re someone who has a pre-existing habit and relationship with public radio, but also at a time when you really need more information than usual, and the information is higher stakes, you are to some extent relying on a paywalled source, but it sounds like the paywall can be a little bit of a barrier.

Sophie: For sure.

Culpepper: Are there any examples that we haven’t already talked about, or that you want to elaborate on further, of something where a formal news source was more helpful to you, and something where an “informal” news source was more helpful to you, to just getting you information you needed?

Sophie: I don’t have a Twitter or a Bluesky account or any of the more rapid social media platforms, but occasionally links from there are shared in local chats. That’s one way information is spreading beyond people that immediately follow those accounts [typically of] local journalists or local activists or council members — somebody in some kind of established capacity.

People have also started creating new accounts to hold some of the relevant information, especially around mutual aid and different needs in the community. There’s an Instagram called Minnesota Neighbors — it’s minnesota_neighbors. And I know some of the people behind that, and so they formed that as a way to centralize and house information. [Culpepper side note: Also see this CJR analysis of how the Facebook pages of Twin Cities-serving nonprofits acted as sources of civic information during the height of the immigration raids.]

I’m trying to think if there’s anything else. The last two months are such a blur. I’m thinking back to what all has been relevant. Um, I don’t ever watch televised news, if that’s helpful information.

Culpepper: Me neither, to be honest.

Sophie: Because I know that my parents do. And so I think that’s just an interesting media habit of note. Like, my mom always has the local news on at her place. And I don’t even have a TV on the main level of my floor, let alone cable — like, I don’t have a television subscription where I ever could turn that on, or I know to turn that on.

Early on in this Operation Metro Surge, it felt like those of us on the ground were getting our information from really direct sources and personal experience. And my mom was in Arizona (she lives there part time) and talking to a neighbor who primarily gets their news from cable news networks. And so when my mom was sharing how things were on the ground — ICE is going into daycares and they’re waiting outside of businesses, and they don’t have warrants — the neighbor was like, “I don’t see any of that happening.” This was around when Renée Good was killed. My mom’s like, “Well, yeah, because cable news isn’t sharing the same information that’s circulating among parents in the community.”

And so it felt like there was a really big disconnect early on between television and cable news, and our on-the-ground experience. I don’t know if that’s changed, because I don’t watch it, but just worth noting that I’ve barely seen any cable or local TV news media about what’s happening, because it’s just not in my habit to watch it.

Culpepper: I’m always thinking about television as a blind spot for me bigger picture, because it’s so outside my own habits. So maybe if I end up being able to talk to someone where TV is core to their news habits, I can get more context on that. (Reader, if that’s you, email me so we can chat!)

Sophie: I think that would be so, so interesting to look at, how that has shaped people’s experiences if they’re primarily getting their news from television.

Culpepper: Local TV versus cable is also an interesting distinction.

Sophie: I will say one interesting crossover is Jana Shortal, who’s a television news reporter on KARE11. She uses Instagram very effectively. She has this clip at the end of her program called “One Last Thing.” And she does a little wrap-up moment. And I think she just brings a lot of humanity to her reporting in that one last word — it’s kind of a little opinion piece, or she’ll share a more story or opinion-based message at the end, versus traditional reporting, and then she’ll post those online. And so those little clips — it seems like they are being shared around a lot. And so even though I’m not tuning into KARE11 Nightly News, I’m seeing a lot of clips from her show get shared around. And she also just has a lot of respect here as a local journalist.

Culpepper: Super interesting.

Zooming out, we started with you mentioning how much more, not just news, but screen time this Operation Metro Surge has kind of forced onto your life. You’re, I imagine, too much in the thick of it to really know how this will play out. But do you have any reflections on how your long-term habits of consuming local information and news may have been changed by this experience?

Sophie: Yeah. I think there are connections that have come out of this intense moment that will be maintained for the long term to more local networks of people, [including] on social media.

I’ll probably increase my financial contribution to public radio because I’m so grateful. Hopefully my screen time will go down. I’m going to have to recalibrate some habits around that. But, I mean, I wasn’t really using Signal until the fall…now Signal is my primary conversation platform. I don’t think that will go away. I think Signal will continue to be a place where people are sharing information, and [a] top source of community connection.

Culpepper: Because you’ve mentioned the moms group, is there anything — any habits that have developed, or even protections you’ve tried to implement — around kids getting information?

Sophie: Well, because my kids are fairly young, I’ve had to be pretty mindful about what I share with them. They obviously know these are not normal times.

It’s kind of nice because, again, we don’t just have television on. They don’t just naturally see news stories. But my six-year-old — we got in the car and the radio just turns on to Minnesota Public Radio, and that’s where he heard about Liam Ramos being taken. And he was like, “Mom, they took a five-year-old?” And I was like, yep.

That probably wasn’t something I would have explained to him, because it would have felt too close. But he heard it because the radio turned on before I could stop it. They definitely overhear things, and then I have to figure out how to explain. So it’s been a balance of how much do I tell them up front, and how much do I respond to because they’ve just heard it. But because it’s so prevalent — I knew they would hear about Renée Good at school or that something would come up. And so I’ve preemptively told them about certain things, but in really vague terms, or in age-appropriate terms.

We go to church right around the corner from where they killed Alex Pretti. So there’s no avoiding it, because we drive by that site on our way to church.

Adobe Stock

Get Nieman Lab’s Daily Digest

The most important stories about journalism and the future of news, delivered to your inbox every afternoon.

Sophie Culpepper is a staff writer covering local news at Nieman Lab. You can reach her via email ([email protected]), Signal (sculpepp.28), or Bluesky DM.
Part of a series   News Diaries

The latest from Nieman Lab

Press Forward gave $20 million to 205 local newsrooms over two years. Here’s how some of them spent it.

The unrestricted funding helped small outlets plug holes and try new things, but publishers ran up against the limits of what two $50,000 grants could accomplish, especially when it came to hiring.