What We’re Reading

We keep an eye out for the most interesting stories about Labby subjects: digital media, startups, the web, journalism, strategy, and more.

The Philadelphia Inquirer / No Author

The Philadelphia Inquirer is killing off (almost) all of its comments sections →

They survive on sports stories. “Commenting on Inquirer.com was long ago hijacked by a small group of trolls who traffic in racism, misogyny, and homophobia. This group comprises a tiny fraction of the Inquirer.com audience. But its impact is disproportionate and enduring.”

What else we were reading on February 1

Press Gazette / Charlotte Tobitt

The slow-journalism site Tortoise has nearly 50,000 paying subscribers →

Up about 50% in 2020. “The business lost all its non-subscriptions revenue in early March last year because the Covid-19 pandemic stopped all live events from going ahead. But that revenue has restarted after switching to virtual events. A big part of the Tortoise model was its Thinkins, which are meetings with members and guests on a chosen topic at which only statements can be made, no questions.”

Jamlab / Benon Oluka

Africa has its first institute for investigative journalism, in Uganda →

Solomon Serwanjja and Raymond Mujuni “now jointly lead an entity [the African Institute for Investigative Journalism] whose work benefits not just their two rival TV networks, but other media houses in Uganda and beyond that seek to improve their investigative journalism.”

Digiday / Seb Joseph

Why Denmark’s biggest news site cut its reliance on Google’s tech →

“No Google Analytics means no middleman between Ekstra Bladet and data from its site, whether its views or subscription conversions…Ekstra Bladet is now in full control of the entire data flow around its site, meaning execs can wrangle it all much easier.”

Riyadh Bureau / Ahmed Al Omran

Can Saudi Arabia’s newspapers survive without a government bailout? (Or with one?) →

“…most of the censorship is self-imposed within the newspapers where top editors practically act as gatekeepers. The editors have a vested interest in not crossing any red lines because the ministry’s consent is required for their appointment and they could easily lose their job if they are not performing their gatekeeping mission properly.”

Ad Age / Mike Juang

Google thinks it’s found the replacement for cookies →

“The tech giant says FLoC, which stands for a ‘Federated Learning of Cohorts,’ could replace third-party cookies, and says ‘advertisers can expect to see at least 95% of the conversions per dollar spent when compared to cookie-based advertising,’ for reaching in-market and affinity audiences.”

The Wall Street Journal / Sahil Patel

Facebook is building brand-safety controls for News Feed advertisers →

One more way advertisers can decide not to put their ads next to news stories. “One of the concerns for advertisers has been a lack of visibility and control over how and where their ads appear on Facebook, especially in the news feed, where ads can show up next to content or posts by users that they feel are objectionable.”

Poynter / Harrison Mantas

Fact-checkers are already fighting the spread of falsehoods from Telegram →

“There was a dynamic that WhatsApp, for example, limited the possibility to forward messages so many times, and Facebook and YouTube reacted to the spreading of COVID-19 misinformation with deleting stuff…And so many people migrated to Telegram because they said, ‘Oh, on Telegram we are free. Nobody is censoring what we say.'”

The Guardian / Vanessa Thorpe

Boris Johnson is poised to appoint the former editor of the Daily Mail to oversee the BBC →

“For many who work in public service broadcasting, it is the nightmare that refuses to go away. Could Paul Dacre, former editor of the Daily Mail, really now have the chance to oversee the statutory regulation of British TV and telecommunications? The Brexiter and longtime bête noire of liberals and leftwingers is understood to be very close to being offered the influential role of chair of Ofcom.” (Related.)

McSweeney’s Internet Tendency / Eli Grober

“I’m being censored, and you can read, hear, and see me talk about it in the news, on the radio, and on TV” →

“I weep for this country, where the media completely cancels anyone with a different point of view, like the one I’m expressing in this highly popular newspaper. So, what can we do about it? How do we make our voices heard when all we can do is write opinion pieces in major magazines, do interviews on popular TV shows and speak on the floor of the US Senate?”

Associated Press / David Bauder

People desperate for COVID-19 guides seek local journalists →

“CC Davidson-Hiers, a reporter for the Tallahassee Democrat in Florida, has lost track of how many requests she’s gotten, many from elderly readers who can’t navigate online vaccination sign-ups. It’s an abrupt turnaround from last year, when her inbox was filled with vitriol from people who called her an alarmist or worthless human being trying to scare people, just because she was writing about COVID-19.”

Digiday / Max Willens

With America still on lockdown, publishers lean into direct mail →

“While many publishers have spent years trying to reduce their reliance on (and the cost of) legacy print businesses, the spread of coronavirus has opened up a narrow window for publishers to capitalize on them again…Few marketers would consider direct mail a bright shiny object, but it has gotten a fresh look in recent years, particularly among DTC brands looking to diversify their media spending beyond Facebook and Google.”

The New Republic / Alex Shephard

What the GameStop rally has revealed about financial media →

“These networks are all about upholding the sanctity of the Blessed Market and protecting the interests of their high-faluting financial sector guests — the people who run hedge funds and corporate oligopolies, who are the keymasters of this universe. The interests of the audience are secondary.”

Associated Press / David Bauder

Tom Brokaw: Journalists should get out of New York and D.C. →

“Take some of the people who are only in Washington and send them to Salt Lake City or Kansas City, or St. Louis for that matter.”

Poynter / Tom Jones

“No, Fox News and MSNBC are not the same thing” →

“There are outlets that have opinion hosts, but they’re playing in the real world — in the world of facts and reality. Fox is spinning its own reality. To suggest there’s an equivalence between the two I think is not accurate and something we should really be careful to avoid.”

The Wall Street Journal / Jeff Horwitz

Facebook Groups are full of hate, harassment, and disinformation, and Facebook has known for years →

“Roughly ‘70% of the top 100 most active US Civic Groups are considered non-recommendable for issues such as hate, misinfo, bullying and harassment,’ [Facebook researchers] concluded. ‘We need to do something to stop these conversations from happening and growing as quickly as they do.'”

The Information / Jessica Lessin

The nightmare awaiting the news industry →

“While AOC was on Twitch, the CEO of Reddit was making news chatting with some people he knew on Clubhouse. Redditors in the r/wallstreetbets group were wreaking havoc on the stock market. And, in my neck of the woods, A16z, the most powerful investment firm in Silicon Valley, was starting to hire journalists to launch its own publication to spread ‘rational optimism’ about tech.”

Broadcasting & Cable / Jon Lafayette

A+E Networks wants to kill off “the demo” →

“Most ad deals are now based on demographic groups, mainly people, men or women 18 to 49 years old or 25 to 54 years old…Those advertisers’ commercials are also seen by a huge number of viewers 55 and older — the biggest group of traditional TV viewers — but the advertisers get those eyeballs for free. What A+E wants is to charge advertisers for all viewers 18 years and older as their primary currency.”

WCHS / Jeff Morris

A West Virginia newspaper publisher has sued Google and Facebook over their advertising dominance →

“The suit claims that Google is violating anti-trust laws, monopolizing the online advertising revenue market and threatening the extinction of local newspapers across the country…’Google’s unlawful anticompetitive conduct is directly stripping newspapers across the country, including the plaintiff, of their primary revenue source.'”

What’s New in Publishing / Faisal Kalim

“Beginning of a newsletter arms race:” How publishers are set to benefit as platforms vie for premium content →

“As the newsletter space grows more crowded, the competing platforms are augmenting their offerings to keep (or retain) authors.”

Exchange4media

This newspaper in India just put out an special edition printed on cloth →

To celebrate its 15 years in Bhilwara, the “Textile City of India.”

The New York Times / Ben Smith

“The editor attached a document titled ‘profanity social media for olivia.pdf’” →

On the management policing of journalists’ tweets. “This often feels like a moral or ethical debate, sometimes played out in caricature on Twitter itself. But the question of how to get your readers to trust you, in my view, isn’t really moral; it’s tactical, and empirical.”

Press Watchers / Dan Froomkin

What the next generation of editors need to tell their political reporters →

“Effective today, you are no longer political reporters (and editors); you are government reporters (and editors). That’s an important distinction, because it frees you to cover what is happening in Washington in the context of whether it is serving the people well, rather than which party is winning.”