How big is the market for rigorous reporting on misinformation? This new newsletter will be an Indicator

“It’s just politically expedient in this climate [for platforms] to lay low. And so this manifests in record levels of digital scams, AI slop everywhere, and entire chatbots dedicated to fringe conspiracy theories.”

If you’ve been paying attention to the world of misinformation and disinformation for the past decade, you know the names of Craig Silverman and Alexios Mantzarlis. First at BuzzFeed News (R.I.P.) and then at ProPublica, Silverman has been one of the top reporters on the beat, uncovering Macedonian fake-news mills, Facebook malfeasance, Google ad shenanigans, and insider ad fraud. And Mantzarlis, through his work at Poynter, the International Fact-Checking Network (which he ran), and the Security, Trust, and Safety Initiative at Cornell Tech, has been at the forefront of discussions about battling misinfo.

So it was quite something this week when the two announced they’d be teaming up, like some very space-limited version of The Avengers, for a new project called Indicator. At one level, it’s a merger of the two newsletters that they’ve been producing independently for some time: Silverman’s Digital Investigations and Mantzarlis’ Faked Up. (Silverman’s was focused more on OSINT and investigatory tools; Mantzarlis’ more straightforwardly about disinformation and “digital deception.”)

But those newsletters were both side gigs to their day jobs at ProPublica and Cornell Tech. While Mantzarlis is remaining at Cornell Tech and devoting about 20% of his time to Indicator, Silverman left his job at ProPublica to create it. (In this economy?!) They say their goal is to serve “the global community of investigators and researchers” — a group that’s been the target of a typhoon of attacks from the Trump administration and its allies in and out of government.

Silverman and Mantzarlis plan to publish several times a week (two stories so far this week). And while it’s become de rigeur for newsletter subscriber benefits to involve video calls with the creator, Indicator plans monthly workshops for subscribers that go farther than most, featuring skills tutorials or walkthroughs of a tool or an investigation — something of interest to investigative reporters more broadly, not just those on the information beat. I asked the pair some questions about their new outfit over email; here’s our lightly edited exchange.

Benton: Craig, you’re leaving ProPublica for Indicator. Why step away from what most people would consider a dream job?

Silverman: It is a dream job to be a national reporter at ProPublica. I just felt that I was meant to do something else, as crazy as that may sound. I’m completely obsessed with how the digital information environment is being manipulated and exploited. I want to spend my time reporting on that, and not just with a U.S. focus.

I was also increasingly being asked to give OSINT and digital investigative workshops, which I find really enjoyable and satisfying. We need more people in journalism and beyond who can apply these skills and techniques, regardless of their beat or interests. I realized that I wanted to play a role in helping grow the number (and types) of people doing this work.

It seemed like Alexios was the perfect person to join with to create something new that publishes digital investigations and gives people the skills and knowledge to do it for themselves. And hey, why not take a big leap when we’re in the midst of global economic uncertainty!

Benton: And Alexios, why’d you want to team up with Craig?

Mantzarlis: This is a bit like asking a moderately established singer why do a collab with Lady Gaga.

12 years ago, when I was just starting up my fact-checking project in Italy, Craig was already knee-deep in the world of deceptive media. He has created this beat and covered it with tenacity but no bombast. He has always been generous to everyone coming into this space and that’s the kind of energy I hope we can bring to Indicator. I’ve been able to get a lot of bad stuff taken down with Faked Up, but I know that working with Craig will make my work smarter, deeper, better.

Benton: We’re four months into this new/old administration, which has gone out of its way to attack both journalists and people who work on misinformation issues. How does this beat look or feel different to you so far in Trump II?

Silverman: A key difference is that Trump II came into power with a pretty well-oiled apparatus to undermine the concept of misinformation and to attack the researchers, journalists, and other people who are trying to expose it and study it. In his previous term, Trump took the phrase “fake news” and used it as a cudgel to beat the press and undermine what constituted credible reporting and information.

By the time he got re-elected, there was a network of legislators, activists, substackers, and others committed to dismantling the “censorship cartel,” and they had been effective at chilling research and funding efforts.

Mantzarlis: I think the big difference is that the CEOs of the big online platforms have given up. The rank-and-file still care and are trying to do their best against deepfakes, scams, and influence operations — because they see their negative consequences on citizens around the world.

However, whether it’s Zuckerberg throwing fact-checkers under the bus or Altman deciding he wants a cut of the deepfake impersonation industry, tech CEOs have decided they are no longer interested in reducing the prevalence of disinformation.

That’s not because the public wants them to lay off false information; au contraire, RISJ found majorities globally think platforms should be held responsible for this type of content. It’s just politically expedient in this climate to lay low. And so this manifests in record levels of digital scams, AI slop everywhere, and entire chatbots dedicated to fringe conspiracy theories.

Benton: How do you think the voices of your two newsletters will mesh together? Digital Investigations was more tools-focused, Faked Up more disinfo-focused — what sort of balance should people expect going forward?

Mantzarlis: Craig is bringing both his Digital Investigations work and the type of reporting he was doing at ProPublica to Indicator, so I think people who followed us before will not be surprised with what they see us publishing.

I also think both of us have an expository, fact-first approach to covering this beat that’s mixed with a sense of amusement at the absurdities we end up uncovering, whether it’s Macedonian teens spreading American fake news or Nigerian organized crime pushing auction scams for Italian houses.

Benton: You say Indicator is meant to serve the “global community of investigators and researchers.” How does that job look different when platforms, universities, and the federal government all seem dedicated to decimating the field?

Silverman: We have a broad definition of the community and of what we call digital deception. Yes, the people who study misinformation are losing funding and being sent letters by Jim Jordan’s House committee, among other efforts to undermine their work. We won’t shy away from that area of reporting.

But this is a much bigger field, encompassing scams and fraud, search engine manipulation, threat actors attacking platforms, abuse of AI tools and systems, etc. Digital deception has a cross-societal impact and it needs to be covered as such. We aim to be a must-read resource for people across academia, the public and private sector, and in journalism. Hopefully, we can grow the field of people doing this work and empower members of the public who care about information quality.

Benton: And to what degree is that investigator/researcher audience your target for Indicator? Do you also aspire to a broader audience?

Mantzarlis: This newsletter is for anyone who cares about the quality of our online information ecosystem. We expect our audience to be predominantly composed of professionals looking to keep abreast of the latest and greatest in digital deception. But we also think that at a time of reduced moderation, great technological development, and fragmented online spaces everyone needs to get better at sniffing out scams and digital dreck. We want our work to be useful to our subscribers and to result in changes on the platforms we cover, including by equipping our readers with the tools to do their own investigations. We are not chasing an audience for the sake of it.

Benton: Tell me a bit more about how you’re thinking about these monthly workshops that’ll be part of membership. What sorts of topics should people expect, and how central are they to your overall subscription strategy?

Silverman: The workshops will typically focus on a topic that we’ve dug into on the site. The idea is to give hands-on tutorials and deeper breakdowns of the techniques used in our reporting. For example, this week I published a story about a global scam network that used fake reviews to lure customers. I also published an accompanying guide on how to investigate online reviews.

Our first workshop could focus on the tools and techniques I used for the story, and that I outlined in the guide. We also give members a chance to ask questions and share their own knowledge. There may be months when I use the workshop to demo some of the new or updated tools we’ve shared in our weekly roundups. And I would love to have (paid) guests as we grow!

I think it’s a big value-add to give people the chance to see things live and to ask questions. It speaks to one of the central ideas of Indicator, which is that everyone — professionals and the public — needs to be equipped to navigate our risky and chaotic information environment. Workshops are a direct and interactive way to do that.

Benton: Now for the obligatory question in this sort of journalist-starts-newsletter story: You’re doing this on Beehiiv. Why Beehiiv instead of Substack, Ghost, or any of the other newsletter platforms du jour?

Mantzarlis: Much like with Pokémon, I got to catch them all. I started Faked Up on Substack, but moved away out of discomfort with their content policies and general posturing about disinformation. Ghost was a solid platform, but Beehiiv has many more functionalities that I think Craig and I will be able to capitalize on.

The company also generously onboarded us to the Media Collective, which has additional benefits like access to Getty Images, legal review for articles, and free access to the platform. Having taken many a struggle bus to find relevant stock images for my pieces, I think Getty may have been my personal clincher.

Get Nieman Lab’s Daily Digest

The most important stories about journalism and the future of news, delivered to your inbox every afternoon.

Joshua Benton is the senior writer and former director of Nieman Lab, which he founded in 2008. You can reach him via email, Twitter (@jbenton), or Bluesky.

The latest from Nieman Lab

Press Forward gave $20 million to 205 local newsrooms over two years. Here’s how some of them spent it.

The unrestricted funding helped small outlets plug holes and try new things, but publishers ran up against the limits of what two $50,000 grants could accomplish, especially when it came to hiring.