Twitter  "Algorithms have consequences." Zeynep Tufekci on Ferguson and net neutrality:  
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

Len Downie: For-profit news orgs won’t create enough journalism

By any measure, former Washington Post executive editor Len Downie epitomized success in the traditional, subscription-and-advertising model of newspaper journalism: With a staff that once topped 900 and an annual budget of $100 million, his newsroom hauled in 25 Pulitzer Prizes over 17 years and wielded influence from Congress to the darkest recesses of the nation’s capital.

Since stepping down from the Post’s top newsroom job at age 66, Downie has taken on a professorship at Arizona State University. But behind the scenes, he also is lending his experience to help shape the practices and prospects for the burgeoning nonprofit sector in journalism.

Why? Simple: Downie says the for-profit model alone no longer can support the kinds of investigative, explanatory, and accountability journalism that society needs. As the for-profit sector shrinks, journalists and interested readers must explore new ways to underwrite their work.

“There are going to have to be many different kinds of economic models,” Downie said in an interview at the Post’s offices. “The future is a much more diverse ecosystem.”

Downie has made himself an expert on the nonprofit model, and wrote about its possibilities in his recent report, “The Reconstruction of American Journalism,” with Michael Schudson.

Less known, perhaps, is that Downie casts a wide net as within the nonprofit sector of journalism. He’s a board member at the Center for Investigative Reporting, which recently launched California Watch to cover money and politics at the state level. He also chairs the journalism advisory committee at Kaiser Health News, which has provided niche explanatory reporting to leading newspapers, including the Post. And he’s also on the board of Investigative Reporters and Editors, which has incorporated panels on the nonprofit model into its conferences. (I should note that I am a part-time editor for the Washington Post News Service.)

Looking across the sector, Downie sees great potential — and some big, unanswered questions.

On the upside, nonprofits are helping journalism move toward a more collaborative model, Downie said. In the old days, newspapers resisted ideas and assistance from outside. But in the new news ecosystem, collaboration is a way of life. “All of our ideas have been changed about that,” he said.

Also a plus: Big foundations and the public at large are warming to the idea that news organizations are deserving of their support, just like the symphony or any other nonprofit that contributes to society’s cultural assets. “There’s a question of whether there’s enough public realization,” Downie said. “I think we’re heading to that direction. Awareness is growing steadily.”

But a lot of questions still must be sorted out, Downie said.

High on the list, he said, is the most basic of all: Where will the money come from? Like other nonprofits, nonprofit news organizations will have to find the right mix of foundation money, grassroots support, advertising, and perhaps additional government support, he said.

That leads to the other big question of sustainability: It’s not clear that all the nonprofits that have launched in recent years will survive. “How many will succeed and for how long?” Downie wondered. A related question: How will the collaborative model will settle out, and where nonprofits will find productive niches?

Downie said he also has been watching nonprofits wrestle with the issue of credibility — how to achieve it and how to keep it.

The answer begins with editorial independence and transparency about financial supporters, Downie said. But when it comes to painting a bright line between journalism and ideology, advocacy or spin, there are no magic formulas to assure readers — just the experience of trial and error.

“It’s one of these things that’s proven by its exceptions,” Downie said. “When there’s an exception, it’s a scandal.”

What to read next
Ken Doctor    Aug. 13, 2014
If newspapers are going to have to survive on their own, the first numbers aren’t encouraging. In southern California, we could see big movement fast.
  • Ben Ilfeld

    There will be a more diverse media ecosystem. There already is one.

    It includes both non-profit and for-profit models and both sectors are vitally important if we want to build better communities.

    Collaboration, integrity, transparency and great journalism are in high demand and now is the time to experiment! That’s what we at The Sacramento Press are doing.

  • Pingback: Nieman Journalism Lab: For-profit model can’t support investigative journalism, says Len Downie | Editors' Blog

  • Mark Johnstone

    The situation may be even worse in the UK. With both the creative funding industry slashing staff and funds this recession, and a media that just will not properly invest in diversity and effective training.

    Our company is an independent training consultancy and an alternative solution away from university education. We have looked at profit and not-for-profit. Both in this current recession are fraught.

  • Jeremy Rudy

    I’m a journalism student at ASU, so I have the opportunity to hear Mr. Downie speak frequently.

    While I have respect for his accomplishments, and agree that not-for-profit models will likely play a part in the future ecosystem of news, I’m disturbed by the message that Mr. Downie and other “respected industry leaders” are increasingly advocating — that since there’s no viable market solution NOW for journalism, there won’t be in the future.

    His worldview is shaped by broken business models and obsolete technologies, and even though it might sound cliche, he lacks the intuitive understanding of technology that younger generations have.

    The journalism industry is transforming. That doesn’t mean failing. It still provides a product/service that consumers demand.

    The problem with not-for-profit models is they frequently support the status-quo, as there’s no incentive to find creative measures to self-finance.

    Innovation won’t come from the wise advice of a long-time expert. It will come from the grassroots, probably from a different industry, and it will be fueled by the profit-motive.

  • Pingback: Journalism Today - Tracking Media Changes

  • Pingback: What Does the Future Hold for Newspapers?

  • Pingback: What Does the Future Hold for Newspapers? |

  • Pingback: Non-Profit Is The Future, iPad Is Not « News News

  • Pingback: Inside Voice: Our Future in Journalism

  • Pingback: A few words from our panelists « The Hyperlocalist