Nieman Foundation at Harvard
You’re more likely to believe fake news shared by someone you barely know than by your best friend
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Nov. 10, 2015, 3:45 p.m.
Reporting & Production

The New York Times hopes its first virtual reality film, “The Displaced,” kicks off mass adoption of VR

“We hope people see this as the moment when VR went mainstream.”

“This is probably the largest communal screening of a virtual reality film ever,” said New York Times Magazine editor Jake Silverstein, as people began to fumble with cardboard visors.

True, but it was also only one of several firsts represented at the premiere of the Times’ first virtual reality film, “The Displaced,” last Thursday in Manhattan. Not only was the Times debuting its first immersive virtual reality experience, but over the weekend of November 8, it delivered more than a million pre-assembled Google Cardboard sets to home delivery subscribers.

On Tuesday, the Times said that its VR app was “the most successful NYT app launch ever,” with “more downloads in its first few days (11/5-11/8) than any other Times app has had at launch,” though it didn’t provide actual numbers.

Virtual reality is clearly having a moment. News outlets like Frontline, The Wall Street Journal, and the AP are all experimenting with how to fit VR into their storytelling.

It was only natural, said Silverstein, who was appointed editor of the magazine in 2014, that the Times also start looking at what it could do.

That initial interest led to a proof-of-concept film shot in March 2015 and published in April: “Walking New York,” a cover feature and, later, a 360-degree film about the large-scale urban murals of the French artist JR.

“We started to get the sense that virtual reality would have legs, that our readers and viewers would like it, and that it could become a more consistent part of our report,” said Silverstein. “And [it was something that] advertisers and sponsors would want to be a part of.” “The Displaced” is sponsored by GE and Mini, and viewers who download the app will see sponsored content for those brands.

At SXSW this past spring, Silverstein and Aaron Luber, head of partnerships for Google Cardboard, discussed the potential of a massive distribution. “It’s the scale that turns this into something of note,” said Silverstein. “A lot of other media companies are doing VR, but they are only able to reach people who already have a headset, or who are just watching it on their phone. That’s a fine experience, but it doesn’t make you feel present in the scene the way doing it with the viewer does.”

“The Displaced,” directed by Imraan Ismail of VR production studio Vrse and Times video journalist Ben Solomon, is beautiful and heartbreaking. The 10-minute piece follows three children — Oleg from Ukraine, Chuol from South Sudan, and Hana, a Syrian refugee living in a camp in Lebanon — through their respective worlds: their friends, their villages, their lives. You hear their stories while walking alongside them in fields, sitting with them in rubble, and witnessing the frantic scramble to receive food dropped from aid planes.

That “food drop shot,” as attendees at the premiere were overheard referring to it, seemed to best illustrate the potentials of virtual reality for journalism. In the film, you as the viewer are first alerted to an approaching plane by the sound of a whirring engine. You instinctively look up just as the plane flies overhead and begins dropping giant sacks. A series of thumps accompanies the drop, before you see people all around you running to collect the food.

The mechanics behind the shot were intentional. The camera rig, which was created from a series of eight GoPro cameras attached to a pole and modified to shoot wide-angle, sat in the middle of the planned action.

Shooting for VR is very different from shooting for 2D, Solomon and Ismail agreed. “The unexplored power of this kind of filmmaking is in directing people’s attention,” said Solomon. “When you think about film, it’s just shots and moving them around. But theater is about getting people to ‘look over here!’ using light and sound to move their attention. I think VR has a lot of that blocking potential.”

The process took its toll on the rig holding the cameras. “If one of our cameras went out, that was the whole shot gone,” explained Ismail. “From the last six months to the next, the tech is going to change dramatically.”

Shooting required the pair to duck behind things in order to avoid being seen in the 360-degree shots. “Watching the film now, in almost every shot I know where we are hiding,” Solomon said.

So, how did the readers who downloaded the New York Times’ VR app like the film?

While Silverstein didn’t share details on the Times’ next VR project, he said he hopes the release of “The Displaced” will be a watershed moment for the emerging technology. “We hope people see this as the moment when VR went mainstream,” he said. “Not when early-adopters, gamers, people who already know got it, but when those without exposure to it realized what this new medium can do.”

More than a century ago, the New York Times Magazine published its first photographs. “We think VR has a promising future,” Silverstein said, “just like photography did 119 years ago.”

Photo of “The Displaced” premiere on November 5, 2015 by Neilson Barnard/Getty Images for The New York Times.

POSTED     Nov. 10, 2015, 3:45 p.m.
SEE MORE ON Reporting & Production
Show tags
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
You’re more likely to believe fake news shared by someone you barely know than by your best friend
“The strength of weak ties” applies to misinformation, too.
To find readers for longform investigations, Public Health Watch leans on partners and in-person work
Nonprofit newsrooms are competing for limited funding and attention spans, grappling with diminishing returns on social, and trying to address low trust in media. It’s forcing outlets large and small to adapt to survive.
Could social media support healthy online conversations? New_ Public is working on it
“We talk to a lot of towns where there is no newspaper anymore; there’s no community center anymore; the town store shut down. And this is kind of it.”