Nieman Foundation at Harvard
Newsonomics: Bryan Goldberg wants to build Bustle into the “Meredith of the digital age”
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Aug. 17, 2016, 12:32 p.m.
Audience & Social

NPR is retiring the comments section on its story pages (because of disuse, not just garbage fires)

“Those who comment are not wholly representative of the overall NPR audience.”

Starting next Tuesday, stories on will no longer have comments sections. NPR announced the decision in a blog post on Wednesday, explaining that while its overall web audience has grown over the years, its comments sections have been largely deserted: Just 1 percent of its audience of 25 to 35 million monthly unique visitors comment. And the number of regular commenters is microscopic:

Instead, NPR is turning to social channels — both official and through its journalists’ personal accounts — to interact with its audience. And that means pulling audiences into the usual places like Facebook (where it has more than 5 million likes), Twitter (more than 6 million followers), and building their Snapchat, Instagram, and Tumblr presences. In the post, managing editor for digital news Scott Montgomery highlighted NPR’s personal finance Facebook group, which now boasts more than 18,000 members. Other audience engagement efforts are also rendering comments sections less useful, Montgomery wrote. Among those:

We’ve taken our special engagement events to new levels with the Tiny Desk Contest and Generation Listen. This year’s Tiny Desk Contest received more than 6,000 entries and introduced the world to winner Gaelynn Lea. Meanwhile, our journalists regularly visit Generation Listen gatherings, connecting with the next generation of public radio fans at NPR Member Stations around the country.

We have an entire team devoted to Audience Relations, who read and personally respond to thousands of listener emails every month. This indispensable forum fields your most substantive feedback and questions and allows us space to provide equally substantive answers. Our site works across platforms and is always open for your questions and concerns.

In coming weeks, in addition to refining our live interaction approaches on Facebook, we’ll begin testing a promising new engagement tool that is rooted in public media. Hearken is a digital platform that allows journalists and the audience to partner on the development of story ideas and it’s already in use at dozens of NPR Member Stations. We will be bringing Hearken to our Goats and Soda blog on global health and development with the potential for expansion in the future.

NPR also has its own full-time ombudsman in Elizabeth Jensen, who helps address issues raised by listeners. Naturally, Jensen weighed in on the killing of the comments, anticipating some pushback around the fact that a public media organization was removing a channel of public input. NPR was using the outside platform Disqus, a system which got “more expensive the more comments that are posted, and in some months has cost NPR twice what was budgeted,” Jensen wrote. In other words, NPR was paying for a small group of people who were not necessarily representative of their audience:

Just 4,300 users posted about 145 comments apiece, or 67 percent of all comments for the two months. More than half of all comments in May, June and July combined came from a mere 2,600 users.

It’s not possible to tell who those commenters are; some users comment anonymously. But there are some clues that indicate those who comment are not wholly representative of the overall NPR audience: They overwhelmingly comment via the desktop (younger users tend to find via mobile), and a Google estimate suggested that the commenters were 83 percent male, while overall users were just 52 percent male, Montgomery said.

NPR’s senior director for digital products Joel Sucherman also told Jensen that readers will likely “see other new options over the next six to nine months.”

On Twitter, the news was greeted mostly positively, though some expressed concern about the increasing influence of social media platforms. The comments sections of Jensen’s and Montgomery’s posts, though, pretty much speak for themselves.


POSTED     Aug. 17, 2016, 12:32 p.m.
SEE MORE ON Audience & Social
Join the 50,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
Newsonomics: Bryan Goldberg wants to build Bustle into the “Meredith of the digital age”
“I think the hard part for something like Esquire or Harper’s Bazaar in digital — even to some extent Vogue — is that you get into the scale game. Digital demands greater scale. I just don’t know how many men are trying to figure out if corduroy is back in fashion.”
Newsonomics: The newspaper industry is thirsty for liquidity as it tries to merge its way out of trouble
Newspaper company CEOs will be the first to tell you a new round of consolidation won’t solve their problems. But it might give them another year or two of breathing room.
With corgis, chickens, and kitchen reveals, the NYT Cooking Community Facebook group is a “happy corner of the internet”
“It’s useful to us to see what people keep on their counters. Do they have their pots and pans hanging or tucked away? It’s a neat window into their lives.”