When the podcast Signal Hill launched last year, I was immediately struck by its formatting. Instead of seasons, it launches issues; episodes, which vary in length from less than two minutes to more than an hour, are broken down by type, like “dispatch” and “feature” and “profile.” It looks, in other words, like a magazine laid out in a podcast feed; it even includes editors’ notes and letters to the editors. The stories range widely: there’s a Talk of the Town-ish piece in which kids in the town of Madrid, New Mexico, literally talked to people all over town; a feature about lutes from writer and Great British Bake-Off runner-up Ruby Tandoh; and an essay about the Native American occupation of Alcatraz, contrasted with the Apollo 11 moon landing (which happened at the same time). No two stories are alike, just as no two pieces in a print magazine are alike.
I’ve been following Signal Hill since the beginning; last year, when Nieman Storyboard editor Mark Armstrong asked us for recommendations, I wrote that Signal Hill was “beautiful, weird, and mesmerizing,” and “the kind of stuff that made me want to be a journalist in the first place.” That remains true, but in the year since its launch the audio magazine has grown up. What started as an experiment is now on its third issue, which launched this month, and is even being broadcast on the radio.
At a time when documentary audio has contracted dramatically, Signal Hill seems to be the rare expansion. To learn more, I spoke with co-founders and editors-in-chief Jackson Roach and Liza Yeager over Zoom. Our conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
Neel Dhanesha: Let’s start with the origin story of Signal Hill.
Jackson Roach: We were inspired by literary magazines as institutions because they are containers for many different people to make many different kinds of things that all go together and have an institutional structure that supports them and holds them through that kind of process. That kind of exists in audio, but [not] as robustly as it does in print.
Liza Yeager: We were both noticing that gap as freelance independent producers where we were like, “O.K., I have like one story that I want to make, and I guess I could pitch this as a whole series,” which is not really what most stories need, or “I could pitch it to a show that already exists, which would maybe give me money to make it, but then I would have to make it sound like that show,” and not every story needs to be squished into a model of a show that already exists.
Roach: Or I could just put it out on my own for free, which is the thing that lots of people do, but they are squeezing it into their nights and weekends, or whatever. If you look at all of the weirdest, greatest stuff, somebody probably did a piece of it for free because there wasn’t an institution that was there to support it, and that’s not really a good model for people to get into an industry.
Yeager: And it’s hard on an emotional level to convince yourself to make work without any kind of institutional support or an editor or anyone holding you accountable at all.
Dhanesha: Did you talk to any of the literary magazines to figure out how they worked?
Roach: Yeah, that was really Liza’s brilliant insight. We talked to some people who work at
N+1, and that place has existed for a long time and started on a really small budget and now has a full paid staff who have healthcare and get paid a real salary and work in a real office and it has this amazing intellectual community of writers who are coming through and like seeking to be part of that world with those people.
Yeager: When we started making Signal Hill, we knew it was kind of breaking the rules of what you’re supposed to do to make a show that is profitable, which is to make something that comes out really often, and reaches a huge audience so that you can sell ads, and has the same voices every time that people get accustomed to and feel like they’re friends with.
And we were like, “O.K. we’re not going to do all of those things. So what are we going to do?” It’s very important to us that our stories are accessible and that lots of people like them and that they’re not rarefied; we’re not trying to make sound art. We are making documentaries that ideally most people can listen to and follow, but our goal is also to give our contributors space to push themselves on sonic and political and intellectual levels. But our goal is not to reach every single possible listener in America. Our goal is to reach a specific listenership of people who will be excited about listening to work that is different from what they’ve heard before.
It felt like a literary magazine was a really good model because those institutions are obviously not reaching a mass audience.
Dhanesha: Signal Hill incorporated as a nonprofit and has gotten some “serious donations.” Tell me about that.
Roach: Nonprofit as a model is tried and true in the art and literary worlds. It has all kinds of other problems and tradeoffs, but it’s shown itself to be more conducive to making the kinds of stuff that we think we could make.
Yeager: It is not profitable to make documentary podcasts. That is another thing that was really obvious to us in that moment when we started making Signal Hill. There had been this huge amount of investment from companies in making documentary shows, and then all of that was kind of falling apart because clearly they realized that in order to make shows that are actually good, you have to spend so much time and money. And that’s not a thing that is going to pull in massive profits. But how literary magazines work, for the most part, is that people are paying money for them because they think the art form is important, and they want it to keep going. That’s been a big thinking shift for us.
When we talked to our comrades in literary magazines, it seemed like the way people were funding things was developing a base that’s half small-scale donors, so people who make fairly small donations on a regular basis, like a $75 per year subscription to a magazine. And the other half is people who make large donations, ideally in a recurring way, but more like $10,000 a year. Most people told us they don’t rely on grants, because they take so much time and come with a lot of strings attached and might not get renewed.
It would be amazing to fund the project fully on small-scale listener donations, but we were like, “O.K., it seems like all these other institutions are clearly relying on people making larger donations, so we need to start developing that kind of base.”
Dhanesha: So those serious donations you’re talking about came from individuals?
Yeager: Yeah. We incorporated the nonprofit right before we launched the first issue and then started building our membership base. We started making a couple thousand dollars a month from members, which felt like a lot for us. And people paying $6 a month or $12 a month really does add up.
We had a listener who ran her own nonprofit who taught us the basics around this type of fundraising. She told us we needed to do an end-of-year fundraiser,so we did that for the first time at the end of last year.
We tried our best to convince people that this is a nonprofit that’s worth giving their money to, and we got one large anonymous donation at the end of last year and one large donation from a listener who had really been moved by one particular story, and then a few smaller donations. We realized we could start to pay ourselves a small stipend for working on this, and that’s made the work a lot more sustainable this year. We both have a lot of other jobs, but now we get a small monthly stipend for this work, which is really amazing.
Roach: I inherited some money from my grandma, and that was the seed funding that allowed us to pay our contributors right away, but that first year all the editors were working essentially for free. We [originally] got paid a stipend per issue, but that wasn’t ultimately sustainable. Now, aside from ourselves, there are three other editors —
Omar Etman,
Annie Rosenthal, and
Lio Wong — who also get paid an editorial stipend each month, as well as a web designer who gets paid a stipend quarterly.
Dhanesha: How big were the donations you received?
Yeager: I think in the end we raised $120,000 total from donors at the end of last year, which doesn’t include the subscriber base. That’s more like $25,000 a year.
That was amazing. When you’ve never done fundraising before you have no idea what is reasonable to ask for, and it’s hard to value your work for the actual time that it takes. The donations changed everything for us as an organization. But we both feel strongly that we need to build the membership program more, because it’s scary to be trying to fundraise from large donors when we don’t know if they’ll come back. [We’d like to] be able to cover the baseline costs of the magazine with the subscriber base.
Dhanesha: Some podcasts like This American Life have
subscriber-only content. Have you considered doing something like that?
Yeager: We’ve considered it, but we can’t do bonus episodes that are at all the thing that Signal Hill is because every story takes eight months or more to make. It’s just so much labor. We haven’t completely ruled out doing some kind of lower-lift audio bonus for subscribers. We have a paywalled newsletter that our subscribers get, where we all write about different kinds of art that’s inspiring us and inspiring Signal Hill. So that’s kind of our answer to that for the moment.
Roach: We made a conscious choice as part of the nonprofit setup not to paywall our audio, because we want to be accessible to as many people as possible. We want a lot of people to hear it so that they will consider signing up to be members, but also just because we want a lot of people to hear it.
Dhanesha: I’m curious about discovery. Literary magazines can be picked up by people who go into bookstores and find them on the shelf, but you can’t do the same thing with audio.
Yeager: When we first launched, we did a big round of just introducing ourselves to people in the magazine and radio world. The radio world is small and we already knew a lot of people in it, but that helped a lot. We put ourselves on other people’s podcast feeds as much as we could. We’ve [also] been throwing parties when we launch an issue, and that’s another thing that we stole from the magazine world…We want to feel like we’re in a community of people who are trying to make this art form better together.
Dhanesha: And now you’re on the radio too, right?
Yeager: Yeah, we’re on
Lumpen Radio, which is a low power station in Chicago, where we both live. We’re also working with
Marfa Public Radio, which has a wide reach. We have always had the goal of getting Signal Hill on the radio, and we started out basically with radio stations where we have a connection. It feels like right now we’re very much in like trying-it-out mode and having fun with it. It’s on our list to figure out how to syndicate and see if we can supplement the budget that way.
Roach: That’s something we wanted to do because anybody could just turn it on and hear us. You don’t have to have heard about Signal Hill from somebody who heard about it from somebody who heard about it from somebody to find it on the radio by accident.
Dhanesha:In some ways Signal Hill reminds me of Audio Flux, which launched around the same time and is also focused on craft but has a very different output: while you’re doing these long documentary pieces, Fluxworks are always three minutes long. Do you think the space for non-corporate, craft-obsessed work is expanding again?
Yeager: When Signal Hill started, it was really at a low point. This is my fake economic theory, but I do have this feeling that when everyone suddenly no longer had these big institutional radio jobs, they went “okay, I guess I’ll do my weird thing now.” It’s a lot less dark than it was for the last few years. The space has opened up, and that’s so cool.
For a long time I had just stopped finding space to make stories like that. It was such a vicious cycle, the corporate thing, because if you’re trying to make it fast to make money, it won’t be good, and then people won’t listen to it, and then it won’t make money, and on and on. But if you give up on the goal of making it to make money, you suddenly have a lot more space.
Roach: When we put out the first issue, which we had worked really hard on, we didn’t know if it would work. We stayed up all night for a few nights before we released it, putting the finishing touches on it, and when it came out it was so good that it short-circuited the part of my brain that made it impossible to like the things I’ve worked on in the past. It was the first time I’ve really felt like that, and I started saying that it sort of feels like the work of my life, which is maybe a little bit crazy. But I’ve never had this level of meaningful depth of both creative community and real care. I feel so lucky that we found ourselves in this set of random historical conditions that made it a little bit possible for us to try it, and that it’s working out all right.
Signal Hill Issue One cover art by Molly Hastings, courtesy of Signal Hill.