Twitter  The NYT's David Leonhardt says The Upshot could be reimagined for local with a staff of no more than three nie.mn/WHcDmB  
Nieman Journalism Lab
Pushing to the future of journalism — A project of the Nieman Foundation at Harvard

Charging (a lot!) for news online: The Newport Daily News’ new experiment with paid content

The Newport Daily News kept waiting for someone else to figure out how to make money giving away news online. But with no obvious solution in sight, its leaders have decided to try an answer of their own: charging for access to the news.

Lots of newspapers are considering similar options. What makes Newport different is that they’re charging more to read the paper online than in print. Quite a bit more, in fact. The idea: Charge enough for the online content that the paper-and-ink product looks a lot more attractive. Don’t undercut your primary product with a free alternative that doesn’t make you money. And provide an online edition for those customers who have a compelling reason to pay for content.

“Our goal was to get people back into the printed product,” publisher Albert K. Sherman, Jr. told me. He said some readers, when hearing about the plan, asked “why would they pay for it on the Internet when they can go buy the printed paper? And that’s perfect — that’s what we want.”

The 12,000-circulation Rhode Island newspaper is old school — it still publishes afternoons on Mondays through Fridays, with a morning edition on Saturday. Last month, the newspaper announced a new three-tier pricing structure for subscriptions. Want home delivery of the print paper? That’s $145 a year. Want home delivery and online access? That’s $245. And if you want just online access — to an electronic edition that duplicates the appearance of the print product — it’s a whopping $345.

“It’s a three-tier pricing structure,” says Sheila L. Mullowney, the newspaper’s executive editor. “And it will be a print-newspaper-first strategy.”

Will it work? It’s too soon to have much evidence; the News is offering a 30-day free trial for the electronic edition, and all users are still in that window. In the first two weeks after the electronic edition became available, it averaged about 1,500 visitors a day, but that dropped to 500 on June 1 when the paper started requiring free registration to access the online version. How many people will be willing to pay is still unknown; Sherman thinks it may appeal to people who have a strong interest in Newport news but live outside the newspaper’s circulation area.

The News brings some built-in advantages to this model. Its competition is limited; the much-larger Providence Journal‘s reduction of statewide coverage has made the News the only organization providing significant coverage of Newport County. And Sherman has not trained News readers to expect full and free content online; the paper has always provided only a limited selection of its stories on its web site. (Even after the pay wall goes up, the News still plans to put some free content on the site, like blogs, obituaries, wedding announcements, and photo galleries.)

The News’s situation has been helped in a number of ways by troubles at the Providence Journal, the longstanding statewide newspaper; when the Journal gave up a printing contract for a Spanish weekly, the News picked it up. (The News also owns several weeklies, magazines, and annuals such Newport Wedding Magazine and Home and Lifestyles.)

The News is betting that, for a newspaper its size, its journalism and its relationships with advertisers work best in print. Sherman says that online ad revenue never made much of a dent in their bottom line, and that keeping print advertisers happy with what the News offers is a much higher priority.

“The people we hired to sell advertising on the Internet just never did very well.”

Sherman, whose family has owned the Rhode Island newspaper since 1918, said “we’ve wanted for years for someone to come out with the new model” that his paper could emulate. He expected it to come from a bigger paper with more resources than his. But now it’s his retro model that’s attracting attention.

“I’m sure the Providence Journal is watching this with great interest,” he says.

                                   
What to read next
RevealCIRlogo
Justin Ellis    July 18, 2014
With $3.5 million in grant funding and an eye for collaboration, the Center for Investigative Reporting and PRX aim to bring deep investigations to radio and podcasting.
  • http://www.bigworldmagazine.com Mary D’Ambrosio

    I teach journalism, and run a web magazine, so I applaud the Newport Daily News for taking a crack at a creating paid web product. Alas: by aggressively overpricing it, the paper sends a “welcome, stranger” message to short-term or occasional visitors like me. I’m an out-of-towner in Newport for a single stormy winter’s night, and would gladly pay the normal cover price to catch up on the local news online. But, $5 for a single read? Sorry! If the News dropped its daily price to 50 cents or a dollar, I’d gladly fork over a the requisite micropayment next time I’m in town.

  • http://phraction.com Jeff Johns

    This is a silly web strategy, kill the web and focus back on print. The younger readers will never buy the print product so once your customer base dies off, so do you.

    Good luck, I don’t see this working. Just my opinion.

  • Barry

    Isnt It sad-they just dont get It…..

  • http://www.thegolfswingfix.com/ The Golf Swing Guy

    This is not a bad idea as long as their is no competition to go against. This seems to be the case in Rhode Island. We’ll have to stay tuned to see the outcome.

  • http://www.cheapshirtsoutletonline.com lacoste polo shirts

    I’m an out-of-towner in Newport for a single stormy winter’s night, and would gladly pay the normal cover price to catch up on the local news online. But, $5 for a single read? Sorry!

  • http://www.lacostepoloshirtsonline.com lacoste outlet

    I don’t see this working

  • http://www.lacostepoloshirtsonsale.co.uk cheap lacoste

    it’s a three-tier pricing structure

  • http://twitter.com/BienPia1 Bien Pia