Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
James Pindell is trying to bring The Boston Globe’s election coverage to everyone by being everywhere
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Aug. 17, 2009, 9 a.m.

Hope you’re “intrigued” by this post: Moods in the spotlight on NBC Local

New York is furious about the mayor’s new Twitter habit, Chicago is snickering at an Oprah lawsuit, and Los Angeles continues to mourn the passing of director John Hughes.

These city-wide emotional check-ins are plucked from NBC’s recently launched local web network. The network’s 10 sites, all associated with NBC owned-and-operated broadcast stations, feature “mood” applications that capture audience sentiment at the story level. Think of it as a hybrid approach: combining the structure and ease of web polls with the strong emotions typically found in user comments.

Tapping and featuring audience emotions is part of NBC’s effort to redraw the boundaries of participation on its local sites. “The city web sites are designed to capture the real-time pulse of the city,” says Greg Gittrich, vice president of content and editor in chief of NBC Local Integrated Media. “The stories we cover are a big part of that, but how our audience reacts to the stories is also significant. So we started looking at ways to elevate the voice of the users and give them meaningful ways to impact and influence the sites.”

Here’s how the mood application works: Visit a story on an NBC local site and look for the adjacent mood bar that notes current voting in six categories: furious, sad, bored, thrilled, intrigued, and laughing. Cast your own vote through the accompanying drop-down menu and watch as percentages update accordingly. That’s all there is to it on the user’s end.

At the site level, though, those emotions get turned into data. An automated system showcases the five stories with the highest number of ratings in a “mood status line” embedded in the site’s header that changes with each refresh. “It’s not a static mood line that’s sitting up there,” says Gittrich. “It chooses the most emotional stories, the most mood-rated stories. It shows the different perspectives of each city.” Toward that end, mood ratings and user comments do not travel between sites in the network, even on stories with a national focus — the intent is to capture city-specific emotions.

Beta versions of NBC’s local sites launched in October 2008, and in the ensuing nine months combined traffic across all 10 sites increased from 5 million to 20 million unique visitors per month. Gittrich attributes much of the growth to a focus on actionable, local content. The mood application itself registers an average of 10,000 votes per day across the 10 sites, according to Brian Buchwald, senior vice president for NBC Local Integrated Media. (It’s hard to tell if it’s having any impact on traffic, since the mood tool debuted with the local sites’ July 29th “commercial” launch.)

Gathering data

A statistician would be quick to note that the tool’s results aren’t exactly scientifically valid. But that doesn’t mean they aren’t fun. For example, the status line on NBC New York recently uncovered pockets of partisan conflict in the city. “On Saturday [Aug. 8] the reaction to [Sonia] Sotomayor being sworn in on the New York site was alternating throughout the day between ‘furious’ and ‘thrilled,’ which I found surprising given the city’s politics,” says Gittrich. “I kept going on the site throughout the day to see how the rating was toggling back and forth.”

Some commenters reference and expand upon a story’s mood with deeper discussion, “writing things like ‘I agree, this story is truly sad,’ and then saying why they think so,” says Gittrich. “I like the fact that people are using the different tools together. Obviously some people are going to be more inclined to use mood. Some are going to be more inclined to make a comment. Other people are going to submit photos or write their own post on So My City [another social component on the NBC local sites]. But it’s interesting when you see them interplaying with one another.”

Aggregated mood data could have a life beyond the websites as well. Gittrich says staff at the NBC stations have expressed interest in mood information, although he hasn’t yet seen it included in broadcasts. And this sort of regimented, push-button feedback seems tailor-made for mobile — 10 city-specific NBC Local iPhone apps are slated to launch in September — and alternative platforms such as trains, taxis, stadiums, etc.

On a broader scale, NBC’s master database of mood results makes cross-city tabulations and other internal data mining possible. There’s also potential for future developer access via APIs, according to Robyn Peterson, vice president of product at NBC Local Integrated Media.

The ability to mine and display collective opinion gives websites one more pathway to serendipitous discovery — the absence of which has been lamented since the Daily Me was first conceived. Features like “most commented posts” or “most emailed stories” can make it easier for users to find interesting content on a site, but NBC’s mood effort goes a step further by overtly integrating audience activity into highly visible spots on the sites. It’s a way to boost the audience’s feeling of community. We’ll see whether moods — or something similar — eventually become as commonplace as comments and slideshows as tools to make website visitors stick around a little longer.

POSTED     Aug. 17, 2009, 9 a.m.
SHARE THIS STORY
   
Show comments  
Show tags
 
Join the 15,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
James Pindell is trying to bring The Boston Globe’s election coverage to everyone by being everywhere
“Whether it’s their inbox, whether it’s for Twitter, Facebook, Medium, Instagram — the idea is to reach audiences where they’re at.”
The New York Times collaborates with This American Life on a special investigative report
The New York Times is running its story Friday, while This American Life’s complementary report will air this weekend and be available for download as a podcast Sunday.
With an interface that looks like a chat platform, Quartz wants to text you the news in its new app
“The content type is always messages, and that’s always true whether you’re getting the message inside the app or as a notification.”
What to read next
0
tweets
From Nieman Reports: Startups are revitalizing journalism in Brazil’s challenging environment
Despite a fraught political and economic environment for journalists, new outlets in Brazil are now experimenting with fact-checking, longform narrative writing, and citizen media.
0The Conversation expands across the U.S., freshly funded by universities and foundations
The news site that uses academics as reporters and journalists as editors now boasts 19 paying member universities and is opening up posts in Atlanta (and maybe in the Bay Area).
0A Howard project is debunking myths about African-Americans and teaching students fact-checking
“There are more black men in prison than college.” “A dollar spent in the black community stays there for only six hours.” A project at Howard University aims to dispel oft-repeated myths.
These stories are our most popular on Twitter over the past 30 days.
See all our most recent pieces ➚
Encyclo is our encyclopedia of the future of news, chronicling the key players in journalism’s evolution.
Here are a few of the entries you’ll find in Encyclo.   Get the full Encyclo ➚
ProPublica
FactCheck.org
Politico
Investigative News Network
California Watch
Storify
Tumblr
Tucson Citizen
Google
Upworthy
News Corp
BBC News