Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
How young Kenyans turned to news influencers when protesters stormed the country’s parliament
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Jan. 21, 2009, 3:39 p.m.

The end of Google’s print ad effort

It’s not terribly surprising to me that Google has given up on its two-year-old program to funnel print ads to newspapers.  As a newspaper publisher, I provided pre-alpha feedback to Google on this program in 2006, and was involved in it from its earliest rollout until I left the business last spring.

No paper that I know of saw anything more than a trickle of advertising through this channel.  Google won’t say how much business Print Ads did.  But Google probably anticipated plenty of volume, so it built in only a small commission for itself.  My guestimation is that their cut came to $1 million or less — probably not enough to cover costs, and certainly a figure with not enough zeros to keep it going as part of Google.  I would not read this as Google giving up on newspapers — in better times, they killed programs with similarly minimal revenue, such as Google Answers.

Among the program’s flaws was the bidding system incorporated in it. Not only did this require a potential managerial decision for each individual ad, but it involved some back-and-forth dickering for every ad.  Most of the very few offers that came through this channel were extremely low-ball ad proposals from sometimes questionable advertisers.

Meanwhile, Google has introduced Google Ad Planner, still in beta rollout, a tool for creating online advertising plans that incorporates the ability to find and select sites based on demographics — a feature that was entirely absent from Print Ads.

POSTED     Jan. 21, 2009, 3:39 p.m.
Show tags
 
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
How young Kenyans turned to news influencers when protesters stormed the country’s parliament
A recent study shows the country’s news ecosystem is shifting towards alternative sources. This trend might shape journalism in the years to come.
Are you being tailed? Tips for reporters concerned about physical surveillance
“As a profession, you’d hope reporters would be good at reading people, situations, scenarios. So how many do you think spotted the spotters? None.”
Why a centuries-old local newspaper in New Hampshire launched a journalism fund
The Keene Sentinel weighed the pros and cons of becoming a nonprofit. It chose a hybrid option instead.