A Canadian heavyweight matchup: Clay Shirky versus Andrew Keen

Our own Mathew Ingram moderated a panel discussion last week between two luminaries in the future-of-content-online space: Clay Shirky (who readers of this site know well) and Andrew Keen, whose thoughts on the subject can probably be sussed out from the title of his book, The Cult of the Amateur: How Today’s Internet is Killing Our Culture. (Available on the Kindle!)

Their wide ranging discussion was captured in all the usual 2009 forms: a liveblog, a hashtag, and video, which I’ve embedded below in four parts. (Note that introductions take a little while, so you may want to skip ahead a bit.)

Get Nieman Lab’s Daily Digest

The most important stories about journalism and the future of news, delivered to your inbox every afternoon.

Joshua Benton is the senior writer and former director of Nieman Lab, which he founded in 2008. You can reach him via email, Twitter (@jbenton), or Bluesky.

The latest from Nieman Lab

The Nieman Lab News-About-News Quiz, November 13, 2026

From new majors to search traffic, newspapers to impeachment: Have you kept up with this week's media news?