Nieman Foundation at Harvard
What journalists and independent creators can learn from each other
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Dec. 13, 2012, 11 a.m.

Better (not second) screens, document clustering, and mobile-native news: Some of Spark Camp’s big ideas of 2012

Amy Webb, Scott Klein, and Jim Frederick share some of the big ideas they’ll take away from the year.
Editor’s Note: What were the most interesting and provocative ideas in journalism in 2012? We’re partnering with Spark Camp to produce a special end-of-year series to ask a group of smart people — Spark Camp’s alumni — that question. (Learn more about Spark Camp at the first post in this series.) Here are thoughts from:

— Amy Webb, a Spark Camp co-founder and CEO of Webbmedia Group, a digital strategy agency. Her new book, Data, A Love Story: How I Gamed Online Dating To Meet My Mate, will be out on January 31.

Scott Klein, editor of news applications at ProPublica, where he directs a team of journalist/programmers building large interactive software projects that tell journalistic stories. Scott is also co-founder of DocumentCloud.

Jim Frederick, editor of Time International. Jim oversees all of Time’s international news coverage appearing in Time’s four global editions, on, and across its other digital and mobile platforms. He is co-author of The Reluctant Communist: My Desertion, Court-Martial and 40-Year Imprisonment in North Korea and author of Black Hearts: One Platoon’s Descent Into Madness in Iraq’s Triangle of Death.

Amy Webb

Amy WebbVideo was what everyone talked about last year, and it will continue to be an important topic in 2013. By the end of 2012, 72 hours of video were being uploaded to YouTube alone every minute. We’re obsessed with creating video — but do we care as much about watching it?

Some media organizations think so, and they spent tremendous resources last year experimenting with new ways to distribute video content. Politico, The Washington Post, The New York Times, NBC Universal, New York magazine…I can’t think of a single major media outlet that wasn’t pushing video in 2012.

One of my favorite projects was the smartly-designed HBO GO, which does a lot of things but is most useful when delivering helpful content during time-shifted viewing. I’d argue that HBO’s “Game of Thrones” is nearly unwatchable on my living room television — but when viewed through the HBO GO I’m able to get the critical details about the show’s many, many characters who are inexplicably left out of the storyline. (Like, who’s this new guy in a lion cloth, and why is everyone so mad at him?)

It brings to mind ongoing conversations about second screens. Why build a second screen experience at all? What we really need is a better screen. HuffPost Live may not have launched brilliant (or sometimes even comprehensible) commentary this year, but the dashboard offers an interesting alternative to traditional broadcast news. So does

The news cycle is fickle, and broadcast journalists often subject viewers to an echo chamber of buzzwords. (Where, exactly, is this fiscal cliff?) If we must truncate public discourse while a story is active over a period of weeks or months, then news orgs should at least offer viewers the opportunity to get more information from them. If not, the video they’re streaming live or putting into elaborate online players will only cause consumers to leave that news site for Wikipedia to learn that the fiscal cliff is a “number of laws that (if unchanged) could result in tax increases, spending cuts, and a corresponding reduction in the US budget deficit beginning in 2013.”

Scott Klein

Scott KleinIn 2012, as part of our Message Machine project, we started using new (to us) techniques like topic modeling, document clustering, and machine learning. We found these tools to be hugely useful and very powerful, and enable bigger assignments than we ever thought possible, like adding structure to very large sets of unstructured text.

We had conversations with academic computer scientists to make sure we were getting the math right and using the right tool for the job. Out of those conversations came a pretty simple observation: Computer scientists have great tools but sometimes boring data (there’s a lot of Twitter firehose out there) and data journalists have great data but aren’t using the latest techniques to analyze it. Perhaps most tantalizing: One computer scientist, who was a bit surprised that journalists only pursue a single story at a time when analyzing data, suggested that academic CS can even provide journalists “hypothesis generation at scale.”

The missing piece, which it’s our endeavor to help develop next year, is the “middleware” between the two disciplines. We need a matching service and coordination assistance so CS folks and data journalists can find each other, and some mechanism by which the collaborations can yield the best, most widely applicable, results.

Jim Frederick

Jim FrederickMost mobile sites are still just websites scrunched onto a tiny screen. This is like when TV was new and anchors just read newspaper stories, or when the web was new and sites just posted static articles. Now we’re finally getting serious attempts to exploit mobile as a unique medium and create news that is created exclusively for it rather than as a port from a legacy system.

So we have attempts to understand “what is news?” almost in its most elemental sense, to break it down to its atoms so that it can be consumed and shared in far smaller chunks than ever before — but in ways that are still satisfying, both on the go and on an small screen. It’s going to take a lot of work before anybody gets it right, but the Circa iPhone app is the best first try I have seen at this.

POSTED     Dec. 13, 2012, 11 a.m.
PART OF A SERIES     Spark Camp's Big Ideas of 2012
Show tags
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
What journalists and independent creators can learn from each other
“The question is not about the topics but how you approach the topics.”
Deepfake detection improves when using algorithms that are more aware of demographic diversity
“Our research addresses deepfake detection algorithms’ fairness, rather than just attempting to balance the data. It offers a new approach to algorithm design that considers demographic fairness as a core aspect.”
What it takes to run a metro newspaper in the digital era, according to four top editors
“People will pay you to make their lives easier, even when it comes to telling them which burrito to eat.”