Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
“It’s just become daily news”: Six Florida newsrooms are teaming up to cover climate change
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
Jan. 25, 2018, 12:25 p.m.
Audience & Social

Facebook’s trust survey, which will help determine News Feed ranking, is two questions. But it’s not as simple as it sounds

What’s clear is that Facebook has plenty of data from users already, which it can — will — use in conjunction with its two-question survey.

Do you recognize the following websites: (Yes. No.)

That’s Facebook’s first question on a survey for users that Facebook wrote up itself, which the company will use as a signal that affects a news publisher’s ranking in the News Feed, according to BuzzFeed News, which first obtained the entire survey.

Here’s the second — and final — question Facebook intends to ask its users: How much do you trust each of these domains? (Options: Entirely / A lot / Somewhat / Barely / Not at all)

From publishers, eyerolls and snark ensued, as well as that ever-present baseline fear of traffic to news sites drying up and the “bloodletting” to come at organizations fixated on that absolute traffic number. Mark Zuckerberg has said in a Facebook post that these updates would “not change the amount of news [users] see on Facebook,” and that these “tweaks for trust” would only mean a change in the “balance of news you see towards sources that are determined to be trusted by the community.”

The survey is brief; how exactly it’ll be used is less clean cut. Adam Mosseri, Facebook’s VP for News Feed and media Twitter’s favorite Facebook rep has responded directly, and with some specificity, to questions and comments on Facebook and Twitter.

How big a ranking signal is this “trust” thing? Casey Newton of The Verge asked, and sort of got an answer:

What’s clear is that Facebook has plenty of data from users already, which it can — will — use in conjunction with its two-question survey.

Embedded in the trust question are additional user characteristics: Facebook is looking at how trusted a news organization is, by a range of users, with a range of news consumption habits.

Some offered other ideas for measuring trust. Mike Caulfield, head of the Digital Polarization Initiative at the American Democracy Project, laid out this suggestion.

From the rollout of the News Feed announcement to Facebook’s follow-up, it can really feel as if there’s a disconnect between teams (it’s a pure engineering problem vs. algorithms are flawed and need a human touch) and among its leadership (why has Facebook’s head of news partnerships Campbell Brown been so quiet?).

Some things are certain: Facebook will roll out new products for news. Announcements will use the phrases “meaningful connections” and “friends and family” and “community.” And news organizations will still stay on the platform, only a little bit less visible to users, and a little bit more battered by uncertainty.

POSTED     Jan. 25, 2018, 12:25 p.m.
SEE MORE ON Audience & Social
SHARE THIS STORY
   
 
Join the 50,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
“It’s just become daily news”: Six Florida newsrooms are teaming up to cover climate change
“It’s not a science story for us here in South Florida. It’s not some kind of theoretical exploration. It’s real. It’s what many in our community experience in their neighborhoods.”
Could technology built for advertising make public radio less top-down and more bottom-up?
Plus: A British podcast company finds surprising success stateside, the Supreme Court provides a S02E14 for In the Dark, and a documentary about Freaknik.
Can you spot a fake photo online? Your level of experience online matters a lot more than contextual clues
Whether an image looks like a random Facebook post or part of a New York Times story doesn’t make much of a difference. But your level of experience with the Internet and image editing does.