Nieman Foundation at Harvard
After criticism over “viewpoint diversity,” NPR adds new layers of editorial oversight
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
July 10, 2019, 9:12 a.m.
Reporting & Production

Hong Kong protests, but also the Met Gala: The New York Times Chinese edition looks for new audiences

“Censorship is a way of life in China right now. Everybody knows that whatever they say and share is controlled by the government. But our traffic has been rising, especially this summer, with all of the big news out of the trade war and the Hong Kong protests, as well as some of the sensitive anniversaries of this year.”

Amid Hong Kong protests, trade wars, and the 30th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square protests, it’s been a big summer for news about China — but of course it’s not easy for Chinese citizens to see uncensored versions of that news.

The news is there, however, for people who can use VPNs to get around the Great Firewall — and one place they can find it is at The New York Times’ Chinese-language edition, which turned seven this summer and was the paper’s first foreign-language edition. (The second was NYT en Español, which launched in 2016.)

The site initially launched to attract China’s growing middle class. A few years in, it’s expanding, with an email newsletter, a WeChat account for non-political stories, and side-by-side Chinese/English versions of stories. I spoke with Ching-Ching Ni, editor-in-chief of the Times’ Chinese site and a 2009 Nieman Fellow, about her day-to-day job and what the Times hopes to accomplish in China. Our conversation, edited slightly for length and clarity, is below.

Laura Hazard Owen: How did you get to where you are?

Ching-Ching Ni: When I was at the Nieman Foundation, it was a moment of transition for me. I’d been working for about 10 years for the L.A. Times covering China, and I was hoping to find that new direction and a different way to make an impact in journalism. In 2009, the economy was crashing, it was difficult to find a new way out, and I’m really lucky because I was able to do two things that allowed me to apply my experience as a journalist and as a cross-cultural person between China and the U.S.

I went back to China to teach journalism and train the next generation of Chinese journalists at Shantou University. And then I got to transition into this current job as editor of the New York Times Chinese edition. Now I get to help share the best New York Times journalism with the entire Chinese-language-speaking world, and that is something I consider high-impact and super-meaningful.

Owen: What is your day-to-day job like? What is the role of the Times’ Chinese website?

Ni: Our job is to curate The New York Times’ content, translate, and promote it. I choose the stories that are relevant to our audience and assign them to our team of translators who translate and edit. Then we publish. We promote by publishing it on our homepage and our social media platforms. We now also have a brand-new briefing newsletter, which is our new way of trying to reach our audience directly through email.

I also do a lot of outreach to get the word out about the fact that there is a Chinese-language edition of The New York Times. A lot of people don’t know that, and whether I’m in China or America, part of my job is to tell people about it, to get the Chinese-language-speaking world aware of this amazing free public service that we provide at The New York Times.

Owen: Who is your audience?

Ni: We believe at least half of our audience — maybe more than half — comes from inside mainland China. We don’t know exactly, because most people use VPN, so it’s hard to know the precise location, but based on their time zone and their browser language, we can guess that they are coming from mainland China.

This is important because our audience is both inside and outside of China — so we’re talking about the entire Chinese-language speaking world, which right now is very much in demand of a reliable, high-quality media outlet that can provide uncensored news and information about the world, and especially about China. Because of the heavy censorship out of China, the entire Chinese-language media world is under attack, so whether you’re inside China or outside, your ability to speak freely is highly limited now. The New York Times Chinese edition fulfills a critical role in this new world. We see this very much as part of our mission as The New York Times to help our readers understand the world.

Owen: The Times’ website is blocked inside China. How does that affect the way you speak to your audience?

Ni: Censorship is a way of life in China right now. Everybody knows that whatever they say and share is controlled by the government. But our traffic has been rising, especially this summer, with all of the big news out of the trade war and the Hong Kong protests, as well as some of the sensitive anniversaries of this year.

What that means is that when there’s big news, our audience goes out of their way to find us. That’s why our traffic is rising. In terms of using the VPN, it is no doubt a challenge and a barrier, but when the information is not available to them anywhere else, I think enough people value what we do and they go out of their way to find us.

The government is making it more and more difficult to use the VPN, and we’re glad that the VPN still works. The other thing, of course, is we’re trying to grow the overseas audience as well, because Chinese speakers around the world don’t need a VPN, but they don’t always know we exist, so we’re trying to improve our outreach.

Owen: What does that outreach consist of right now?

Ni: It’s very hard for us to now exist inside Chinese social media. We are growing very fast outside Chinese social media — we have over 1 million followers on Twitter and about half a million on Facebook, so if people can’t find us inside Chinese social media, they do find us outside.

We also have a foothold inside Chinese social media: We have one WeChat account where we share non-sensitive political stories that are still high-quality and relevant, and we’re quickly growing that audience as well. It’s a different kind of audience there: Our main audience comes to us for about political news about China and the world that they won’t see anywhere else, but on WeChat, we share other things, like lifestyle or educational stories, that are also very relevant to our readers and perhaps help to develop a different kind of audience.

Owen: Which non-political topics do the best for you?

Ni: Smarter Living is very popular — stories about overworking and the importance of sleep. Modern Love, food, and pictures of the Met Gala, things like that. A lot of Chinese people didn’t know The New York Times had this rich variety of non-political stories.

We started a unique original Chinese feature called Word of the Day, where we take a word from the news and explain to the Chinese audience what it means. Because we have limited resources, we don’t translate every single NYT story — we have to pick and choose — and often we don’t have time to translate a lot of American cultural stories, for example. So we use Word of the Day to explain, for example, when the Met Gala happened and the theme was “camp” — what does “camp” mean in Chinese? Even a lot of English speakers don’t know what camp means. So we explained that. We’ll explain things like “grit.” And a lot of things related to Trump — what is “temperament,” things like that.

Also, one of the unique things we offer on the Chinese New York Times is that we not only have a Chinese version of the stories that we translate, we have a bilingual side-by-side feature that allows readers to see a story in both English and Chinese simultaneously side by side. It’s a great learning tool, and it’s very time-consuming for us, but we do it as a public service and a lot of people enjoy that.

Owen: You mentioned that the site is free. Are there any plans to ever launch some kind of paywall for it?

Ni: For now, it’s free, as we’re building up and try to get the word out. But eventually, we can see ourselves moving in the direction of the English paywall. But I don’t have a timeline right now. It’s something that we consider a public service right now, but I think that the audience, once they see the value of what we offer, they’re going to want to support us and support our mission.

Laura Hazard Owen is the editor of Nieman Lab. You can reach her via email ( or Twitter DM (@laurahazardowen).
POSTED     July 10, 2019, 9:12 a.m.
SEE MORE ON Reporting & Production
Show tags
Join the 60,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
After criticism over “viewpoint diversity,” NPR adds new layers of editorial oversight
“We will all have to adjust to a new workflow. If it is a bottleneck, it will be a failure.”
“Impossible to approach the reporting the way I normally would”: How Rachel Aviv wrote that New Yorker story on Lucy Letby
“So much of the media coverage — and the trial itself — started at the point at which we’ve determined that [Lucy] Letby is an evil murderer; all her texts, notes, and movements are then viewed through that lens.”
Increasingly stress-inducing subject lines helped The Intercept surpass its fundraising goal
“We feel like we really owe it to our readers to be honest about the stakes and to let them know that we truly cannot do this work without them.”