Nieman Foundation at Harvard
HOME
          
LATEST STORY
James Pindell is trying to bring The Boston Globe’s election coverage to everyone by being everywhere
ABOUT                    SUBSCRIBE
April 18, 2011, 11 a.m.

The layered look: How Google News is integrating the social web

While many have been closely following the news of new social network projects from Google — whether it’s Google Wave, Google Buzz, or a rumored project reportedly called Google Me — the search giant has been rolling out a number of products that add a “social layer” to its search, sometimes quietly and other times with official announcements. Most recently, it announced Google +1, an application that acted as the equivalent of the Facebook “Like” for search results.

But perhaps the most apposite example of social web integration is the kind slowly being added to Google News. This is the search vertical that people often turn to for aggregation and current news (in fact, unless otherwise specified, most searches turn up articles less than a month old), so it’s not difficult to understand why Google would want to use it to tap into the immediacy of social media. Other algorithm-based aggregation sites have already developed similar measures. For instance, Techmeme announced earlier this year that it would begin publishing tweets as headlines. “It seemed as if something was missing in passing over tweets,” wrote Techmeme’s Gabe Rivera. “We’d miss the first few minutes of certain developing stories as well as opportunities for including good commentary. We also missed the chance to let certain sources simply speak under their own byline.” Google’s Matt Cutts suggested recently that publishers should tweet links to their articles immediately in order to get them indexed more quickly within the search engine.

I spoke with Jeannie Hornung, a spokesperson for Google News, about the various ways Twitter and other social media platforms are used by the aggregator. She pointed first to the “Most Shared” section, found on the right sidebar near the bottom of the main page. At the time of this writing, it displays headlines from a mixture of blogs and more traditional news outlets and allows you to sort the most popular stories by day, week, and month. (Only news outlets that are among the 50,000+ aggregated by Google News are included.)

But “most shared” in what way? While Hornung confirmed that Twitter was one of the signals used in this section, she said she couldn’t comment on the others. But the feature includes a drop-down menu allowing one to share these stories on various platforms — email, Google Reader, Twitter, Facebook, and Google Buzz — and so it wouldn’t be too presumptuous to assume that many of these platforms are used in the algorithm, as well.

Hornung also pointed out a feature launched just last week on Google News; if you click on a news cluster of stories from the front page, it now aggregates related tweets on the sidebar of that cluster. “It’s using the same technology that real-time search uses,” she told me, confirming that the tweets aren’t a raw feed, but rather are ranked by authority or “relevance.” Unlike the “Most Shared” section, however, these tweets do not all have links to stories indexed by Google News; they’re based, instead, on related keywords.

“The Tweets section appears when there’s a high level of activity on Twitter focused on that story and those tweets add diversity to the full coverage page,” Hornung wrote in a follow-up email. “For example, we demote tweets that are on a broad topic not necessarily tied to the specific news story, that simply restate a headline and/or that link to a story already included on the full coverage page.”

But I couldn’t help but notice that most of the social integration is only apparent on the sidebar, rather than within the main search results. Is it possible that the algorithm uses any incoming signals from Twitter to determine a news story’s prominence? As with most questions about the 100+ signals in Google’s algorithm, I got a “no comment.”

Hornung did say that the raw immediacy of social media is better suited for Google’s Realtime Search than Google News. “Google News is quite fast because it isn’t hand-curated,” she said. “Because it is an algorithm, it can see stories quickly, but it can only see them as quickly as publishers publish them so it can index those stories.”

While the idea of social media integration being added to all of Google News’ aggregation is appealing to a tech media reporter like myself, Hornung was more realistic in addressing Google’s approach. “I understand why you’re driving at that because it’s the premise of the story,” she said. “It really is — not to diminish it at all — it is an incremental enhancement to the full coverage page, not the main page. So I wouldn’t say adding tweets to full coverage is a sign of anything larger than a moderate enhancement to the full coverage page.”

Or, to put it another way: “It’s a tasty side dish.”

POSTED     April 18, 2011, 11 a.m.
SHARE THIS STORY
   
Show comments  
Show tags
 
Join the 15,000 who get the freshest future-of-journalism news in our daily email.
James Pindell is trying to bring The Boston Globe’s election coverage to everyone by being everywhere
“Whether it’s their inbox, whether it’s for Twitter, Facebook, Medium, Instagram — the idea is to reach audiences where they’re at.”
The New York Times collaborates with This American Life on a special investigative report
The New York Times is running its story Friday, while This American Life’s complementary report will air this weekend and be available for download as a podcast Sunday.
With an interface that looks like a chat platform, Quartz wants to text you the news in its new app
“The content type is always messages, and that’s always true whether you’re getting the message inside the app or as a notification.”
What to read next
0
tweets
From Nieman Reports: Startups are revitalizing journalism in Brazil’s challenging environment
Despite a fraught political and economic environment for journalists, new outlets in Brazil are now experimenting with fact-checking, longform narrative writing, and citizen media.
0The Conversation expands across the U.S., freshly funded by universities and foundations
The news site that uses academics as reporters and journalists as editors now boasts 19 paying member universities and is opening up posts in Atlanta (and maybe in the Bay Area).
0A Howard project is debunking myths about African-Americans and teaching students fact-checking
“There are more black men in prison than college.” “A dollar spent in the black community stays there for only six hours.” A project at Howard University aims to dispel oft-repeated myths.
These stories are our most popular on Twitter over the past 30 days.
See all our most recent pieces ➚
Encyclo is our encyclopedia of the future of news, chronicling the key players in journalism’s evolution.
Here are a few of the entries you’ll find in Encyclo.   Get the full Encyclo ➚
The Economist
Fox News
Las Vegas Sun
Kickstarter
San Francisco Chronicle
Forbes
Newsweek
Examiner.com
Tribune Publishing
PolitiFact
The Wall Street Journal
McClatchy