As if there wasn’t enough Facebook news to digest already, another deep dive from The Washington Post this morning revealed that Facebook engineers changed the company’s algorithm to prioritize and elevate posts that elicited emoji reactions — many of which were rolled out in 2017. More specifically, the ranking algorithm treated reactions such as “angry,” “love,” “sad,” and “wow” as five times more valuable than traditional “likes” on the social media platform.
The problem with this plan for engagement: Other posts also likely to yield similar reactions were more likely to show up, only these posts were likely to also contain misinformation, spam, or forms of clickbait. One Facebook staffer, whose name was redacted in a dump of documents shared with the Securities and Exchange Commission by whistleblower and former Facebook employee Frances Haugen, had warned that this might happen; they were proven right.
According to the Post, “The company’s data scientists confirmed in 2019 that posts that sparked angry reaction emoji were disproportionately likely to include misinformation, toxicity and low-quality news.”
More on that:
That means Facebook for three years systematically amped up some of the worst of its platform, making it more prominent in users’ feeds and spreading it to a much wider audience. The power of the algorithmic promotion undermined the efforts of Facebook’s content moderators and integrity teams, who were fighting an uphill battle against toxic and harmful content.
This isn’t the first time that “anger” has reared its ugly head as a useful metric. Back in 2017, a report found that hyper-political publishers were especially adept at provoking the anger of their readers. And in 2019, another report found some of the effects of Facebook’s change to prioritizing meaningful interactions:
- It has pushed up articles on divisive topics like abortion, religion, and guns;
- politics rules; and
- the “angry” reaction (😡) dominates many pages, with “Fox News driving the most angry reactions of anyone, with nearly double that of anyone else.”
Facebook introduced the suite of “reaction” emojis in response to a decline in people talking to each other on the social platform, according to the report. Giving the reactions five times the value of a single like was Facebook’s effort to signal that “the post had made a greater emotional impression than a like; reacting with an emoji took an extra step beyond the single click or tap of the like button.”
Mark Zuckerberg acknowledges that reactions can be used to indicate dislike.
Members of Facebook’s integrity teams raised concerns about the amplification of “anger” as a societal emotion, the documents reviewed by the Post show, but managers had a mixed record when it came to responding to these concerns.
A screenshot showing a staffer raising the question, “Quick question to play devil’s advocate: will weighting Reactions 5x stronger than Likes lead to News Feed having a higher ratio of controversial than agreeable content?”
According to the latest documents, even efforts to counteract this effect — when they were actually implemented — produced less-than-desirable results. For instance, even if Facebook employees tried to manipulate the score of a high-ranking post to get it to show up less often things often didn’t work out as planned.
If Facebook’s algorithms thought a post was bad, Facebook could cut its score in half, pushing most of instances of the post way down in users’ feeds. But a few posts could get scores as high as a billion, according to the documents. Cutting an astronomical score in half to “demote” it would still leave it with a score high enough to appear at the top of the user’s feed.
“Scary thought: civic demotions not working,” one Facebook employee noted.
The Post’s story details Facebook’s different attempts at dialing down this effect of amplifying reaction-driven posts.
When Facebook finally set the weight on the angry reaction to zero, users began to get less misinformation, less “disturbing” content and less “graphic violence,” company data scientists found. As it turned out, after years of advocacy and pushback, there wasn’t a trade-off after all. According to one of the documents, users’ level of activity on Facebook was unaffected.
Facebook’s reaction to this latest finding linking its algorithm and the prioritizing “anger” and posts that tend to invoke that emotion in users: “We continue to work to understand what content creates negative experiences, so we can reduce its distribution. This includes content that has a disproportionate amount of angry reactions, for example,” Facebook spokesperson Dani Lever told the Post.
22 comments:
Experience the epitome of airport travel through airporttransferdfw.com. Our luxury car service redefines premium airport transportation, offering comfort and sophistication combined. Travel lavishly and conveniently in our upscale vehicles. Reserve now for a dependable, opulent journey tailored to you
As a preeminent DFW luxury car service, we prioritize quality and safety for our clients by performing regular maintenance on our fleet of opulent vehicles. We recognize that our clientele expects nothing less than exceptional luxury and style, which is precisely what our services offer.
Make your birthday unforgettable with our party bus rentals. Enjoy spacious seating, customizable lighting, and top-notch sound systems as you and your friends ride in luxury, celebrating in style.
Explore top-tier party bus rentals in Miami, FL, through bestmiamipartybus.com. Find convenient and stylish options for your event needs. Rent a party bus hassle-free in vibrant Miami, Florida, ensuring a memorable transportation experience.
Uncover Maryland’s trusted bus companies specializing in group transportation services throughout the state. Whether for corporate functions or leisure excursions, find efficient solutions to meet your travel requirements. Experience unparalleled comfort and style with KV Limo’s luxurious transportation services tailored to your needs.
Experience seamless travel in the Bahamas with our efficient airport transfers. From convenient pickup and drop-off services at Nassau airport to smooth transportation across the islands, we’ve got your journey covered.
Nassau Airport to Rosewood Baha Mar – We’re excited to be able to provide professional transportation services from Nassau Airport to Rosewood Baha Mar and Paradise Island!
Bahamas Premium Transfers is proud to serve private transportation from Nassau Airport to Atlantis Resort with professional cheuffeur.
Reliable airport limo service in Parry Sound. Offering taxi service, airport transportation, and Parry Sound limo service. Count on our reliable taxi and airport shuttle for seamless travel.
Waterloo Airport Taxi provides reliable service with Waterloo Airport Limo options for a comfortable journey. Our Waterloo Taxi To Pearson Airport and Waterloo To Toronto Airport options ensure a stress-free travel experience.
Travel conveniently with our Buffalo Airport Shuttle Services, offering efficient transfers to various destinations including Niagara Falls. Enjoy comfortable and reliable transportation from the airport to your desired location.
Experience convenience with our Charter Bus Services in Chicago. From group tours to corporate events, we offer spacious coaches and professional drivers for your comfort. Trust us for reliable and efficient transportation solutions in Chicago.
Streamlined Teterboro Airport (TEB) transportation services feature shuttle, taxi, rental, and transfer options, providing hassle-free travel solutions for passengers.
Hire a limousine for your next event in Dubai. If you are looking for luxury, elegance and comfort, then you need to work with our team.
Streamline your journey from LAX to Orange County with our efficient transportation services. Trust our dedicated SNA airport transportation for a seamless and comfortable transfer between major Southern California destinations.
Mercedes Sprinter Dubai offers top-tier chauffeur services in Dubai, featuring luxury Mercedes Sprinter vans. Experience comfort, style, and reliability with professional drivers, ideal for corporate events and special occasions.
We are dedicated to providing quality Luxury airport transfers, including comfortable and reliable limousine services. We service all over Dubai city.
Little Stars Travel provides reliable airport transportation services in Dubai. With professional drivers and a versatile fleet, they ensure punctual and comfortable transfers to and from the airport. Whether for business or leisure, their services guarantee a hassle-free start or end to your journey in Dubai.
Experience a royal journey with a rental limo in Dubai. Whether it’s a celebration or an official occasion, indulge in the opulent ride of a limousine. Relax and relish the lavish stretch limo ride, and enjoy the luxury that Dubai has to offer.
My brother recommended I would possibly like this web site.
He used to be entirely right. This publish actually made my day.
You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this info!
Thanks!
Visit my blog สาระน่ารู้ทั่วไป
If you would like to obtain much from this paragraph then you have to apply these techniques to your won blog.
Here is my homepage เกร็ดความรู้
It’s really very difficult in this full of activity life
to listen news on Television, thus I only
use web for that reason, and obtain the latest news.
Here is my site :: สาระน่ารู้
Trackbacks:
Leave a comment