Being honest about how journalists are different from their communities

“Journalism is a team sport. We rely on each other to help us best reflect a complicated world and to wrestle with the most accurate versions of a variety of perspectives in good faith.”

Who we are as people affects how we do journalism. Our values, our lived experiences, our personal ethics, our surroundings, our friends…all of it influences what we’re curious about and what we find interesting. And collectively, that determines what we cover.

It’s also pretty undeniable that, collectively, journalists have a lot more in common with each other than we often do with the communities we serve. We are also not immune from the societal sorting that’s happening, in which we are increasingly surrounded by people we have a lot in common with.

As an industry, it’s clear we’re whiter, more educated and more middle to upper class (by actual salary or by mindset). We’re also more urban — 22% of newsroom employees live in New York, D.C. or L.A. compared to 13% of the overall workforce. It’s clear to me that we’re also more liberal and more secular, though hard data on those topics are harder to come by.

Journalism is a team sport. We rely on each other to help us best reflect a complicated world and to wrestle with the most accurate versions of a variety of perspectives in good faith.

We have gotten into the habit of acknowledging — but are still not making nearly fast enough progress on — our lack of racial diversity. (Sadly, I suspect we would be less transparent about that challenge if it were easier to hide.) We know that we have blind spots, and more newsrooms are investing in reckoning with the harm they have caused and with the intense work they need to do to earn a trusted role in the lives of communities of color. We’re still not doing nearly enough to talk openly about it with the people we serve. (Our team at Trusting News has been working on that.)

I’m hopeful that we’re also ready as an industry to talk honestly about how our lived experiences in other areas affect our ability to cover our communities with empathy and complexity. Do you have people on your team whose own experiences can help ensure your coverage of rural life is complex and based in the real values and priorities of the communities you cover? How about people with experience in law enforcement families? Or immigrant families?

How about when it comes to covering polarizing topics? I hope your newsrooms are staffed by people who agree with the basic fact that the outcome of the 2020 election was valid and are committed to reporting that authoritatively. But I also hope you have people who can empathize with the information climate that produced a majority of Republicans still saying last month that Trump’s claims had legitimacy. Our coverage needs to understand that information climate if we hope to penetrate it. And what about a topic like abortion? Can colleagues in your newsroom help each other present accurate, respectful, neutrally framed summaries across the spectrum of views on abortion?

I am hopeful that in 2022 we can do the following:

  • Let’s acknowledge internally where we’re coming from personally. Let’s talk about our values and experiences and bring our whole selves to our work. And let’s produce newsroom cultures that empower people — across staff power dynamics — to speak up and offer input that improves each other’s work.
  • Let’s address our blind spots proactively. Let’s use outreach and engagement strategies to build community relationships that can round out our understanding of the people we serve, and let’s invite those partners to hold us accountable for coverage that feels accurate and complex to people across our diverse communities.
  • Let’s hire differently. Let’s acknowledge our natural homophily and check our bias for people who see the world like we do. Let’s ask questions that help us better understand what experiences and values job candidates would add to our teams. (I’m working on this right now. If you’re interested in hearing how you could get involved, please get in touch.)

We’re better off when our team represents a variety of lived experiences. Let’s make this the year we get honest about who we are and how that affects our work.

Joy Mayer is director of Trusting News.

Who we are as people affects how we do journalism. Our values, our lived experiences, our personal ethics, our surroundings, our friends…all of it influences what we’re curious about and what we find interesting. And collectively, that determines what we cover.

It’s also pretty undeniable that, collectively, journalists have a lot more in common with each other than we often do with the communities we serve. We are also not immune from the societal sorting that’s happening, in which we are increasingly surrounded by people we have a lot in common with.

As an industry, it’s clear we’re whiter, more educated and more middle to upper class (by actual salary or by mindset). We’re also more urban — 22% of newsroom employees live in New York, D.C. or L.A. compared to 13% of the overall workforce. It’s clear to me that we’re also more liberal and more secular, though hard data on those topics are harder to come by.

Journalism is a team sport. We rely on each other to help us best reflect a complicated world and to wrestle with the most accurate versions of a variety of perspectives in good faith.

We have gotten into the habit of acknowledging — but are still not making nearly fast enough progress on — our lack of racial diversity. (Sadly, I suspect we would be less transparent about that challenge if it were easier to hide.) We know that we have blind spots, and more newsrooms are investing in reckoning with the harm they have caused and with the intense work they need to do to earn a trusted role in the lives of communities of color. We’re still not doing nearly enough to talk openly about it with the people we serve. (Our team at Trusting News has been working on that.)

I’m hopeful that we’re also ready as an industry to talk honestly about how our lived experiences in other areas affect our ability to cover our communities with empathy and complexity. Do you have people on your team whose own experiences can help ensure your coverage of rural life is complex and based in the real values and priorities of the communities you cover? How about people with experience in law enforcement families? Or immigrant families?

How about when it comes to covering polarizing topics? I hope your newsrooms are staffed by people who agree with the basic fact that the outcome of the 2020 election was valid and are committed to reporting that authoritatively. But I also hope you have people who can empathize with the information climate that produced a majority of Republicans still saying last month that Trump’s claims had legitimacy. Our coverage needs to understand that information climate if we hope to penetrate it. And what about a topic like abortion? Can colleagues in your newsroom help each other present accurate, respectful, neutrally framed summaries across the spectrum of views on abortion?

I am hopeful that in 2022 we can do the following:

  • Let’s acknowledge internally where we’re coming from personally. Let’s talk about our values and experiences and bring our whole selves to our work. And let’s produce newsroom cultures that empower people — across staff power dynamics — to speak up and offer input that improves each other’s work.
  • Let’s address our blind spots proactively. Let’s use outreach and engagement strategies to build community relationships that can round out our understanding of the people we serve, and let’s invite those partners to hold us accountable for coverage that feels accurate and complex to people across our diverse communities.
  • Let’s hire differently. Let’s acknowledge our natural homophily and check our bias for people who see the world like we do. Let’s ask questions that help us better understand what experiences and values job candidates would add to our teams. (I’m working on this right now. If you’re interested in hearing how you could get involved, please get in touch.)

We’re better off when our team represents a variety of lived experiences. Let’s make this the year we get honest about who we are and how that affects our work.

Joy Mayer is director of Trusting News.

Matt Karolian

Ståle Grut

Mario García

Sam Guzik

Moreno Cruz Osório

Whitney Phillips

Cindy Royal

Errin Haines

Jennifer Coogan

Jesse Holcomb

Mary Walter-Brown

Doris Truong

Anthony Nadler

Jennifer Brandel

Anita Varma

Simon Allison

j. Siguru Wahutu

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Andrew Freedman

Amara Aguilar

Alice Antheaume

Rachel Glickhouse

Gordon Crovitz

Natalia Viana

Michael W. Wagner

Eric Nuzum

Zizi Papacharissi

Simon Galperin

Robert Hernandez

Jonas Kaiser

Paul Cheung

Ariel Zirulnick

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Chase Davis

Sarah Stonbely

Joe Amditis

Raney Aronson-Rath

Parker Molloy

Julia Angwin

Joanne McNeil

Sarah Marshall

Francesco Zaffarano

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Matthew Pressman

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Gonzalo del Peon

Victor Pickard

Don Day

Jim Friedlich

Megan McCarthy

Jessica Clark

Cristina Tardáguila

Millie Tran

Kerri Hoffman

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Meena Thiruvengadam

Kristen Jeffers

Candace Amos

A.J. Bauer

Gabe Schneider

Matt DeRienzo

Mike Rispoli

Kristen Muller

Joy Mayer

Stephen Fowler

S. Mitra Kalita

Larry Ryckman

Julia Munslow

James Green

Wilson Liévano

Christina Shih

Tom Trewinnard

Melody Kramer

Anika Anand

Stefanie Murray

Shalabh Upadhyay

Juleyka Lantigua

Cherian George

Janelle Salanga

Daniel Eilemberg

Christoph Mergerson

Nikki Usher

Mandy Jenkins

Joni Deutsch

Richard Tofel

Tamar Charney

Catalina Albeanu

An Xiao Mina

Jody Brannon

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Burt Herman

David Cohn

David Skok

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Izabella Kaminska

John Davidow

Chicas Poderosas

Brian Moritz

Tony Baranowski

Joshua P. Darr