Tomorrow’s news audience: Smaller, but more obsessed

“It’s a whole new era of convergence, one that a growing segment of the American news audience distrusts — but also can’t resist.”

If you spend as much time as I do with survey data about the news media, it’s hard to escape the conclusion that news audiences — at least here in the U.S. — are on the decline.

To be sure, news consumption tends to come in peaks and troughs around election cycles, and so a languishing news audience in 2022 would fit a predictable pattern. And further, many observers have noted the burnout effect following months of wearying news about Covid-19. (The Knight-Gallup Trust, Media, and Democracy research initiative — for which I am an advisor — saw that audiences were turning away from the news after a 2020 spike in interest.)

But the audience erosion extends beyond episodic boom and bust. The Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism has tracked American usage of major news sources for nearly a decade, and has shown steady — if incremental — declines for not just print and television, but digital, including social news usage as well. (On the latter point, the Pew Research Center has also shown something approaching a cool-down in the last year). Gallup, which has been tracking news consumption for decades, has also shown steady erosion across most sources.

Yet for all the well-documented evidence of news avoidance, we’re also experiencing a moment of acute political hobbyism. Since 2001, Gallup has been polling Americans on their attention to national political news. In September, they recorded their highest measure yet for a non-election year, with 38% of Americans saying they were following national political news “very closely.”

All of this is likely exacerbated by the decline of local, original reporting and the glut of nationally oriented political content that’s more widely accessible than ever before.

As a result, we’re likely to see a 2022 news audience that overall is smaller than before — as more Americans let the news fade into the ambient background or tune out altogether — but those who remain will be even more animated by national political narratives than in the past.

How journalists ought to navigate this terrain, I leave for wiser folks than myself to offer counsel. But to other survey researchers who study media attitudes: It strikes me that the line between politics and news media is becoming blurred to a point of little distinction in the eyes of some, perhaps many, Americans. When we think we’re asking survey respondents about their consumption of news, they might as well be telling us about their consumption of politics. News outlets that were once viewed skeptically as tools of political parties and movements, today may be more likely seen as official organs of those parties and movements.

It’s a whole new era of convergence, one that a growing segment of the American news audience distrusts — but also can’t resist.

Jesse Holcomb is an assistant professor of journalism and communication at Calvin University.

If you spend as much time as I do with survey data about the news media, it’s hard to escape the conclusion that news audiences — at least here in the U.S. — are on the decline.

To be sure, news consumption tends to come in peaks and troughs around election cycles, and so a languishing news audience in 2022 would fit a predictable pattern. And further, many observers have noted the burnout effect following months of wearying news about Covid-19. (The Knight-Gallup Trust, Media, and Democracy research initiative — for which I am an advisor — saw that audiences were turning away from the news after a 2020 spike in interest.)

But the audience erosion extends beyond episodic boom and bust. The Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism has tracked American usage of major news sources for nearly a decade, and has shown steady — if incremental — declines for not just print and television, but digital, including social news usage as well. (On the latter point, the Pew Research Center has also shown something approaching a cool-down in the last year). Gallup, which has been tracking news consumption for decades, has also shown steady erosion across most sources.

Yet for all the well-documented evidence of news avoidance, we’re also experiencing a moment of acute political hobbyism. Since 2001, Gallup has been polling Americans on their attention to national political news. In September, they recorded their highest measure yet for a non-election year, with 38% of Americans saying they were following national political news “very closely.”

All of this is likely exacerbated by the decline of local, original reporting and the glut of nationally oriented political content that’s more widely accessible than ever before.

As a result, we’re likely to see a 2022 news audience that overall is smaller than before — as more Americans let the news fade into the ambient background or tune out altogether — but those who remain will be even more animated by national political narratives than in the past.

How journalists ought to navigate this terrain, I leave for wiser folks than myself to offer counsel. But to other survey researchers who study media attitudes: It strikes me that the line between politics and news media is becoming blurred to a point of little distinction in the eyes of some, perhaps many, Americans. When we think we’re asking survey respondents about their consumption of news, they might as well be telling us about their consumption of politics. News outlets that were once viewed skeptically as tools of political parties and movements, today may be more likely seen as official organs of those parties and movements.

It’s a whole new era of convergence, one that a growing segment of the American news audience distrusts — but also can’t resist.

Jesse Holcomb is an assistant professor of journalism and communication at Calvin University.

j. Siguru Wahutu

Joni Deutsch

Meena Thiruvengadam

Simon Allison

Julia Angwin

Natalia Viana

Shalabh Upadhyay

Amara Aguilar

Stephen Fowler

Robert Hernandez

David Cohn

Sam Guzik

Sarah Marshall

Jim Friedlich

James Green

Gordon Crovitz

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Kerri Hoffman

Gabe Schneider

Ståle Grut

Chase Davis

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Anthony Nadler

Joanne McNeil

Tamar Charney

Mike Rispoli

Doris Truong

Catalina Albeanu

Julia Munslow

Richard Tofel

Whitney Phillips

Simon Galperin

Christina Shih

Anita Varma

Mary Walter-Brown

Joy Mayer

Candace Amos

Cherian George

Cristina Tardáguila

Larry Ryckman

Millie Tran

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Ariel Zirulnick

Errin Haines

Michael W. Wagner

Matthew Pressman

Zizi Papacharissi

Nikki Usher

Matt Karolian

Paul Cheung

Christoph Mergerson

Francesco Zaffarano

Gonzalo del Peon

Raney Aronson-Rath

Cindy Royal

Burt Herman

Melody Kramer

Megan McCarthy

Jessica Clark

Juleyka Lantigua

Don Day

John Davidow

Chicas Poderosas

Stefanie Murray

Jesse Holcomb

Mandy Jenkins

Izabella Kaminska

Anika Anand

Alice Antheaume

Matt DeRienzo

Brian Moritz

Moreno Cruz Osório

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Joshua P. Darr

Jennifer Brandel

Jennifer Coogan

Tony Baranowski

Rachel Glickhouse

Parker Molloy

Sarah Stonbely

Wilson Liévano

Victor Pickard

Daniel Eilemberg

Mario García

Kristen Muller

David Skok

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

A.J. Bauer

Jonas Kaiser

Andrew Freedman

An Xiao Mina

Joe Amditis

Janelle Salanga

Jody Brannon

Eric Nuzum

Tom Trewinnard

S. Mitra Kalita

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Kristen Jeffers