More news is the problem, not the solution

“Journalism now functions to condense, contextualize, and curate the sheer volume of information that is out there and accessible to all — to stand between readers and the abyss of the infodemic.”

At the beginning of the pandemic, way back in early 2020, World Health Organization director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, said that the world was facing not one but two major crises: the pandemic, yes, but also what he called the “infodemic” — a deluge of information so overwhelming that it becomes impossible for ordinary people to figure out what is or isn’t credible information.

The symptoms of the infodemic are all too obvious: the rise of conspiracy theories like QAnon, the vast numbers of people who refuse to get vaccinated for Covid-19, and the persistent untruths which fuel so much of today’s politics, no matter how often they are dutifully debunked.

As journalists, we’re on the frontlines of the infodemic. But instead of coming up with solutions, too many of us are part of the problem, dumping vast amounts of information on our audiences, across multiple platforms, and expecting them to have the tools — and the time — to process it all.

This is a function, perhaps, of the infinite nature of the internet: There are no limits on how many stories we can publish, or how long those stories should be. It doesn’t help that the algorithms that define our online existence are set up to reward more pages and more clicks.

But this approach fails to recognize that the nature of journalism has fundamentally changed in the 21st century. In an information-scarce environment, such as the pre-internet age, journalism existed to find and distribute news to an audience, because they couldn’t get that news anywhere else.

Today, everyone with access to the internet lives in an information-rich environment, and the primary role of effective journalism is different. Journalism now functions to condense, contextualize, and curate the sheer volume of information that is out there and accessible to all — to stand between readers and the abyss of the infodemic.

Ironically, the news product that does this best is an old-fashioned print newspaper, where stories are carefully ordered and, because space is at a premium, ruthlessly cut to fit. The hard work is done in the newsroom by people whose job it is to process information; all readers have to do is to keep turning the pages.

The news product that does this worst is a news website, where readers are faced on every page with a dizzying array of stories, each of which might link to a dozen other stories on a dozen other websites. It’s simply too much information to take in at once, and the decision fatigue sets in immediately. Many readers switch off, or they go somewhere else that makes it much easier to access information — even if that information is less reliable.

As journalists, we need to think a lot more carefully about how much information we are putting out into the world and how we present it. Are we countering the infodemic or contributing to it? What we do publish needs to be meaningful, high quality, and respectful of our audience’s time. (For example, if the editing is good enough, most stories can run at half the word count without losing meaning or style — including, no doubt, this one.)

Anything else and the infodemic wins.

Simon Allison is co-founder and editor-in-chief of The Continent, Africa’s most widely distributed newspaper.

At the beginning of the pandemic, way back in early 2020, World Health Organization director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, said that the world was facing not one but two major crises: the pandemic, yes, but also what he called the “infodemic” — a deluge of information so overwhelming that it becomes impossible for ordinary people to figure out what is or isn’t credible information.

The symptoms of the infodemic are all too obvious: the rise of conspiracy theories like QAnon, the vast numbers of people who refuse to get vaccinated for Covid-19, and the persistent untruths which fuel so much of today’s politics, no matter how often they are dutifully debunked.

As journalists, we’re on the frontlines of the infodemic. But instead of coming up with solutions, too many of us are part of the problem, dumping vast amounts of information on our audiences, across multiple platforms, and expecting them to have the tools — and the time — to process it all.

This is a function, perhaps, of the infinite nature of the internet: There are no limits on how many stories we can publish, or how long those stories should be. It doesn’t help that the algorithms that define our online existence are set up to reward more pages and more clicks.

But this approach fails to recognize that the nature of journalism has fundamentally changed in the 21st century. In an information-scarce environment, such as the pre-internet age, journalism existed to find and distribute news to an audience, because they couldn’t get that news anywhere else.

Today, everyone with access to the internet lives in an information-rich environment, and the primary role of effective journalism is different. Journalism now functions to condense, contextualize, and curate the sheer volume of information that is out there and accessible to all — to stand between readers and the abyss of the infodemic.

Ironically, the news product that does this best is an old-fashioned print newspaper, where stories are carefully ordered and, because space is at a premium, ruthlessly cut to fit. The hard work is done in the newsroom by people whose job it is to process information; all readers have to do is to keep turning the pages.

The news product that does this worst is a news website, where readers are faced on every page with a dizzying array of stories, each of which might link to a dozen other stories on a dozen other websites. It’s simply too much information to take in at once, and the decision fatigue sets in immediately. Many readers switch off, or they go somewhere else that makes it much easier to access information — even if that information is less reliable.

As journalists, we need to think a lot more carefully about how much information we are putting out into the world and how we present it. Are we countering the infodemic or contributing to it? What we do publish needs to be meaningful, high quality, and respectful of our audience’s time. (For example, if the editing is good enough, most stories can run at half the word count without losing meaning or style — including, no doubt, this one.)

Anything else and the infodemic wins.

Simon Allison is co-founder and editor-in-chief of The Continent, Africa’s most widely distributed newspaper.

Simon Galperin

Joy Mayer

Raney Aronson-Rath

Meena Thiruvengadam

Catalina Albeanu

Simon Allison

Michael W. Wagner

Mary Walter-Brown

Mike Rispoli

Anita Varma

Sarah Stonbely

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Alice Antheaume

Millie Tran

Joshua P. Darr

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Andrew Freedman

Anika Anand

Cherian George

Wilson Liévano

Burt Herman

Tony Baranowski

Anthony Nadler

John Davidow

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Amara Aguilar

Jesenia De Moya Correa

An Xiao Mina

Robert Hernandez

Megan McCarthy

Matt Karolian

Richard Tofel

Jesse Holcomb

Gabe Schneider

Kristen Muller

Joanne McNeil

Cristina Tardáguila

Christoph Mergerson

David Cohn

Rachel Glickhouse

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Zizi Papacharissi

Brian Moritz

Matt DeRienzo

Chase Davis

Daniel Eilemberg

Moreno Cruz Osório

Stephen Fowler

Jody Brannon

Christina Shih

Jim Friedlich

Julia Angwin

Shalabh Upadhyay

James Green

Julia Munslow

Whitney Phillips

Mandy Jenkins

Francesco Zaffarano

David Skok

Jennifer Coogan

Izabella Kaminska

Errin Haines

Eric Nuzum

Mario García

Jonas Kaiser

Nikki Usher

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Kristen Jeffers

Jessica Clark

Sarah Marshall

Doris Truong

Joni Deutsch

Candace Amos

Larry Ryckman

Don Day

Parker Molloy

Jennifer Brandel

Gonzalo del Peon

Juleyka Lantigua

S. Mitra Kalita

Paul Cheung

Kerri Hoffman

Stefanie Murray

Victor Pickard

Melody Kramer

Chicas Poderosas

Matthew Pressman

A.J. Bauer

Natalia Viana

Ståle Grut

Joe Amditis

Gordon Crovitz

Sam Guzik

Cindy Royal

Tamar Charney

Tom Trewinnard

Janelle Salanga

Ariel Zirulnick

j. Siguru Wahutu