There’s a large looming threat to local news — and it’s beyond all the hue and cry about local newspapers. While big publications often conflate the death of local newspapers with the death of local news, the information needs of communities these days are more often served by television journalism, along with newspapers and independent sites like mine, BoiseDev.com.
But the threat that’s being undercovered and underappreciated is the seismic changes to the cable bundle. Over the past several decades, local stations and networks have reaped billions in what’s known as retransmission consent payments. When you pay your cable, satellite, or over-the-top TV provider, much of that cash goes to the owners of the programming you watch. Changes to federal law in 1992 allowed local TV stations to start collecting those fees from the cable companies in exchange for the right to air NBC/CBS/ABC/Fox, etc., along with the local news that often comes along with it.
(If you’re still a linear TV customer and your favorite local channel has gone dark, it’s because the TV station owner and your TV provider are fighting over these payments.)
But with each passing day, fewer people are spending their hard-earned cash on the cable bundle. A decent proxy for the overall health of the bundle is ESPN. The sports powerhouse is carried almost universally across each cable provider. In 2011, the Disney-owned sports outlet announced it was available in 100 million homes. Ten years later, its latest filing with the SEC shows that figure dropped to 76 million. Fortunately, that makes for easy math and shows its total penetration has dropped by 24% in ten years. More troubling, the pace of decline is accelerating, with ESPN losing eight million subscribers in the most recent year.
But this isn’t about ESPN. ESPN has a robust strategy in place to shift users to its ESPN+ streaming service. NBC has Peacock, CBS has Paramount+, ABC has Hulu and Disney+, and so on.
This is about your local news providers. The ones without a real plan to shift to streaming down the road. The ones that still make the bulk of their revenue from linear TV. The ones that provide a significant amount of the local news output (and consumption) in any given market.
The national content providers are very aware of the troubling trends for their traditional business — that the cable bundle is falling apart. Most if not all are trying to figure out how to go from a world where they get a check from the cable company for every person who gets cable, regardless of whether they watch their content, to a world in which they have to convince customers one by one to fork over a credit card number for a monthly or yearly payment.
But at the local level, very few have decided to dive into the direct-to-consumer business. There are some experiments here and there, but no large TV group has gone all-in on trying to shift the business model. They’re stuck in the innovator’s dilemma of not wanting to upset the current apple cart — because for now, that apple cart remains a pretty tasty one. Traditional TV remains a top medium for political ads, and the shower of cash that falls on local stations at least every other year has proved to be a good business (the AP called it record-shattering in 2020).
But today’s tasty apples are tomorrow’s rotted mush. The newspaper industry has seen its fortunes sink over the last few decades, as “vulture capital” firms like Alden Global Capital rise. The short gist of a long story: Alden buys up lots of papers, cuts as much as possible on the expense side, and tries to manage the decline on the revenue side.
Is local TV next for that strategy?
My former employer, Tegna, has been in play for the last 18 months, with one potential buyer the paired-up hedge funds Standard General and Apollo Global Management. At stake is ownership of local TV stations in 54 markets. Neither hedge fund is known for its investment in the companies it buys.
For now, local TV news is still a cash-flowing investment. The hundreds of stations across this country contribute strong journalism and solid public service, and they make a material difference in the communities they serve. But nothing is forever, and without some unexpected and surprising changes, I have significant concerns about yet another pillar of local news in the United States.
Don Day is the founder and editor of BoiseDev.com.
There’s a large looming threat to local news — and it’s beyond all the hue and cry about local newspapers. While big publications often conflate the death of local newspapers with the death of local news, the information needs of communities these days are more often served by television journalism, along with newspapers and independent sites like mine, BoiseDev.com.
But the threat that’s being undercovered and underappreciated is the seismic changes to the cable bundle. Over the past several decades, local stations and networks have reaped billions in what’s known as retransmission consent payments. When you pay your cable, satellite, or over-the-top TV provider, much of that cash goes to the owners of the programming you watch. Changes to federal law in 1992 allowed local TV stations to start collecting those fees from the cable companies in exchange for the right to air NBC/CBS/ABC/Fox, etc., along with the local news that often comes along with it.
(If you’re still a linear TV customer and your favorite local channel has gone dark, it’s because the TV station owner and your TV provider are fighting over these payments.)
But with each passing day, fewer people are spending their hard-earned cash on the cable bundle. A decent proxy for the overall health of the bundle is ESPN. The sports powerhouse is carried almost universally across each cable provider. In 2011, the Disney-owned sports outlet announced it was available in 100 million homes. Ten years later, its latest filing with the SEC shows that figure dropped to 76 million. Fortunately, that makes for easy math and shows its total penetration has dropped by 24% in ten years. More troubling, the pace of decline is accelerating, with ESPN losing eight million subscribers in the most recent year.
But this isn’t about ESPN. ESPN has a robust strategy in place to shift users to its ESPN+ streaming service. NBC has Peacock, CBS has Paramount+, ABC has Hulu and Disney+, and so on.
This is about your local news providers. The ones without a real plan to shift to streaming down the road. The ones that still make the bulk of their revenue from linear TV. The ones that provide a significant amount of the local news output (and consumption) in any given market.
The national content providers are very aware of the troubling trends for their traditional business — that the cable bundle is falling apart. Most if not all are trying to figure out how to go from a world where they get a check from the cable company for every person who gets cable, regardless of whether they watch their content, to a world in which they have to convince customers one by one to fork over a credit card number for a monthly or yearly payment.
But at the local level, very few have decided to dive into the direct-to-consumer business. There are some experiments here and there, but no large TV group has gone all-in on trying to shift the business model. They’re stuck in the innovator’s dilemma of not wanting to upset the current apple cart — because for now, that apple cart remains a pretty tasty one. Traditional TV remains a top medium for political ads, and the shower of cash that falls on local stations at least every other year has proved to be a good business (the AP called it record-shattering in 2020).
But today’s tasty apples are tomorrow’s rotted mush. The newspaper industry has seen its fortunes sink over the last few decades, as “vulture capital” firms like Alden Global Capital rise. The short gist of a long story: Alden buys up lots of papers, cuts as much as possible on the expense side, and tries to manage the decline on the revenue side.
Is local TV next for that strategy?
My former employer, Tegna, has been in play for the last 18 months, with one potential buyer the paired-up hedge funds Standard General and Apollo Global Management. At stake is ownership of local TV stations in 54 markets. Neither hedge fund is known for its investment in the companies it buys.
For now, local TV news is still a cash-flowing investment. The hundreds of stations across this country contribute strong journalism and solid public service, and they make a material difference in the communities they serve. But nothing is forever, and without some unexpected and surprising changes, I have significant concerns about yet another pillar of local news in the United States.
Don Day is the founder and editor of BoiseDev.com.
j. Siguru Wahutu
Rachel Glickhouse
Chase Davis
Gabe Schneider
Janelle Salanga
Sarah Stonbely
Andrew Freedman
Kerri Hoffman
Cristina Tardáguila
Mike Rispoli
Candace Amos
Robert Hernandez
Izabella Kaminska
Whitney Phillips
Don Day
Jesse Holcomb
Rasmus Kleis Nielsen
Stefanie Murray
Julia Angwin
AX Mina
Kristen Muller
Christoph Mergerson
Shalabh Upadhyay
Amy Schmitz Weiss
Raney Aronson-Rath
Moreno Cruz Osório
Chicas Poderosas
Natalia Viana
Paul Cheung
Juleyka Lantigua
Joe Amditis
Ariel Zirulnick
Jennifer Brandel
Melody Kramer
Tom Trewinnard
David Cohn
Ståle Grut
Victor Pickard
Tony Baranowski
Errin Haines
Anika Anand
James Green
Joanne McNeil
David Skok
Jennifer Coogan
Matt Karolian
Zizi Papacharissi
Cherian George
Larry Ryckman
Parker Molloy
Simon Galperin
Megan McCarthy
Joshua P. Darr
John Davidow
Eric Nuzum
Francesco Zaffarano
Millie Tran
Nikki Usher
Kristen Jeffers
Richard Tofel
Wilson Liévano
Meena Thiruvengadam
Anita Varma
Kathleen Searles Rebekah Trumble
Daniel Eilemberg
Mandy Jenkins
Alice Antheaume
Sarah Marshall
Jessica Clark
Joni Deutsch
Matt DeRienzo
Jonas Kaiser
Jim Friedlich
Amara Aguilar
Michael W. Wagner
S. Mitra Kalita
Laxmi Parthasarathy
Joy Mayer
Kendra Pierre-Louis
Jody Brannon
Simon Allison
Christina Shih
Julia Munslow
Gordon Crovitz
Catalina Albeanu
Tamar Charney
A.J. Bauer
Sam Guzik
Stephen Fowler
Jesenia De Moya Correa
Mario García
Cindy Royal
Mary Walter-Brown
Doris Truong
Burt Herman
Matthew Pressman
Gonzalo del Peon
Anthony Nadler
Brian Moritz
Shannon McGregor Carolyn Schmitt