From extractive to regenerative

“Regenerative industries and processes focus on developing self-renewing systems that take both natural and human resources into account. They recognize that both are finite.”

En route to yet another meeting on journalism business models in November, I encountered this scene: Reporters and staff standing side-by-side, picketing The New York Times.

It was a stark reminder that, amidst a larger “Great Resignation,” the news industry continues to hemorrhage talent. This isn’t just a happy tale of people quitting their jobs to pursue their side hustle, take control of their time, or launch that sizzling Substack. It’s a story of, well, great resignation. Many reporters who leave have become numb to the fact that their outlets don’t care about them, their audiences don’t trust them, and their prospects are increasingly precarious.

These dynamics reflect a larger critique of the industry as extractive. It starts at the investor level, with hedge funds like Alden Global Capital strip-mining historic newspapers for their assets. It trickles down to managers who need to squeeze more hours out of shrinking staff and freelancers, who have faced new demands and dangers during the pandemic. In turn, it alienates sources and communities, who feel that even when they do interact with reporters, their stories are being told poorly or not at all.

How can news leaders and outlets staunch the wound? One way is to take a page from environmentally minded designers who are focusing on taking a “regenerative” approach. Regenerative industries and processes focus on developing self-renewing systems that take both natural and human resources into account. They recognize that both are finite, and that healthy ecosystems are based on interdependence. They move beyond the frame of “sustainability” into a mode of “circular design,” which posits that nurturing the wellbeing of both employees and communities can in turn strengthen businesses and products.

At the Guild of Future Architects (GoFA), we have been exploring these concepts through our New/s initiative — a three-year project funded by the Ford Foundation to support diverse journalism innovators.

This fall, we launched our pilot New/s Incubator to support two project teams led by Tayyib Smith and Erin Washington. They were selected from a set of proposals submitted by GoFA members — who number more than 200 to date and come from a variety of disciplines and lived experiences. With program manager Evan Blaine Walsh and advisor Christie George, we’re designing it as a space for peer learning, with other members stepping up to lead and contribute to various programs.

Here are some possible futures this incubator is exploring that reveal how the industry can move into a more regenerative mode. While these might sound idealistic, they represent trends already in motion:

We are also learning that it’s all too easy to blame those in power and give away agency in the process. To move forward, journalists will start to:

We know that shifting to a regenerative mindset will take time and imagination. But we also know that we’re not alone. In October, in tandem with GoFA member Robert Sinclair, we hosted a Futurist Writers’ Room at the Double Exposure conference with two colleagues who have also been using forward-looking approaches to reimagine nonfiction media: Alicia Bell currently directs the Racial Equity in Journalism Fund at Borealis Philanthropy and was a founder of the Media 2070 initiative, and Karim Ahmed is the director of outreach and inclusion at the Sundance Institute and a GoFA member who co-authored the recent report “Restoring the Future.”

We hope to host more of these discussions in 2022. But we also expect to see many others picking up the torch to explore regenerative models. After all, the future of news — and the people who report on it — depends on it.

Jessica Clark is founder and executive director of Dot Connector Studio.

En route to yet another meeting on journalism business models in November, I encountered this scene: Reporters and staff standing side-by-side, picketing The New York Times.

It was a stark reminder that, amidst a larger “Great Resignation,” the news industry continues to hemorrhage talent. This isn’t just a happy tale of people quitting their jobs to pursue their side hustle, take control of their time, or launch that sizzling Substack. It’s a story of, well, great resignation. Many reporters who leave have become numb to the fact that their outlets don’t care about them, their audiences don’t trust them, and their prospects are increasingly precarious.

These dynamics reflect a larger critique of the industry as extractive. It starts at the investor level, with hedge funds like Alden Global Capital strip-mining historic newspapers for their assets. It trickles down to managers who need to squeeze more hours out of shrinking staff and freelancers, who have faced new demands and dangers during the pandemic. In turn, it alienates sources and communities, who feel that even when they do interact with reporters, their stories are being told poorly or not at all.

How can news leaders and outlets staunch the wound? One way is to take a page from environmentally minded designers who are focusing on taking a “regenerative” approach. Regenerative industries and processes focus on developing self-renewing systems that take both natural and human resources into account. They recognize that both are finite, and that healthy ecosystems are based on interdependence. They move beyond the frame of “sustainability” into a mode of “circular design,” which posits that nurturing the wellbeing of both employees and communities can in turn strengthen businesses and products.

At the Guild of Future Architects (GoFA), we have been exploring these concepts through our New/s initiative — a three-year project funded by the Ford Foundation to support diverse journalism innovators.

This fall, we launched our pilot New/s Incubator to support two project teams led by Tayyib Smith and Erin Washington. They were selected from a set of proposals submitted by GoFA members — who number more than 200 to date and come from a variety of disciplines and lived experiences. With program manager Evan Blaine Walsh and advisor Christie George, we’re designing it as a space for peer learning, with other members stepping up to lead and contribute to various programs.

Here are some possible futures this incubator is exploring that reveal how the industry can move into a more regenerative mode. While these might sound idealistic, they represent trends already in motion:

We are also learning that it’s all too easy to blame those in power and give away agency in the process. To move forward, journalists will start to:

We know that shifting to a regenerative mindset will take time and imagination. But we also know that we’re not alone. In October, in tandem with GoFA member Robert Sinclair, we hosted a Futurist Writers’ Room at the Double Exposure conference with two colleagues who have also been using forward-looking approaches to reimagine nonfiction media: Alicia Bell currently directs the Racial Equity in Journalism Fund at Borealis Philanthropy and was a founder of the Media 2070 initiative, and Karim Ahmed is the director of outreach and inclusion at the Sundance Institute and a GoFA member who co-authored the recent report “Restoring the Future.”

We hope to host more of these discussions in 2022. But we also expect to see many others picking up the torch to explore regenerative models. After all, the future of news — and the people who report on it — depends on it.

Jessica Clark is founder and executive director of Dot Connector Studio.

Wilson Liévano

Julia Angwin

Tamar Charney

Francesco Zaffarano

Parker Molloy

A.J. Bauer

Joshua P. Darr

Zizi Papacharissi

Jennifer Brandel

Moreno Cruz Osório

Jesse Holcomb

An Xiao Mina

Sarah Marshall

Ariel Zirulnick

Victor Pickard

Chase Davis

Amara Aguilar

Don Day

Sam Guzik

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Joe Amditis

Andrew Freedman

Tom Trewinnard

Cherian George

Jennifer Coogan

Michael W. Wagner

Millie Tran

Megan McCarthy

Jessica Clark

Melody Kramer

Doris Truong

Matthew Pressman

Mario García

Catalina Albeanu

Raney Aronson-Rath

Richard Tofel

Gonzalo del Peon

Errin Haines

Kristen Muller

Shalabh Upadhyay

Christina Shih

Tony Baranowski

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Brian Moritz

Anika Anand

Janelle Salanga

Candace Amos

Paul Cheung

Larry Ryckman

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Simon Allison

Matt Karolian

Chicas Poderosas

Cristina Tardáguila

Matt DeRienzo

Mandy Jenkins

Simon Galperin

Nikki Usher

Julia Munslow

Stefanie Murray

Izabella Kaminska

Mary Walter-Brown

Anita Varma

Christoph Mergerson

Mike Rispoli

Stephen Fowler

Meena Thiruvengadam

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Natalia Viana

Cindy Royal

Rachel Glickhouse

Kristen Jeffers

Jonas Kaiser

j. Siguru Wahutu

Kerri Hoffman

Joanne McNeil

Gabe Schneider

Alice Antheaume

Juleyka Lantigua

Daniel Eilemberg

Sarah Stonbely

Robert Hernandez

Joni Deutsch

David Cohn

John Davidow

Ståle Grut

James Green

David Skok

Whitney Phillips

S. Mitra Kalita

Anthony Nadler

Jody Brannon

Eric Nuzum

Joy Mayer

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Burt Herman

Gordon Crovitz

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Jim Friedlich