Newsrooms, social scientists, public health professionals, and librarians unite

“We’ll see more attacks on public institutions — libraries, universities, school boards, news organizations. They’ll be hard to parse and hard to think about as connected.”

Working outside of newsrooms for the past three years — alongside social scientists, public health professionals, and library professionals — has been instrumental in the ways I think about the future of news. There are many ways that these groups can work together to help little-d democracy in 2022, and I hope they do. Here are some thoughts based on my time with demographers, population researchers, information scientists, and digital archivists:

  • We’ll see more new local for-profit and nonprofit news organizations launch in existing news deserts — and some of them will have close ties to PACs and/or political groups. (We’ve already seen this take place in Stockton and Chapel Hill and in 12 other states, as reported by Yowei Shaw, Tammy Grubb, and Priyanjana Bengani, respectively.) In many cases, these newsrooms will appear in places with few, if any, local media watchdogs — and where thousands of new residents move in without any existing media habits. This will be interesting to watch in light of the Local Journalism Sustainability Act.
  • We’ll see more newsrooms and audio organizations partner with digital archivists and librarians to save content that may be relevant in the future, and to understand how to incorporate web and media archiving into existing workflows. Preserve This Podcast’s work in this area is aimed at independent podcasters; my own MLIS project Saving Political Sites archived 25,000 local candidate websites from the 2021 election cycle, some of which have already disappeared from the web over the past month. There are also sorts of ways to do this in a smart way and at scale — and the best work in this area will take place entirely at the local level. (You know the “Friends Of” groups that spring up in your area in an election cycle — others don’t.)
  • We’ll see more experimentation with paywalls, whether that means looking at the aggregate behavior of readers, or the location of readers, or whether someone is moving or standing still. We’ll see bundles happen more frequently — and we’ll also see paywalls figure more prominently into mutual aid networks.
  • More newsrooms and academic research centers will partner, and it will benefit both groups. We’ve seen this go well in Wisconsin in a partnership between WisContext and the University of Wisconsin Applied Population Lab, and in Toronto between a reporter at The Toronto Star and a researcher at the University of Sheffield. Dear Pandemic, from researchers at a variety of schools, could easily be syndicated or repackaged by newsrooms for a local context.
  • We’ll start to see mastheads spread out across the country. This will be good, especially if we’re hiring people who live there and not people who already work at a news organization and have moved to a new place.
  • Medium will pivot.
  • Revenue-splitting will become the norm with columnists. Could we see something similar for editors and product managers?
  • Deborah Dwyer’s research on unpublishing the news will become even more relevant as more mergers take place (and hedge funds try to delete previous stories written about them).
  • Newsroom workers in the 28 “right-to-work” states (like North Carolina) will try to unionize, and the outcomes across these states may be very different.
  • We’ll see more news organizations post metadata to help prove provenance of images, audio, and video. The News Provenance Project at The New York Times and the Starling Lab at Stanford University will help fight misinformation through reducing uncertainty.
  • We’ll see more attacks on independent student media, particularly at public institutions in red states. Louisiana State University’s journalism students now work for a bureau in the school’s communications office; its student newspaper stopped publishing in 2019. A 2016 report by the AAUP outlines a series of threats that college media organizations face
  • We’ll see more attacks on public institutions — libraries, universities, school boards, news organizations. They’ll be hard to parse and hard to think about as connected. Will there be a Dear Pandemic that launches that focuses on the breakdown of democracy? How can social scientists and journalists partner together? (See No. 4.)

Melody Kramer is finishing an MLIS degree and leading communications for a population research center at the University of North Carolina.

Working outside of newsrooms for the past three years — alongside social scientists, public health professionals, and library professionals — has been instrumental in the ways I think about the future of news. There are many ways that these groups can work together to help little-d democracy in 2022, and I hope they do. Here are some thoughts based on my time with demographers, population researchers, information scientists, and digital archivists:

  • We’ll see more new local for-profit and nonprofit news organizations launch in existing news deserts — and some of them will have close ties to PACs and/or political groups. (We’ve already seen this take place in Stockton and Chapel Hill and in 12 other states, as reported by Yowei Shaw, Tammy Grubb, and Priyanjana Bengani, respectively.) In many cases, these newsrooms will appear in places with few, if any, local media watchdogs — and where thousands of new residents move in without any existing media habits. This will be interesting to watch in light of the Local Journalism Sustainability Act.
  • We’ll see more newsrooms and audio organizations partner with digital archivists and librarians to save content that may be relevant in the future, and to understand how to incorporate web and media archiving into existing workflows. Preserve This Podcast’s work in this area is aimed at independent podcasters; my own MLIS project Saving Political Sites archived 25,000 local candidate websites from the 2021 election cycle, some of which have already disappeared from the web over the past month. There are also sorts of ways to do this in a smart way and at scale — and the best work in this area will take place entirely at the local level. (You know the “Friends Of” groups that spring up in your area in an election cycle — others don’t.)
  • We’ll see more experimentation with paywalls, whether that means looking at the aggregate behavior of readers, or the location of readers, or whether someone is moving or standing still. We’ll see bundles happen more frequently — and we’ll also see paywalls figure more prominently into mutual aid networks.
  • More newsrooms and academic research centers will partner, and it will benefit both groups. We’ve seen this go well in Wisconsin in a partnership between WisContext and the University of Wisconsin Applied Population Lab, and in Toronto between a reporter at The Toronto Star and a researcher at the University of Sheffield. Dear Pandemic, from researchers at a variety of schools, could easily be syndicated or repackaged by newsrooms for a local context.
  • We’ll start to see mastheads spread out across the country. This will be good, especially if we’re hiring people who live there and not people who already work at a news organization and have moved to a new place.
  • Medium will pivot.
  • Revenue-splitting will become the norm with columnists. Could we see something similar for editors and product managers?
  • Deborah Dwyer’s research on unpublishing the news will become even more relevant as more mergers take place (and hedge funds try to delete previous stories written about them).
  • Newsroom workers in the 28 “right-to-work” states (like North Carolina) will try to unionize, and the outcomes across these states may be very different.
  • We’ll see more news organizations post metadata to help prove provenance of images, audio, and video. The News Provenance Project at The New York Times and the Starling Lab at Stanford University will help fight misinformation through reducing uncertainty.
  • We’ll see more attacks on independent student media, particularly at public institutions in red states. Louisiana State University’s journalism students now work for a bureau in the school’s communications office; its student newspaper stopped publishing in 2019. A 2016 report by the AAUP outlines a series of threats that college media organizations face
  • We’ll see more attacks on public institutions — libraries, universities, school boards, news organizations. They’ll be hard to parse and hard to think about as connected. Will there be a Dear Pandemic that launches that focuses on the breakdown of democracy? How can social scientists and journalists partner together? (See No. 4.)

Melody Kramer is finishing an MLIS degree and leading communications for a population research center at the University of North Carolina.

Jim Friedlich

Mandy Jenkins

David Skok

Catalina Albeanu

Nikki Usher

Michael W. Wagner

Joy Mayer

Simon Galperin

Rachel Glickhouse

Wilson Liévano

Juleyka Lantigua

Alice Antheaume

Jennifer Brandel

Christina Shih

Cherian George

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Melody Kramer

Jonas Kaiser

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Errin Haines

Ståle Grut

S. Mitra Kalita

David Cohn

Victor Pickard

Mario García

Whitney Phillips

Richard Tofel

Julia Munslow

Anika Anand

Joanne McNeil

Don Day

Burt Herman

A.J. Bauer

Matthew Pressman

Meena Thiruvengadam

Parker Molloy

Sarah Marshall

Kerri Hoffman

Stephen Fowler

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Izabella Kaminska

Andrew Freedman

Eric Nuzum

Paul Cheung

Moreno Cruz Osório

An Xiao Mina

Raney Aronson-Rath

Ariel Zirulnick

Millie Tran

Simon Allison

Francesco Zaffarano

Joni Deutsch

Joshua P. Darr

Chicas Poderosas

Candace Amos

John Davidow

Tony Baranowski

Jesse Holcomb

Doris Truong

Shalabh Upadhyay

Matt DeRienzo

Sam Guzik

Larry Ryckman

Kristen Jeffers

Tom Trewinnard

Mary Walter-Brown

Gabe Schneider

Jessica Clark

Cindy Royal

Megan McCarthy

Christoph Mergerson

Matt Karolian

Anthony Nadler

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Chase Davis

Kristen Muller

Zizi Papacharissi

Mike Rispoli

Gordon Crovitz

Jody Brannon

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Daniel Eilemberg

Cristina Tardáguila

Sarah Stonbely

j. Siguru Wahutu

Janelle Salanga

Amara Aguilar

James Green

Jennifer Coogan

Tamar Charney

Gonzalo del Peon

Stefanie Murray

Anita Varma

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Brian Moritz

Natalia Viana

Robert Hernandez

Joe Amditis

Julia Angwin