Digital subscriber growth will slow, but that won’t be all bad

“Slowing growth will renew our imperative to focus on the needs of our readers and the quality of our products — simply because it leaves us with no other choice.”

2021 has been a stressful year for news organizations counting on paid digital subscriptions for sustainability.

In the early years of digital subscription programs, growth came more easily as loyal, long-time readers converted in large numbers. That was followed by the “Trump bump,” then a global pandemic that led readers to us in droves.

And then things stalled. From Netflix and The New York Times to many local newsrooms, digital subscription growth has slowed in 2021. Blame news fatigue, subscription fatigue, market saturation, macroeconomic concerns, or whatever you’d like — the last year brought the sobering reminder that for even the most successful digital subscription businesses, converting new subscribers only gets harder as time goes on.

One way or another, 2022 is going to teach us much about the durability of our digital subscription strategies. By the end of the year, we’ll know whether 2021 was a blip or our new reality. We’ll better understand what each of our individual markets will bear. There will be adjusting of forecasts, revising of expectations, and wringing of hands.

All that might not be good for our short-term bottom lines, but it could be good for our long-term sustainability.

Slowing growth will renew our imperative to focus on the needs of our readers and the quality of our products — simply because it leaves us with no other choice. Strategies that were backburnered as we scrambled through the growth years will take on new life as we fight to win new subscribers on the margins.

Readers who choose to pay for us will be more intentional and less transactional, driven by a deeper appreciation for our journalism and digital products. The pace with which we continue to grow new subscriptions will be more up to us and less up to events beyond our control.

It’ll be scary, maybe, but also hopeful. No pressure, no diamonds.

Chase Davis is deputy managing editor for digital strategy and technology at the Star Tribune in Minneapolis.

2021 has been a stressful year for news organizations counting on paid digital subscriptions for sustainability.

In the early years of digital subscription programs, growth came more easily as loyal, long-time readers converted in large numbers. That was followed by the “Trump bump,” then a global pandemic that led readers to us in droves.

And then things stalled. From Netflix and The New York Times to many local newsrooms, digital subscription growth has slowed in 2021. Blame news fatigue, subscription fatigue, market saturation, macroeconomic concerns, or whatever you’d like — the last year brought the sobering reminder that for even the most successful digital subscription businesses, converting new subscribers only gets harder as time goes on.

One way or another, 2022 is going to teach us much about the durability of our digital subscription strategies. By the end of the year, we’ll know whether 2021 was a blip or our new reality. We’ll better understand what each of our individual markets will bear. There will be adjusting of forecasts, revising of expectations, and wringing of hands.

All that might not be good for our short-term bottom lines, but it could be good for our long-term sustainability.

Slowing growth will renew our imperative to focus on the needs of our readers and the quality of our products — simply because it leaves us with no other choice. Strategies that were backburnered as we scrambled through the growth years will take on new life as we fight to win new subscribers on the margins.

Readers who choose to pay for us will be more intentional and less transactional, driven by a deeper appreciation for our journalism and digital products. The pace with which we continue to grow new subscriptions will be more up to us and less up to events beyond our control.

It’ll be scary, maybe, but also hopeful. No pressure, no diamonds.

Chase Davis is deputy managing editor for digital strategy and technology at the Star Tribune in Minneapolis.

Gordon Crovitz

Megan McCarthy

Kristen Jeffers

Sarah Stonbely

Mary Walter-Brown

Francesco Zaffarano

Joshua P. Darr

Julia Angwin

Sarah Marshall

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Cristina Tardáguila

Izabella Kaminska

Meena Thiruvengadam

Chase Davis

Juleyka Lantigua

Joe Amditis

David Cohn

Joni Deutsch

Jody Brannon

An Xiao Mina

Catalina Albeanu

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Gabe Schneider

Matthew Pressman

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Zizi Papacharissi

Jonas Kaiser

Tony Baranowski

Jennifer Coogan

Millie Tran

Daniel Eilemberg

Alice Antheaume

Larry Ryckman

Amara Aguilar

Andrew Freedman

Paul Cheung

Parker Molloy

j. Siguru Wahutu

David Skok

John Davidow

Kristen Muller

Stefanie Murray

Jennifer Brandel

Eric Nuzum

Don Day

Jim Friedlich

Stephen Fowler

Simon Allison

Whitney Phillips

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Janelle Salanga

Anthony Nadler

Robert Hernandez

Matt Karolian

Wilson Liévano

Matt DeRienzo

Mario García

Burt Herman

Natalia Viana

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Jessica Clark

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Mandy Jenkins

Julia Munslow

Victor Pickard

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Moreno Cruz Osório

S. Mitra Kalita

James Green

Ståle Grut

Mike Rispoli

Richard Tofel

Kerri Hoffman

Candace Amos

Jesse Holcomb

Joy Mayer

Cherian George

Brian Moritz

Errin Haines

Chicas Poderosas

Simon Galperin

Tom Trewinnard

Christoph Mergerson

Michael W. Wagner

Tamar Charney

Cindy Royal

Raney Aronson-Rath

Sam Guzik

Joanne McNeil

Ariel Zirulnick

Anita Varma

Christina Shih

Rachel Glickhouse

A.J. Bauer

Nikki Usher

Anika Anand

Gonzalo del Peon

Shalabh Upadhyay

Melody Kramer

Doris Truong