Aid to publishers will be politicized

“Populist alt-right and activist left-wing publications will use the tax credit as a cudgel to hammer reporters and editors for being in the pocket of the Biden administration.”

Normally when I write these annual predictions, I stick my index finger in the air to guess which way the wind is blowing. But this year, I can actually see the future — because I’m already living it.

Some context: Following in the footsteps of its Canadian brethren, the U.S. government may soon issue a labor tax credit for journalists as part of the Build Back Better bill that passed the House in November.

According to The New York Times’ Marc Tracy:

If the $2.2 trillion social safety net and climate package makes it through the Senate, it will provide $1.67 billion over the next five years for newspapers, websites, radio and TV stations, and other outlets that primarily cover local news.

You can argue about the importance of this program to publishers seeking a lifeline. But what can’t be argued is that any government aid to publishers will be politicized. This risks further eroding trust in traditional media and needs to be considered before any legislation is passed.

Republican opponents of the bill will chew on the “journalism bailout” as red meat for a base that already distrusts traditional media.

Populist alt-right and activist left-wing publications will use the tax credit as a cudgel to hammer reporters and editors for being in the pocket of the Biden administration. And conveniently, it’ll be a great fundraising opportunity for their own “independent” news outlets.

Companies on the receiving end of the subsidies will howl into the wind, “Journalistic independence!” Only to be drowned out anytime the #Bidenbloviators, #Bidensbeat, and #Bidensbroadcasters hashtags trend when a story is viewed unfavorably by the competing base.

My own views on this form of government assistance for journalism aren’t relevant in this prediction, although you can read what I wrote at the time about the Canadian government’s approach here and here. But know that this is all already happening north of the border.

David Skok is the CEO and editor-in-chief of The Logic.

Normally when I write these annual predictions, I stick my index finger in the air to guess which way the wind is blowing. But this year, I can actually see the future — because I’m already living it.

Some context: Following in the footsteps of its Canadian brethren, the U.S. government may soon issue a labor tax credit for journalists as part of the Build Back Better bill that passed the House in November.

According to The New York Times’ Marc Tracy:

If the $2.2 trillion social safety net and climate package makes it through the Senate, it will provide $1.67 billion over the next five years for newspapers, websites, radio and TV stations, and other outlets that primarily cover local news.

You can argue about the importance of this program to publishers seeking a lifeline. But what can’t be argued is that any government aid to publishers will be politicized. This risks further eroding trust in traditional media and needs to be considered before any legislation is passed.

Republican opponents of the bill will chew on the “journalism bailout” as red meat for a base that already distrusts traditional media.

Populist alt-right and activist left-wing publications will use the tax credit as a cudgel to hammer reporters and editors for being in the pocket of the Biden administration. And conveniently, it’ll be a great fundraising opportunity for their own “independent” news outlets.

Companies on the receiving end of the subsidies will howl into the wind, “Journalistic independence!” Only to be drowned out anytime the #Bidenbloviators, #Bidensbeat, and #Bidensbroadcasters hashtags trend when a story is viewed unfavorably by the competing base.

My own views on this form of government assistance for journalism aren’t relevant in this prediction, although you can read what I wrote at the time about the Canadian government’s approach here and here. But know that this is all already happening north of the border.

David Skok is the CEO and editor-in-chief of The Logic.

Julia Angwin

Sam Guzik

Mario García

S. Mitra Kalita

Anita Varma

Ariel Zirulnick

Whitney Phillips

Jesse Holcomb

Jody Brannon

Kristen Muller

Zizi Papacharissi

Mary Walter-Brown

Raney Aronson-Rath

Rachel Glickhouse

James Salanga

Cristina Tardáguila

Errin Haines

Stefanie Murray

Kerri Hoffman

Francesco Zaffarano

Jessica Clark

John Davidow

James Green

Sarah Stonbely

Jennifer Brandel

Matt Karolian

Simon Allison

Kristen Jeffers

Burt Herman

Chase Davis

Shannon McGregor & Carolyn Schmitt

Joshua P. Darr

Tamar Charney

Doris Truong

Simon Galperin

Melody Kramer

Jonas Kaiser

Christoph Mergerson

Gabe Schneider

Tom Trewinnard

Meena Thiruvengadam

Catalina Albeanu

Sarah Marshall

Megan McCarthy

Shalabh Upadhyay

Andrew Freedman

Gonzalo del Peon

Ståle Grut

Joy Mayer

Jennifer Coogan

A.J. Bauer

David Skok

j. Siguru Wahutu

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen

Don Day

Kendra Pierre-Louis

Joe Amditis

Tony Baranowski

Gordon Crovitz

Julia Munslow

Millie Tran

Joni Deutsch

Robert Hernandez

Mike Rispoli

Richard Tofel

Jim Friedlich

Natalia Viana

Anthony Nadler

Stephen Fowler

Jesenia De Moya Correa

Michael W. Wagner

Christina Shih

Cindy Royal

Paul Cheung

Nik Usher

Amara Aguilar

Chicas Poderosas

Matt DeRienzo

Kathleen Searles & Rebekah Trumble

Moreno Cruz Osório

Brian Moritz

Anika Anand

Laxmi Parthasarathy

Amy Schmitz Weiss

Matthew Pressman

Daniel Eilemberg

Candace Amos

Larry Ryckman

Juleyka Lantigua

Eric Nuzum

Alice Antheaume

Joanne McNeil

Izabella Kaminska

David Cohn

Parker Molloy

Cherian George

Victor Pickard

Mandy Jenkins

Wilson Liévano

AX Mina