Forgive me if this sounds like a case of the hammer seeing everything come up nails, but as someone who covers the creator economy by day, I’ve noticed that the difference between influencers, creators, and journalists seems to shrink every time I look.
Reporting on not just Substack, but Patreon, Cameo, Twitch, and OnlyFans, I find myself struck more by the similarities than the distinctions between the entertainers, artists, digital professionals, influencers, and journalists who populate these platforms. Though we like to consider ourselves distinct by dent of our craft’s supposedly elevated calling, journalists are really just creators by a different name.
We all create content designed for consumption on the internet; we all cultivate a niche and then work to make ourselves indispensable to it; and we all make use of tools and platforms that turn our skill sets into revenue. Indeed, what Patreon has done for podcasters, OnlyFans for sex workers, Twitch for gamers, and Cameo for celebrities, Substack has done for writers.
And while the content might look different, the process is very much the same: Produce something valuable and charge people for access.
More than ever, it’s paywalls that do this charging, and their importance to this trend cannot be overstated. In the wake of a decimated digital advertising industry, and in the face of FAANG’s unassailable scale, creators have embraced a new(ish) method of monetization, the digital subscription. Thanks to this technology, “1,000 true fans” has been transformed from a koan into a business model. You no longer need a million views to turn a profit, just a couple dozen supporters.
This shift has revolutionized solo entrepreneurship, because subscriptions unleash the individual creator. So long as their expertise lies in some breed of digitally distributable content, these second-generation influencers can use the financial model to turn their side-hustle into a day job more easily than ever. This is as true for journalism as it is for any other field.
Substack and the other horsemen of the newsletter apocalypse have made this reality all too apparent, and in doing so have upended much of the media world. The siren song of Chris, Hamish, and Jairaj has been so irresistible that top writers have left pedigreed publications in droves to strike out alone on the platform.
The allure of bootstrapping a career in writing has even encouraged other, less naturally endowed newsletter-whisperers to give the creator economy a shot. Most of these amateur authors (yours truly included) have found only modest success on the platform, but a lucky few have managed to strike gold organically, cultivating a following through nothing more than sheer talent and an origin story that would bring a tear to Horatio Alger’s eyes.
This is bad and good for all the reasons you might imagine. It’s bad because many of the journalists finding success as creators are the same kinds of people who were finding success before: mostly white, mostly male, mostly affluent or well-connected. It’s good because the standard methods of gatekeeping no longer apply; as long as anyone can make a profit all by themselves, everyone can make a profit all by themselves.
So, given that this seems to be the emerging reality, we need to begin to prepare accordingly. What will journalism look like when its most influential practitioners prefer to go it alone? Who loses when publications are forced to vie with lone writers for eyeballs? What happens when the media unbundles so thoroughly that everyone competes with everyone for everyone’s attention?
It’s time to start asking these questions, because the foundation of the next decade of problems is being laid right now. The media can keep chasing its tail, going about the same routines and expecting different results, but perhaps it’s time to have a larger conversation about the system at a distance.
A for-profit model means everything comes at a price, including knowledge. As the people most engaged in parsing and parceling that knowledge, maybe it’s time journalists play a larger role in making sure this arrangement really works for everyone.
Mark Stenberg is a reporter for Business Insider and author of Medialyte.
Forgive me if this sounds like a case of the hammer seeing everything come up nails, but as someone who covers the creator economy by day, I’ve noticed that the difference between influencers, creators, and journalists seems to shrink every time I look.
Reporting on not just Substack, but Patreon, Cameo, Twitch, and OnlyFans, I find myself struck more by the similarities than the distinctions between the entertainers, artists, digital professionals, influencers, and journalists who populate these platforms. Though we like to consider ourselves distinct by dent of our craft’s supposedly elevated calling, journalists are really just creators by a different name.
We all create content designed for consumption on the internet; we all cultivate a niche and then work to make ourselves indispensable to it; and we all make use of tools and platforms that turn our skill sets into revenue. Indeed, what Patreon has done for podcasters, OnlyFans for sex workers, Twitch for gamers, and Cameo for celebrities, Substack has done for writers.
And while the content might look different, the process is very much the same: Produce something valuable and charge people for access.
More than ever, it’s paywalls that do this charging, and their importance to this trend cannot be overstated. In the wake of a decimated digital advertising industry, and in the face of FAANG’s unassailable scale, creators have embraced a new(ish) method of monetization, the digital subscription. Thanks to this technology, “1,000 true fans” has been transformed from a koan into a business model. You no longer need a million views to turn a profit, just a couple dozen supporters.
This shift has revolutionized solo entrepreneurship, because subscriptions unleash the individual creator. So long as their expertise lies in some breed of digitally distributable content, these second-generation influencers can use the financial model to turn their side-hustle into a day job more easily than ever. This is as true for journalism as it is for any other field.
Substack and the other horsemen of the newsletter apocalypse have made this reality all too apparent, and in doing so have upended much of the media world. The siren song of Chris, Hamish, and Jairaj has been so irresistible that top writers have left pedigreed publications in droves to strike out alone on the platform.
The allure of bootstrapping a career in writing has even encouraged other, less naturally endowed newsletter-whisperers to give the creator economy a shot. Most of these amateur authors (yours truly included) have found only modest success on the platform, but a lucky few have managed to strike gold organically, cultivating a following through nothing more than sheer talent and an origin story that would bring a tear to Horatio Alger’s eyes.
This is bad and good for all the reasons you might imagine. It’s bad because many of the journalists finding success as creators are the same kinds of people who were finding success before: mostly white, mostly male, mostly affluent or well-connected. It’s good because the standard methods of gatekeeping no longer apply; as long as anyone can make a profit all by themselves, everyone can make a profit all by themselves.
So, given that this seems to be the emerging reality, we need to begin to prepare accordingly. What will journalism look like when its most influential practitioners prefer to go it alone? Who loses when publications are forced to vie with lone writers for eyeballs? What happens when the media unbundles so thoroughly that everyone competes with everyone for everyone’s attention?
It’s time to start asking these questions, because the foundation of the next decade of problems is being laid right now. The media can keep chasing its tail, going about the same routines and expecting different results, but perhaps it’s time to have a larger conversation about the system at a distance.
A for-profit model means everything comes at a price, including knowledge. As the people most engaged in parsing and parceling that knowledge, maybe it’s time journalists play a larger role in making sure this arrangement really works for everyone.
Mark Stenberg is a reporter for Business Insider and author of Medialyte.
Pablo Boczkowski Audiences have revolted. Will newsrooms adapt?
Patrick Butler Covid-19 reporting has prepared us for cross-border collaboration
Cory Bergman The year after a thousand earthquakes
Beena Raghavendran Journalism gets fused with art
Logan Jaffe History as a reporting tool
John Garrett A surprisingly good year
Matt Skibinski Misinformation won’t stop unless we stop it
Kerri Hoffman Protecting podcasting’s open ecosystem
Annie Rudd Newsrooms grow less comfortable with the “view from above”
Bo Hee Kim Newsrooms create an intentional and collaborative culture
Francesca Tripodi Don’t expect breaking up Google and Facebook to solve our information woes
Jim Friedlich A newspaper renaissance reached by stopping the presses
Marissa Evans Putting community trauma into context
M. Scott Havens Traditional pay TV will embrace the disruption
Nisha Chittal The year we stop pivoting
Ariane Bernard Going solo is still only a path for the few
Sue Cross A global consensus around the kind of news we need to save
Andrew Ramsammy Stop being polite and start getting real
Danielle C. Belton A decimated media rededicates itself to truth
Mariano Blejman It’s time to challenge autocompleted journalism
Taylor Lorenz Journalists will learn influencing isn’t easy
Errin Haines Let’s normalize women’s leadership
Ben Werdmuller The web blooms again
David Chavern Local video finally gets momentum
John Ketchum More journalists of color become newsroom founders
Rodney Gibbs Zooming beyond talking heads
Sonali Prasad Making disaster journalism that cuts through the noise
Jonas Kaiser Toward a wehrhafte journalism
Pia Frey Building growth through tastemakers and their communities
Doris Truong Indigenous issues get long-overdue mainstream coverage
Brian Moritz The year sports journalism changes for good
Mike Ananny Toward better tech journalism
Juleyka Lantigua The download, podcasting’s metric king, gets dethroned
Meredith D. Clark The year journalism starts paying reparations
Ernie Smith Entrepreneurship on rails
John Saroff Covid sparks the growth of independent local news sites
Victor Pickard The commercial era for local journalism is over
Sarah Stonbely Videoconferencing brings more geographic diversity
Masuma Ahuja We’ll remember how interconnected our world is
Laura E. Davis The focus turns to newsroom leaders for lasting change
Linda Solomon Wood Canada steps up for journalism
Matt DeRienzo Citizen truth brigades steer us back toward reality
Megan McCarthy Readers embrace a low-information diet
Tonya Mosley True equity means ownership
Francesco Zaffarano The year we ask the audience what it needs
Jennifer Brandel A sneak peak at power mapping, 2073’s top innovation
An Xiao Mina 2020 isn’t a black swan — it’s a yellow canary
Talmon Joseph Smith The media rejects deficit hawkery
Eric Nuzum Podcasting dodged a bullet in 2020, but 2021 will be harder
Imaeyen Ibanga Journalism gets unmasked
A.J. Bauer The year of MAGAcal thinking
Sarah Marshall The year audiences need extra cheer
Whitney Phillips Facts are an insufficient response to falsehoods
Jesse Holcomb Genre erosion in nonprofit journalism
Joni Deutsch Local arts and music make journalism more joyous
Delia Cai Subscriptions start working for the middle
Mandy Jenkins You build trust by helping your readers
Nonny de la Pena News reaches the third dimension
Tanya Cordrey Declining trust forces publishers to claim (or disclaim) values
Mark S. Luckie Newsrooms and streaming services get cozy
Richard Tofel Less on politics, more on how government works (or doesn’t)
Amara Aguilar Journalism schools emphasize listening
Garance Franke-Ruta Rebundling content, rebuilding connections
Jessica Clark News becomes plural
Gonzalo del Peon Collaborations expand from newsrooms to the business side
Nabiha Syed Newsrooms quit their toxic relationships
Kristen Muller Engaged journalism scales
Zainab Khan From understanding to feeling
Steve Henn Has independent podcasting peaked?
Celeste Headlee The rise of radical newsroom transparency
John Davidow Reflect and repent
Cindy Royal J-school grads maintain their optimism and adaptability
Candis Callison Calling it a crisis isn’t enough (if it ever was)
Chicas Poderosas More voices mean better information
Robert Hernandez Data and shame
Alyssa Zeisler Holistic medicine for journalism
Joshua P. Darr Legislatures will tackle the local news crisis
Samantha Ragland The year of journalists taking initiative
C.W. Anderson Journalism changed under Trump — will it keep changing under Biden?
Anthony Nadler Journalism struggles to find a new model of legitimacy
Kate Myers My son will join every Zoom call in our industry
Rachel Schallom The rise of nonprofit journalism continues
Mark Stenberg The rise of the journalist-influencer
Marie Shanahan Journalism schools stop perpetuating the status quo
Julia B. Chan and Kim Bui Millennials are ready to run things
Rishad Patel From direct-to-consumer to direct-to-believers
Marcus Mabry News orgs adapt to a post-Trump world (with Trump still in it)
Loretta Chao Open up the profession
Natalie Meade Journalism enters rehab
Mike Caulfield 2021’s misinformation will look a lot like 2020’s (and 2019’s, and…)
Charo Henríquez A new path to leadership
Colleen Shalby The definition of good journalism shifts
Jer Thorp Fewer pixels, more cardboard
Edward Roussel Tech companies get aggressive in local
Kawandeep Virdee Goodbye, doomscroll
Kevin D. Grant Parachute journalism goes away for good
Chase Davis The year we look beyond The Story
Jacqué Palmer The rise of the plain-text email newsletter
Ben Collins We need to learn how to talk to (and about) accidental conspiracists
Janet Haven and Sam Hinds Is this an AI newsroom?
Burt Herman Journalists build post-Facebook digital communities
María Sánchez Díez Traffic will plummet — and it’ll be ok
Hossein Derakhshan Mass personalization of truth
Shaydanay Urbani and Nancy Watzman Local collaboration is key to slowing misinformation
Nicholas Jackson Blogging is back, but better
Renée Kaplan Falling in love with your subscription
Sam Ford We’ll find better ways to archive our work
Gordon Crovitz Common law will finally apply to the Internet
Stefanie Murray and Anthony Advincula Expect to see more translations and non-English content
Nikki Usher Don’t expect an antitrust dividend for the media
Benjamin Toff Beltway reporting gets normal again, for better and for worse
Ariel Zirulnick Local newsrooms question their paywalls
Tamar Charney Public radio has a midlife crisis
Parker Molloy The press will risk elevating a Shadow President Trump
Sara M. Watson Return of the RSS reader
Moreno Cruz Osório In Brazil, a push for pluralism
Anna Nirmala Local news orgs grasp the urgency of community roots
Sumi Aggarwal News literacy programs aren’t child’s play
David Skok A pandemic-prompted wave of consolidation
Gabe Schneider Another year of empty promises on diversity
José Zamora Walking the talk on diversity
Nico Gendron Ask your readers to help build your products
Alfred Hermida and Oscar Westlund The virus ups data journalism’s game
Ashton Lattimore Remote work helps level the playing field in an insular industry
Joanne McNeil Newsrooms push back against Ivy League cronyism
Julia Angwin Show your (computational) work
Astead W. Herndon The Trump-sized window of the media caring about race closes again
Rick Berke Virtual events are here to stay
Christoph Mergerson Black Americans will demand more from journalism
Rasmus Kleis Nielsen Stop pretending publishers are a united front
Michael W. Wagner Fractured democracy, fractured journalism
Aaron Foley Diversity gains haven’t shown up in local news
J. Siguru Wahutu Journalists still wrongly think the U.S. is different
Don Day Business first, journalism second
Tim Carmody Spotify will make big waves in video
Alicia Bell and Simon Galperin Media reparations now
Heidi Tworek A year of news mocktails
Cherian George Enter the lamb warriors
Jeremy Gilbert Human-centered journalism
Catalina Albeanu Publish less, listen more
Ryan Kellett The bundle gets bundled
Bill Adair The future of fact-checking is all about structured data
Zizi Papacharissi The year we rebuild the infrastructure of truth
Ray Soto The news gets spatial
Jody Brannon People won’t renew
Ståle Grut Network analysis enters the journalism toolbox
Raney Aronson-Rath To get past information divides, we need to understand them first
Tauhid Chappell and Mike Rispoli Defund the crime beat
Rachel Glickhouse Journalists will be kinder to each other — and to themselves
Andrew Donohue The rise of the democracy beat
Jean Friedman-Rudovsky and Cassie Haynes A shift from conversation to action