2
0
1
9

The coming splintering of conservative media

“Without Trump as its lodestar, the conservative mediasphere is likely to experience a period of fragmentation as well — competition for right-wing audiences and clicks will foster ideological sorting as different sites will seek to establish their niches and advance these competing conservatisms.”

As the aphorism goes: Another year older, another year wiser, another year closer to death. The passage of time and the mercy of presidential term limits means that 2019 brings us closer to the end of the Trump era. The coming year will determine whether that era ends in a bang or a whimper.

Will Democratic control of the House and the ongoing Mueller investigation dovetail into real political consequences for Trump’s inglorious track record of graft and dissembling? While Republican control of the Senate makes impeachment and removal a pipe dream, 2019 will see an acceleration of new subpoenas, new disclosures, new investigations, and new convictions that may well change the political calculus within the Republican Party. The conditions may be ripe for a primary challenge — some ego-driven and principled conservative (Paul Ryan? John Kasich? Nikki Haley? Mike Pence?) will rise to confront Trump’s cult of personality.

What a conservative challenge to Trump looks like in 2019, and what a contested Republican primary looks like in 2020, would ultimately be determined by neither Trump nor the Republican Party.

Indeed, there’s an elephant in the Republican Party — and it’s not the one you think. If the Reagan presidency was the crowning achievement of the post-war conservative movement, the decades since have seen that movement eclipsed by a commercially viable conservative mediasphere with power and motivations all its own.

Its foundations were built by talk radio hosts like Rush Limbaugh beginning shortly after the Reagan FCC ended the “fairness doctrine” broadcast requirements in the late 1980s. By the mid-1990s, Fox News arrived on the scene, with its “fair and balanced” answer to putative liberal media hegemony. The past decade has seen a quickening of the conservative mediasphere, with proliferating online outlets — from Glenn Beck’s The Blaze, to Breitbart, to The Daily Caller — not to mention successful social media entrepreneurship of figures like Ben Shapiro and Tomi Lahren.

For its part, the Republican Party has largely avoided publicly acknowledging its subordinate status within the broader constellation of conservative media institutions. The 2012 Republican autopsy report, commissioned after Romney failed to defeat Obama, made no reference to any part of the right-wing mediasphere within whose constraints the party’s candidates are increasingly forced to operate. The report’s section on “Friends and Allies,” for example, describes pertinent third-party groups as consisting of “advocacy organization to think tanks to political action committees to SuperPACs or 501(c)(4) organizations” — no discussion of the increasingly outsized role played by outlets of conservative news and commentary.

Scholars and progressive media critics, on the other hand, have often depicted the conservative mediasphere as a powerful monolith. David Brock famously called it a “noise machine.” At the outset of their pathbreaking work on the conservative “echo chamber,” Kathleen Hall Jamieson and Joseph N. Cappella predicted that if the conservative media establishment of the time (Rush, Fox, and The Wall Street Journal opinion page) “were confronted by a serious Republican presidential contender whose proposals and past deviated from the Reagan doctrine, they would marshal against the candidacy.” At the time of publication, Mike Huckabee’s failed 2008 presidential run seemed to confirm their claims as conservative media challenged his bona fides. But by later that year, Fox had hired Huckabee, giving him a show of his own.

By the 2016 Republican primaries, the “echo chamber” seemed unable and unwilling to police Trump’s far more egregious deviations from the fusionist conservatism that Reagan embodied. The National Review’s attempt at launching a “Never Trump” movement quickly fizzled, while the more widely circulated (not to mention more paleoconservative and supportive of white nationalists) Breitbart threw its full support behind Trump’s candidacy. As Yochai Benkler, Robert Faris, and Hal Roberts have compellingly documented, by 2015 Breitbart had emerged as a crucial and influential node within the broader conservative mediasphere. The success of an ardent and widely shared pro-Trump site forced Fox News to guard its right flank.

The Trump presidency has resulted in further thematic, and to some extent ideological, consolidation within the conservative mediasphere around Trump and his policies. Fox has rebuilt its primetime lineup with Trump acolytes and apologists. Right-wing publisher MediaDC gave the ax to neoconservative The Weekly Standard while expanding the more Trump-loyalist Washington Examiner.

What happens to the conservative mediasphere when it loses its current center of gravity?

Trump has largely championed the ideas of long-beleaguered paleoconservatives, but neoliberal conservatives, libertarians, neoconservatives, and fusionists will all be vying to control the post-Trump Republican Party. Without Trump as its lodestar, the conservative mediasphere is likely to experience a period of fragmentation as well — competition for right-wing audiences and clicks will foster ideological sorting as different sites will seek to establish their niches and advance these competing conservatisms.

Of course, it’s also possible that some other conservative figure will quickly step in to fill the impending Trump power vacuum. Such a figure could stave off conservative mediasphere fragmentation a bit longer.

But even if that happens, media critics, journalists, and journalism scholars would be wise not to take a monolithic conservative mediasphere for granted — to acknowledge that unity of messaging among discrete conservative media outlets is historically contingent. The more we can learn about the political, ideological, and commercial imperatives that produce conditions of unanimity within the conservative mediasphere, the better we’ll understand its component parts, and the challenges it presents for professional journalism.

A.J. Bauer is a visiting assistant professor in the Department of Media, Culture and Communication at NYU.

John Garrett   You can’t raise prices forever

Kelsey Proud   Journalism becomes the escape

james Wahutu   Think 2018 was bad? Wait until you see 2019

Emma Carew Grovum   The year of the loyal reader

Bill Adair   Another year fighting Trump’s falsehoods

Heba Aly   The rise of international nonprofit news

Simon Galperin   After capitalism’s fire, journalism’s secondary succession

Ben Smith   The pendulum starts to swing back

Errin Haines Whack   Say it with me: Racism

Matthew Pressman   The battle over objectivity intensifies

Greg Emerson   Power to the user

Becca Aaronson   From bridge roles to product thinkers

Libby Bawcombe   Haikus of the news

Joshua Darr   The nationalization of political news will accelerate

Logan Molyneux   Seeing social media for what it is

Matt Karolian   Publishers come to terms with being Facebook’s enablers

Rick Berke   The year of loyalty

Frank Mungeam   Tonight at 11: News, sports, and climate change

Talia Stroud   Engaging people across lines of difference

Whitney Phillips   Our information systems aren’t broken — they’re working as intended

Laura E. Davis   More access, but not that kind

Rodney Gibbs   A bright — and young — year for audio

Efrat Nechushtai   Journalism wants to be your friend, not your teacher

Joe Amditis   Give the audience a seat at the table

Pia Frey   You can’t solve a crisis without treating it as a crisis

Peter Bale   Venture capital runs out of patience

Cătălina Albeanu   Being responsible for what we don’t know

Mike Caulfield   Ditch the media literacy cynicism and get to work

Mario García   The rise of content “pilots”

Alexandra Svokos   Good luck convincing us millennials to pay

Shalabh Upadhyay   A culture clash on India’s growing Internet

Cherian George   Fake news wins in Asia

Tushar Banerjee   Interactive ads will be the new face of display advertising

Craig Newmark   The end of “loudspeakers for liars”

Hossein Derakhshan   The news is dying, but journalism will not — and should not

Jenée Desmond-Harris   It finally sinks in that some people aren’t white

Axie Navas   The traffic hunt, CMS battle, and magazine identity crises loom

Mat Yurow   Content competition from the tech companies

Andrew Ramsammy   The great re-pivot to audio

M. Scott Havens   Time to swing for the fences

Kainaz Amaria   We consider who’s behind the camera

Celeste LeCompte   Local news needs local conversation to survive

Lauren Katz   Community becomes a core newsroom value

Rebecca Lee Sanchez   We are all actors in the running rampant of political theater

Betsy O'Donovan and Melody Kramer   The most beautiful sentence in 2019 is “No.”

Andrea Faye Hart   Doing less harm, not just more good

Steve Henn   Smart speakers get smarter

Heather Chaplin   Agree we’re partisan — for the democratic system

Seth C. Lewis   The gap between journalism and research is too wide

Jeff Chin   We detox from Chartbeat

Seema Yasmin   We will create our own spaces

Jack Riley   Facebook refugees, from ad revenue to news habits

Robin Kwong   Tech shouldn’t be the only field pollinating “news nerds”

Kawandeep Virdee   Media wants to take care of you

Elizabeth Jensen   Going where the Acela can’t take you

Steve Grove   A reckoning for tech’s work with news

Mandy Velez   Putting the social back in social media

Annie Rudd   A more intimate aesthetic of politics — on Insta

Michael Rain   The year of the culturally relevant curator

Simon Rogers   Data journalism becomes a global field

Moreno Cruz Osório   Damaged credibility and a new threat in Brazil

Sarah Alvarez   Simplify and redistribute

Carolina Guerrero   Spanish-language audio blows up

Brian Moritz   The subscription-pocalypse is about to hit

Nicholas Jackson   More transparency around newsroom decisions

Frank Chimero   Leave the phone at home and put news on your wrist

Tshepo Tshabalala   Ahead of African elections, unlock partnerships with fact-checkers

Mandy Jenkins   Fight the urge to run away from social media

Manoush Zomorodi   Tech will do for information overload what it did for mindfulness

Robert Hernandez   Racists and sexists get replaced

Nico Gendron   Reaching Generation Z beyond the coasts

Nisha Chittal   The homepage makes a comeback

Patrick Butler   Measuring impact will increase audience trust

Mariana Moura Santos   From pageviews to impact

Stephanie Edgerly   It’s time to understand the un-audience

An Xiao Mina   The death of consensus, not the death of truth

Pablo Boczkowski   Reimagining the media for post-institutional times

Dave Burdick   Seeing our blind spots

Millie Tran   There is no magic — you’ve got this

Monique Judge   Committing to the truth, calling out lies

Gabriel Snyder   Journalism doesn’t fit well in a funnel

Rebecca Searles   From silos to Swiss Army knife teams

Zuzanna Ziomecka   News leadership gets an overdue upgrade

Alyssa Zeisler   We expand what (and how and who) we serve

Elisabeth Goodridge   Yes, they signed up — but our job’s not over

Michael Grant   More newsrooms experiment their way to success

Juleyka Lantigua-Williams   Podcasting battles East Coast bias

Eric Ulken   The year you actually start to like your CMS

Mike Isaac   The old exit doors for digital media companies are closing

Ben Werdmuller   The platform tide is turning

Joanne McNeil   Building a digital hospice

Winny de Jong   Data journalism goes undercover

Nathalie Malinarich   Video — yes, video

Alexandra Borchardt   Newsrooms need to build trust with their journalists, not just the audience

Jennifer Dargan   You don’t build diversity through one-off training sessions

Sarah Marshall   A return to destination journalism

Sue Robinson   Reporters go on the offensive

P. Kim Bui   The misfits become the bosses

Francesco Marconi   The year of iterative journalism

Hearken   Pivot to people

Knight Foundation   A year of local collaboration

Amy King   We should listen to the kids (especially on Instagram)

Elizabeth Dunbar   Local reporters reflect on what’s not important

Jesse Holcomb   We’ll get better at making the case for local journalism

Tim Carmody   Unlocking the commons

Charo Henríquez   Pivot to journalism

Matt Waite   “I went to Node.js because I wished to live deliberately”

Matt Skibinski   Quality and reliability are the new currencies for publishers

Johannes Klingebiel   We all grow hooves

Colleen Shalby   Representation becomes more than a talking point

Justin Kosslyn   Text hits a tipping point

Jim Friedlich   Meet Citizen Kane 2.0

Gideon Lichfield   Goodbye attention economy, we’ll miss you

Dan Shanoff   Bet on sports gambling

Taylor Lorenz   Personal branding is more powerful than ever

Rachel Glickhouse   Newsrooms will prioritize audience needs

Masuma Ahuja   Make foreign coverage less foreign

John Saroff   The pivot to reader revenue’s unintended consequences

Reyhan Harmanci   Selling more stories to Hollywood

Jake Shapiro   Podcasting is media’s slow food movement

Victor Pickard   We will finally confront systemic market failure

Elite Truong   What do we owe the next generation?

Callie Schweitzer   The rise of the conveners

Candis Callison   Learn from Indigenous journalists on covering climate change

Darryl Holliday   Let’s talk about power (yours)

Meredith Artley   Huge demand for…anything but politics

Angèle Christin   Algorithms and the reflexive turn

A.J. Bauer   The coming splintering of conservative media

Ernie Smith   The year we step back from the platform

Sue Cross   Return of the water cooler

Shannon McGregor   More bogus embedded tweets in our stories

Julia Rubin   Meeting people where they are

Jonathan Stray   More algorithmic accountability reporting, and a lot of it will be meh

Alberto Cairo   A year of uncertainty and confidence

Heather Bryant   We are responsible for how we use our power

Rasmus Kleis Nielsen   A long, slow slog, with no one coming to the rescue

Tyler Fisher   This is journalism’s do-or-die moment

Peter Cunliffe-Jones   The focus of misinformation debates shifts south

Angilee Shah   The year news orgs say “yes” to real leaders

Elizabeth Bramson-Boudreau   A more sincere definition of “community”

Glyn Mottershead and Martin Chorley   When a tech company pulls the plug on your story

Ruth Palmer and Benjamin Toff   From news fatigue to news avoidance

Soo Oh   Just showing our work isn’t enough

Raney Aronson-Rath   We learn “digital” doesn’t have to mean “short”

Jared Newman   AI-generated fakes launch a software arms race

Eric Nuzum   The year of the DIY podcast network

Adam Thomas   In Europe, foundations invest in news

Ariel Zirulnick   Participation gets professional

Jonathan Gill   Publishers build a common tech platform together

Bill Grueskin   Toward a symphony model for local news

LaToya Drake   Listen up: New stories, new storytellers

Stefanie Murray   Local news wakes up and starts collaborating

Joel Konopo   Influencers become the new liberated power in Africa

Salem Solomon   Correcting our corrections

Andrew Donohue   Voting rights becomes the new climate change

Francesco Zaffarano   Towards a rethinking of journalism on social media

Steve Myers   From trying to cover it all to covering what matters

Kevin Douglas Grant   A year to embrace journalism as public service

Chase Davis   We can acknowledge what we don’t know

Jesse Brown   Canada’s subsidy for news backfires

Julie Posetti   The year of the fight back

Sarah Stonbely   Mapping the local news ecosystem — with scale but detail

Jonas Kaiser   Catching up with “Neuland”

Ståle Grut   A new dawn for 3D tech in journalism

Josh Schwartz   A pullback from platforms and a focus on product

John Biewen   Podcasts keep getting better

Umbreen Bhatti   The story doesn’t end for the people we quote

Kristen Muller   Local news fails — in a good way

Renan Borelli   Developing loyalty means developing your talent

Christa Scharfenberg and Vickie Baranetsky   The year of the lawsuit

Nikki Usher   Three ways national media will further undermine trust

Linda Solomon Wood   The year of the climate reporter

Adam B. Ellick   Video forensic reporting goes mainstream — and local

Ernst-Jan Pfauth   Readers are only getting started

Kjerstin Thorson   Time to get mad about information inequality (again)

Almar Latour   Reported facts, weaponized in service of action

Thomas Hanitzsch   The rise of tribal journalism

Rachel Davis Mersey   Local news goes minimalist

Cindy Royal   For journalism curriculum to change, its faculty needs disruption

Ole Reißmann   The rise of vertical storytelling

Tamar Charney   Seriously: What do you do for people?

Rubina Madan Fillion   Fighting the reality of deepfakes

Geetika Rudra   The year of actionable (local) journalism

Adam Smith   Platforms will have to help rebuild trust in news

Rishad Patel   A design system for responsible publishing

Kate Myers   Journalism continues to be bad for democracy

Jean Friedman Rudovsky   Cross-newsroom collaborations strengthen communities

Jeremy Gilbert   AI finally becomes helpful

Renée Kaplan   Our future could lie within our own organizations

Cory Bergman   Journalism as a technology service

Carl Bialik   Fatigued news consumers will pay more for less news

Zizi Papacharissi   Old interface, say hello to the new interface

Mike Rispoli and Craig Aaron   Government funds local news — and that’s a good thing

Carrie Brown-Smith   Advocating a healthy civic life is no journalistic crime

Amy Schmitz Weiss   Local news isn’t where you thought it was

Claire Wardle   Forget deepfakes: Misinformation is showing up in our most personal online spaces

Kyra Darnton   A shift to depth in video

Don Day   Timewalls and other reader revenue experiments

Alexis Lloyd & Matt Boggie   The year product leads media

Dheerja Kaur   A focus on problems, not platforms

Zainab Khan   Publishers whose products can stand up to social media giants will win

Elva Ramirez   News — but make it cinematic

Marie Shanahan   Newsrooms take the comments sections back from platforms

Borja Bergareche Sainz de los Terreros   Entering a more balanced era

Cristi Hegranes   A year to invest in the security of local journalists