The year journalism and capitalism finally divorce

“It is capitalism that incentivizes the degradation of our news media — disinvesting in local journalism, weaponizing social media to capture our attention and data, and devaluing media workers’ labor conditions.”

2023 is the year that journalism and capitalism finally break up. Their relationship has always been fraught, but now it’s turned toxic — culminating in a messy dissolution as the retreating market hollows out newsrooms, leaving millions of Americans bereft of local news.

Virtually the only for-profit firms still interested in the local news business are the hedge-fund vultures, like Alden Global Capital, that pounce on dying newspapers to profit from their scraps. Meanwhile, all manner of media organizations — CNN, Twitter, Meta, Gannett and BuzzFeed — are laying off significant numbers of workers. Others, like The New York Times and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, are trying to discipline their workforce into submission by refusing to bargain in good faith on fair labor conditions.

To make sense of the news industry’s wild fluctuations, we often turn to cultural explanations about the evolving tastes of audiences, or point to technological disruptions, or indict the misdeeds of individual media owners such as Elon Musk and Rupert Murdoch. But one key culprit almost always eludes scrutiny: capitalism.

It is capitalism that incentivizes the degradation of our news media — disinvesting in local journalism, weaponizing social media to capture our attention and data, and devaluing media workers’ labor conditions. All the while, commercial media outlets treat news as a commodity, not a public service, and audiences as consumers, not engaged citizens.

Much of what we decry in our media is symptomatic of the underlying capitalist imperative to maximize profit above all else, social costs be damned. Deprived of a structural analysis of the American media system, the easiest villains for critics to pinpoint are the billionaire bad boys, the latter-day press barons who do nefarious things. But they’re epiphenomenal of a deeper structural pathology. Namely, a media system founded on unregulated, oligopolistic, hyper-commercialized corporations. Such a pay-to-play system is always vulnerable to capture by oligarchs who turn media outlets into their personal playthings.

Capitalist logics wire our news media to behave in antisocial ways, from exploiting news workers to privileging some audiences (whiter, wealthier) over others. Various forms of redlining and market censorship — patterns of exclusion and bias — are baked into the system. By now, it should be commonsensical that the interests of profit-driven media firms and democratic societies will never fully align. Nor can the market entirely support public goods. Yet, we too often act as if it will.

Despite glaringly obvious market failures, can we even imagine what a post-commercial media system might look like? This prospect is especially daunting in the US where Americans have been socialized for many decades to believe there’s no alternative to the neoliberal paradigm. We’re entrenched within the trap of capitalist realism: The market seems as natural as gravity, and thinking beyond its confines is nearly impossible.

But glimmers of alternative models glint at us from the wreckage of our media landscape. The nonprofit sector continues to grow, labor activism in media industries continues to swell, and mergers between public broadcasting and print outlets are forming the basis of a new quasi-public media sector. An increasing number of state-level initiatives to subsidize local media production also give hope.

But bolder actions are necessary. We can try cobbling together a flotilla of public spaces and infrastructures — think libraries, post offices, public access cable outlets, and public broadcasting stations — or we can build something entirely new. My own preference is to build new anchor institutions — what I call public media centers — in every community. Inspired by the early 2000s Indymedia movement, these publicly financed news cooperatives could not only guarantee a baseline level of news media for all members of society but also empower local communities to govern their own newsrooms and tell their own stories.

Regardless of means, the ultimate objective is crystal clear: We must protect public goods like journalism from commercial depredations to preserve the material conditions necessary for democracy. Of course, a post-capitalist media system won’t manifest overnight, and some for-profit news media will persist and perhaps even flourish. But the public and nonprofit media sectors must ultimately provide for the balance of our information and communication needs.

At various points in history, both in the United States and around the world, there has been greater awareness of capitalism’s systemic limitations in supporting the news media that democracy requires. After decades of market fundamentalism, this critical consciousness has been largely beaten out of the discourse. Recovering this critique and sundering journalism from capitalism is the first step toward building a post-commercial system that privileges democracy over profit.

Victor Pickard is the C. Edwin Baker Professor of Media Policy and Political Economy at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication.

2023 is the year that journalism and capitalism finally break up. Their relationship has always been fraught, but now it’s turned toxic — culminating in a messy dissolution as the retreating market hollows out newsrooms, leaving millions of Americans bereft of local news.

Virtually the only for-profit firms still interested in the local news business are the hedge-fund vultures, like Alden Global Capital, that pounce on dying newspapers to profit from their scraps. Meanwhile, all manner of media organizations — CNN, Twitter, Meta, Gannett and BuzzFeed — are laying off significant numbers of workers. Others, like The New York Times and Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, are trying to discipline their workforce into submission by refusing to bargain in good faith on fair labor conditions.

To make sense of the news industry’s wild fluctuations, we often turn to cultural explanations about the evolving tastes of audiences, or point to technological disruptions, or indict the misdeeds of individual media owners such as Elon Musk and Rupert Murdoch. But one key culprit almost always eludes scrutiny: capitalism.

It is capitalism that incentivizes the degradation of our news media — disinvesting in local journalism, weaponizing social media to capture our attention and data, and devaluing media workers’ labor conditions. All the while, commercial media outlets treat news as a commodity, not a public service, and audiences as consumers, not engaged citizens.

Much of what we decry in our media is symptomatic of the underlying capitalist imperative to maximize profit above all else, social costs be damned. Deprived of a structural analysis of the American media system, the easiest villains for critics to pinpoint are the billionaire bad boys, the latter-day press barons who do nefarious things. But they’re epiphenomenal of a deeper structural pathology. Namely, a media system founded on unregulated, oligopolistic, hyper-commercialized corporations. Such a pay-to-play system is always vulnerable to capture by oligarchs who turn media outlets into their personal playthings.

Capitalist logics wire our news media to behave in antisocial ways, from exploiting news workers to privileging some audiences (whiter, wealthier) over others. Various forms of redlining and market censorship — patterns of exclusion and bias — are baked into the system. By now, it should be commonsensical that the interests of profit-driven media firms and democratic societies will never fully align. Nor can the market entirely support public goods. Yet, we too often act as if it will.

Despite glaringly obvious market failures, can we even imagine what a post-commercial media system might look like? This prospect is especially daunting in the US where Americans have been socialized for many decades to believe there’s no alternative to the neoliberal paradigm. We’re entrenched within the trap of capitalist realism: The market seems as natural as gravity, and thinking beyond its confines is nearly impossible.

But glimmers of alternative models glint at us from the wreckage of our media landscape. The nonprofit sector continues to grow, labor activism in media industries continues to swell, and mergers between public broadcasting and print outlets are forming the basis of a new quasi-public media sector. An increasing number of state-level initiatives to subsidize local media production also give hope.

But bolder actions are necessary. We can try cobbling together a flotilla of public spaces and infrastructures — think libraries, post offices, public access cable outlets, and public broadcasting stations — or we can build something entirely new. My own preference is to build new anchor institutions — what I call public media centers — in every community. Inspired by the early 2000s Indymedia movement, these publicly financed news cooperatives could not only guarantee a baseline level of news media for all members of society but also empower local communities to govern their own newsrooms and tell their own stories.

Regardless of means, the ultimate objective is crystal clear: We must protect public goods like journalism from commercial depredations to preserve the material conditions necessary for democracy. Of course, a post-capitalist media system won’t manifest overnight, and some for-profit news media will persist and perhaps even flourish. But the public and nonprofit media sectors must ultimately provide for the balance of our information and communication needs.

At various points in history, both in the United States and around the world, there has been greater awareness of capitalism’s systemic limitations in supporting the news media that democracy requires. After decades of market fundamentalism, this critical consciousness has been largely beaten out of the discourse. Recovering this critique and sundering journalism from capitalism is the first step toward building a post-commercial system that privileges democracy over profit.

Victor Pickard is the C. Edwin Baker Professor of Media Policy and Political Economy at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication.

Jakob Moll   Journalism startups will think beyond English

Anika Anand   Independent news businesses lead the way on healthy work cultures

Tim Carmody   Newsletter writers need a new ethics

Molly de Aguiar and Mandy Van Deven   Narrative change trend brings new money to journalism

Sarabeth Berman   Nonprofit local news shows that it can scale

Nicholas Thompson   The year AI actually changes the media business

Nicholas Jackson   There will be launches — and we’ll keep doing the work

Jim Friedlich   Local journalism steps up to the challenge of civic coverage

Kirstin McCudden   We’ll codify protection of journalism and newsgathering

Karina Montoya   More reporters on the antitrust beat

Ariel Zirulnick   Journalism doubles down on user needs

Michael W. Wagner   The backlash against pro-democracy reporting is coming

Cory Bergman   The AI content flood

Joni Deutsch   Podcast collaboration — not competition — breeds excellence

Julia Beizer   News fatigue shows us a clear path forward

Amy Schmitz Weiss   Journalism education faces a crossroads

Zizi Papacharissi   Platforms are over

Mariana Moura Santos   A woman who speaks is a woman who changes the world

Burt Herman   The year AI truly arrives — and with it the reckoning

Jenna Weiss-Berman   The economic downturn benefits the podcasting industry. (No, really!)

Basile Simon   Towards supporting criminal accountability

Eric Nuzum   A focus on people instead of power

Nikki Usher   This is the year of the RSS reader. (Really!)

Masuma Ahuja   Journalism starts working for and with its communities

S. Mitra Kalita   “Everything sucks. Good luck to you.”

Anita Varma   Journalism prioritizes the basic need for survival

Eric Thurm   Journalists think of themselves as workers

Sarah Marshall   A web channel strategy won’t be enough

Laxmi Parthasarathy   Unlocking the silent demand for international journalism

Sue Cross   Thinking and acting collectively to save the news

Stefanie Murray   The year U.S. media stops screwing around and becomes pro-democracy

Sam Gregory   Synthetic media forces us to understand how media gets made

Bill Grueskin   Local news will come to rely on AI

Susan Chira   Equipping local journalism

Andrew Donohue   We’ll find out whether journalism can, indeed, save democracy

Paul Cheung   More news organizations will realize they are in the business of impact, not eyeballs

Moreno Cruz Osório   Brazilian journalism turns wounds into action

Laura E. Davis   The year we embrace the robots — and ourselves

Christoph Mergerson   The rot at the core of the news business

Jennifer Choi and Jonathan Jackson   Funders finally bet on next-generation news entrepreneurs

Michael Schudson   Journalism gets more and more difficult

John Davidow   A year of intergenerational learning

Sarah Alvarez   Dream bigger or lose out

Joe Amditis   AI throws a lifeline to local publishers

Jacob L. Nelson   Despite it all, people will still want to be journalists

Ayala Panievsky   It’s time for PR for journalism

Delano Massey   The industry shakes its imposter syndrome

Alex Sujong Laughlin   Credit where it’s due

Dominic-Madori Davis   Everyone finally realizes the need for diverse voices in tech reporting

Francesco Zaffarano   There is no end of “social media”

Snigdha Sur   Newsrooms get nimble in a recession

Tre'vell Anderson   Continued culpability in anti-trans campaigns

Khushbu Shah   Global reporting will suffer

Doris Truong   Workers demand to be paid what the job is worth

Ståle Grut   Your newsroom experiences a Midjourney-gate, too

Richard Tofel   The press might get better at vetting presidential candidates

Sam Guzik   AI will start fact-checking. We may not like the results.

Priyanjana Bengani   Partisan local news networks will collaborate

Joanne McNeil   Facebook and the media kiss and make up

Johannes Klingebiel   The innovation team, R.I.P.

Jim VandeHei   There is no “peak newsletter”

Ryan Kellett   Airline-like loyalty programs try to tie down news readers

Eric Ulken   Generative AI brings wrongness at scale

Gina Chua   The traditional story structure gets deconstructed

Victor Pickard   The year journalism and capitalism finally divorce

Jody Brannon   We’ll embrace policy remedies

Megan Lucero and Shirish Kulkarni   The future of journalism is not you

Elite Truong   In platform collapse, an opportunity for community

Jennifer Brandel   AI couldn’t care less. Journalists will care more. 

Emily Nonko   Incarcerated reporters get more bylines

Bill Adair   The year of the fact-check (no, really!)

Hillary Frey   Death to the labor-intensive memo for prospective hires

Cari Nazeer and Emily Goligoski   News organizations step up their support for caregivers

Wilson Liévano   Diaspora journalism takes the next step

Shanté Cosme   The answer to “quiet quitting” is radical empathy

Lisa Heyamoto   The independent news industry gets a roadmap to sustainability

Juleyka Lantigua   Newsrooms recognize women of color as the canaries in the coal mine

Gabe Schneider   Well-funded journalism leaders stop making disparate pay

Kavya Sukumar   Belling the cat: The rise of independent fact-checking at scale

Cindy Royal   Yes, journalists should learn to code, but…

Barbara Raab   More journalism funders will take more risks

Pia Frey   Publishers start polling their users at scale

Kathy Lu   We need emotionally agile newsroom leaders

Taylor Lorenz   The “creator economy” will be astroturfed

Sumi Aggarwal   Smart newsrooms will prioritize board development

Daniel Trielli   Trust in news will continue to fall. Just look at Brazil.

Ben Werdmuller   The internet is up for grabs again

Don Day   The news about the news is bad. I’m optimistic.

Rodney Gibbs   Recalibrating how we work apart

Matt Rasnic   More newsroom workers turn to organized labor

Peter Sterne   AI enters the newsroom

Janet Haven   ChatGPT and the future of trust 

Esther Kezia Thorpe   Subscription pressures force product innovation

Kaitlin C. Miller   Harassment in journalism won’t get better, but we’ll talk about it more openly

Amethyst J. Davis   The slight of the great contraction

Leezel Tanglao   Community partnerships drive better reporting

Dana Lacey   Tech will screw publishers over

Andrew Losowsky   Journalism realizes the replacement for Twitter is not a new Twitter

Walter Frick   Journalists wake up to the power of prediction markets

Jarrad Henderson   Video editing will help people understand the media they consume

Anna Nirmala   News organizations get new structures

Sarah Stonbely   Growth in public funding for news and information at the state and local levels

Janelle Salanga   Journalists work from a place of harm reduction

Sue Robinson   Engagement journalism will have to confront a tougher reality

Simon Galperin   Philanthropy stops investing in corporate media

Kaitlyn Wells   We’ll prioritize media literacy for children

Julia Angwin   Democracies will get serious about saving journalism

Alexandra Borchardt   The year of the climate journalism strategy

Errin Haines   Journalists on the campaign trail mend trust with the public

Anthony Nadler   Confronting media gerrymandering

Jonas Kaiser   Rejecting the “free speech” frame

Brian Moritz   Rebuilding the news bundle

Tamar Charney   Flux is the new stability

Felicitas Carrique and Becca Aaronson   News product goes from trend to standard

Jessica Clark   Open discourse retrenches

David Skok   Renewed interest in human-powered reporting

Jesse Holcomb   Buffeted, whipped, bullied, pulled

Al Lucca   Digital news design gets interesting again

Jessica Maddox   Journalists keep getting manipulated by internet culture

Alex Perry   New paths to transparency without Twitter

Nicholas Diakopoulos   Journalists productively harness generative AI tools

David Cohn   AI made this prediction

Martina Efeyini   Talk to Gen Z. They’re the experts of Gen Z.

Gordon Crovitz   The year advertisers stop funding misinformation

Cassandra Etienne   Local news fellowships will help fight newsroom inequities

Eric Holthaus   As social media fragments, marginalized voices gain more power

Mar Cabra   The inevitable mental health revolution

Parker Molloy   We’ll reach new heights of moral panic

A.J. Bauer   Covering the right wrong

Alexandra Svokos   Working harder to reach audiences where they are

Brian Stelter   Finding new ways to reach news avoiders

Mario García   More newsrooms go mobile-first

Elizabeth Bramson-Boudreau   More of the same

Peter Bale   Rising costs force more digital innovation

Josh Schwartz   The AI spammers are coming

Sue Schardt   Toward a new poetics of journalism

Mael Vallejo   More threats to press freedom across the Americas

AX Mina   Journalism in a time of permacrisis

Kerri Hoffman   Podcasting goes local

Valérie Bélair-Gagnon   Well-being will become a core tenet of journalism

Raney Aronson-Rath   Journalists will band together to fight intimidation

Emma Carew Grovum   The year to resist forgetting about diversity

Ryan Gantz   “I’m sorry, but I’m a large language model”

Surya Mattu   Data journalists learn from photojournalists

Upasna Gautam   Technology that performs at the speed of news

Joshua P. Darr   Local to live, wire to wither

Ryan Nave   Citizen journalism, but make it equitable

Rachel Glickhouse   Humanizing newsrooms will be a badge of honor

Mary Walter-Brown and Tristan Loper   Mission-driven metrics become our North Star

Jaden Amos   TikTok personality journalists continue to rise

Christina Shih   Shared values move from nice-to-haves to essentials

Mauricio Cabrera   It’s no longer about audiences, it’s about communities

Danielle K. Brown and Kathleen Searles   DEI efforts must consider mental health and online abuse

J. Siguru Wahutu   American journalism reckons with its colonialist tendencies

Larry Ryckman   We’ll work together with our competitors

Alan Henry   A reckoning with why trust in news is so low

Dannagal G. Young   Stop rewarding elite performances of identity threat